So let's get this straight: Innovation is:
4G like every other phone out there now?
NFC, like every other phone out there now?
There's nothing wrong with liking a small screen. There's something wrong with saying Apple can hold out because giving us a better product that we want is stupid.
Its like the people who criticize the iPad mini idea. I think Apple will release it. If you don't like it, stop commenting that its a bad idea. To be honest, I don't see the point in the product, but I'm simply not buying it. Don't like an iPhone with a larger display? Stick to a 4S. If you want one with a larger display that's not available? Buy an iPhone. Easy solution.
A big, high res screen will bring out the innovations in the phone though. But by this point I can't think of ANY innovation Apple's doing, at least, not since the iPhone 3G.
I'm not sure what point you're trying to make or, in fact, what it is I've said you're responding to. I'm not saying what people should or shouldn't want. How should I know what anyone else wants?