Pity that you almost certainly wouldn't be allowed to release the app to the store in the event of the BBC really not bothering. I won't be getting a new TV, I have no use for one any more having so many other options that provide the content I need, but good work on the app. Really does show up a huge corporation like the BBC.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Developers Press BBC to Bring iPlayer to Apple TV by Building Their Own Proof of Concept App
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Pity that you almost certainly wouldn't be allowed to release the app to the store in the event of the BBC really not bothering. I won't be getting a new TV, I have no use for one any more having so many other options that provide the content I need, but good work on the app. Really does show up a huge corporation like the BBC.
Seeing as you've just said they have an iOS app, and they have an OSX app, it doesn't sound like any such thing.
It sounds as though there is some reason specific to ATV - maybe technical, maybe small numbers using it compared to other platforms.
then don't watch it
duh
on the other hand, if you want to watch some high quality (amongst the increasing amount of dross) advert free content, pay for it, it's not as if a license fee is expensive
duh
either way, you're not making yourself look like a towering intellect
Last edited:
I agree with the point about the small number of people with ATV, but no other means to stream iPlayer.
But global rights can't be an issue - there are several ATV services that are US only. We won't be getting HBO Go in the UK for example.
But we'll almost certainly get the icon for it just to rub it in we have zero outside content for our boxes
At one stage they did have global iplayer which was popular in Australia , a paid service. Though the problem you face is rights and liscenced content in different territories. You will never get a proper iplayer experience outside of Uk
W1A is so close to the true, you would swear it was recorded live at times.
Last edited by a moderator:
The BBC are definitely at fault, and for nonsensical reasons. They gave a pretty weak excuse for why they wouldn't develop one for the current ATV despite the high demand while simultaneously developing one for the chrome cast.
http://www.imore.com/bbc-comes-clean-why-theres-no-iplayer-apple-tv
The BBC is 100% totally, utterly at fault, and for a reason they're not telling us, because their stated reason is male cow excrement.
If I get one it'll be for the same reason I always buy Apple products - simply the best user interface. Once it has all the apps I need I have little doubt it'll be the best way to access them.
Yep, definitely bull poo. Just because something is a limited market doesn't mean you shouldn't do it. The new Samsung TVs changed their OS this year to Tizen which would have requireda rewrite or a port of their existing app. There was a BBC iPlayer app very quickly on them.
However, my TV has been almost unused for well over a year now. Just sits there for when I need to AirPlay something. I have a FireTV for my bedroom TV that knocks spots off the TV for functionality and content and I have Netflix, Plex and Amazon Prime Video available directly on main my TV and two of those apps provide 4K content. Can't see me ever getting an TV again if I'm honest.
No argument here! I don't even have a cable subscription. I get all my stuff from live streams and primewire
You just stated the reason yourself, the truth is Apple TV is not a hit in the us, and certainly not a hit in the uk. Developing an app means they need to hire developers for Apple TV and support it, it simply might not be worth it
Samsung is the world's #1 tv manufacturer, so if they change of course I player will change
I want BBC make iPlayer app Apple TV. I keep see just AirPlay comment. That useless for me cos if AirPlay there no subtitles. Can only watch on iPad or iPhone or Mac but can't AirPlay Apple TV. If BBC finally make app then I finally can watch on TV.
Apple fan boys I'm used to but a BBC fanboy - I like it.
Mostly agree - there are some great programmes but the level of utter drivel is on the increase - Mountain Goats (a Scottish sit com so bad I cried) and From Darkness (yet another check list based piece of crap - troubled cop with a past / an unsolved murder / did they shag / what about the kids / oh that senior cop seems dodgy / haunting music / staring at shoes a lot / needless long journeys). You also forgot that all the presenters are now bleeding heart apologists - if someone so much as farts on a live show the presenters are contractually obliged to halt whatever is being discussed to apologise in case anyone was offended - then it requires a continuity announcer at the end of the show to give a number in case anyone was affected by the fart. And don't start me on Radio presenters, nothing short of driving rusty meathooks through their craniums would shut some of them up - "thank you caller for getting halfway through this incredibly touching piece on domestic violence but I need to cut you off as there might be a wicket at the cricket that our listeners could not possible wait an extra ten seconds to hear about'
Yep for every 'Mighty Bush' there was a 'F*$k off I'm a Hairy Woman' and for every David Attenborough there's a Nicky Campbell
companies have limited budgets and resources . Do you think the BBC would jump at apples announcement and find budget from nowhere to develop an app? No that's not how the real world works.
Apple also shares the blame for dragging it feet with the ATV for so long . Why would BBC support a device which Apple considers a hobby device. I'm sure when apple takes the ATV as a serious stream , so will the others.
Most people I know ditched thier ATVs, cause the other offerings on the market were far superior.
There was a subscription-based Global iPlayer app for iOS for a couple of years, with a mix of (some) current and (mostly) archive BBC content. It was killed off this year.
Change your user agent to iPad on your desktop browser - that forces html5 and no flash.
There is also a beta for html5 on some browsers you can try without user agent fudgery.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/internet/entries/19d875b8-c966-465b-880a-e38c71900c4c
Has anyone mentioned BBC iPlayer works fine if you just stream it from your iPhone/iPad to the Apple TV using Airplay.
The BBC have always been weird with iPlayer though. It is available on Sky, but is massively cut down.
The BBC have always been weird with iPlayer though. It is available on Sky, but is massively cut down.
Not up to the BBC to do that, it would be part of the Charter that the Government draws for funding and conduct of the BBC.
With people moving from traditional linear TV, it seems logical that a subscription model will be inevitable, but not for a few years.
It took two developers 9 hours to code a prototype and the current iPlayer on iOS is going to share a large amount of source code with any hypothetical new ATV app.
The reason the BBC stated that there was no app currently wasn't because of a lack of resources (they have a full iOS dev team, for example) but because the ATV "only works with one device" (?? I do not know what they mean here - only one TV? Only one computer? Only one remote?) yet somehow the Chromecast wasn't subject to these restrictions.
The new Apple TV runs iOS so not supporting it is an active decision to avoid it, since if you have an app on the iPad (which they do), having an app on the Apple TV will be comparatively little work, especially a content consumption app like iPlayer.