In my opinion yes, it looks too big. I think the bigger Apple Watches look too big on most wrists, I think that's true of a lot of analogue watches too, I'm just kindof a small watch guy. It's mostly the thickness I think. My favorite ever watch was a Mondain Swiss Railways watch I had before Apple Watch came out, was a lovely thin, minimalist design.
As for everyone saying "who cares, you do you", I agree with the sentiment 100% - if you like it then it doesn't matter what anyone else things, but if OP actually just can't make their mind up and genuinely wants a second opinion to help them figure out what their own opinion is* then you're not helping.
*and sometimes hearing the opposite of your opinion can help sure up your own in your mind, it's not like they're necessarily just going to go with what the majority tells them