Whoops, I meant to say I dislike 26. My M4 and A18 Pro devices ran flawlessly on 18 and Sequoia, even better than current gen models on 26. It's pretty annoying to have a brand new MacBook Pro that get's laggy quite often. I don't know how much you've used Tahoe, but it's not a buttery smooth experience.
Yeah, 26 is not good. I luckily haven’t used it (iOS and iPadOS 18 on a 16 Plus and 11th-gen iPad (A16)), but there are overwhelming reports of a 20% battery life impact on the devices and some moderate performance issues. And the new models don’t correct this, like you said.
But the worst part is for those devices that can’t even try 27. 2018 iPad Pro, iPad Air 3, etc. Those devices, if their owners updated them to 26, are just gone.
And that’s the worst part: Apple’s hardware is great! Hardware-wise, their devices are of great quality, and extremely long-lasting.
Even if compatibility collapses, you can always find a use case for them. I use my iPhone 6s on iOS 10 for music, and my 9.7-inch iPad Pro on iOS 12 works for 3 out of the 4 streaming services I have. MacRumors Forums works on both. I’m typing this on my 16 Plus on iOS 18, but I could type it almost anywhere.
But my needs aren’t massive, really, and I realistically need one iPhone and one iPad with enough compatibility. The rest can all be very behind.
I do think people update anything without thinking and for no reason at all. Like you said, 26 is poor even on current devices. Do you really need to update a 2018 iPad Pro to it? If you update this device you’ve probably always updated it, what difference does having 18 make? None at all.
And OP’s point is true I think, but now, with years of experience using iOS, people really can’t at least stay behind with the oldest devices? Why not? What do those users gain by updating and then complaining that their devices are awful?
I kind of get it if you update an M4 iPad Pro and an iPhone 16 from 18 to 26. They’re new and they’ll be fine is not a poor conclusion, this has almost always been the case. But not the oldest-supported device.