Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
ALL of these devices should be sold sans charger, power/communication lead.
Apple are packaging masters and I'm sure they can design the shipping boxes so they all fit together nicely if you do in fact need peripherals.
During the purchase stage we should be presented with a screen that says there is no power/data lead and then be given the option to add to basket.

The unnecessary waste that these extra bits created is phenomenal.
 


Apple's new M5 MacBook Pro will ship without a power adapter in the box in the United Kingdom and European Union, prompting online confusion that the change was mandated by EU law — a claim that is incorrect.

M5-MacBook-Pro.jpg

Apple quietly updated its online store following the launch of the M5 MacBook Pro to note that customers in the UK and EU who purchase the new 14-inch model will no longer receive a charging brick by default. The laptop still includes a MagSafe 3 cable, but buyers must purchase a compatible USB-C power adapter separately. The change does not apply to other markets such as the United States, where a 70W USB-C Power Adapter remains included at no extra cost.

The omission led some observers to suggest that the decision was required under new European environmental regulations. Some claimed that the European Union had banned manufacturers from including power adapters with new electronics in order to reduce electronic waste, but this is not the case.

The confusion appears to stem from the EU's 2022 Common Charger Directive, legislation designed to standardize charging ports and give consumers flexibility when purchasing new devices. The directive requires that all smartphones, tablets, and laptops sold within the EU use USB-C for wired charging. It also stipulates that consumers must be offered the option to buy a device without a charger to limit unnecessary e-waste.

The law "ensures that consumers will be able to purchase new electronic devices without having to obtain a new charger each time," but it does not prevent manufacturers from supplying one. In practice, this means companies must provide a version of each product that can be purchased without an adapter, while retaining the freedom to include a charger or offer it free of charge.

Apple's decision to remove the charger entirely from the EU boxes therefore goes beyond what the law requires. The company could, for example, offer customers the option to include a charger at checkout for no additional cost, as long as it also sells a version without one. The lack of charger in the UK is even more unnecessary, since it is not part of the European Union.

The move to charge separately for adapters is therefore a business choice by Apple, not a legal necessity. The company's approach simplifies logistics and packaging, avoiding the need for separate SKUs in Europe, but it also shifts the cost to customers who do not already own a compatible charger.

Apple has historically argued that omitting power bricks from its packaging is part of a wider environmental effort. The company first removed the charger from iPhone boxes in 2020, citing the environmental benefits of smaller packaging and fewer redundant accessories. Similar reasoning has since extended to other product lines. By reducing the size and weight of shipments, Apple says it can cut carbon emissions and limit use of resources across its supply chain.

The M5 MacBook Pro continues to support both MagSafe and USB-C charging. Customers can use existing 67W, 96W, or 140W USB-C adapters to charge the device, depending on the configuration. Apple sells its own USB-C power adapters separately, and the company's online product pages now prominently note that "power adapter sold separately" for the affected regions.

Pricing adjustments partly offset the omission in some regions. In several European countries, the new 14-inch MacBook Pro is approximately €100 cheaper than its predecessor, although the UK model retains the same starting price.

Article Link: EU Didn't Stop Apple From Including Charger With M5 MacBook Pro
Hartley, do you have any source for this?

Or are you trying to interpret the law and provide legal advice on your own?

Unless you are a lawyer, I suspect that might itself be prohibited under local regulations (legal profession law, bar association rules, and the like).
 
Right because Apple is a new company that can’t manage their stock.. Poor Apple
I didn’t say Apple can’t. I said Apple didn’t want to. They definitely could but didn’t want to incur the extra capstone and headache introduced by the EU.

So yeah, Apple is penny pinching on stock management here, but the part of the original blame definitely goes to the EU.

Plus, Apple reduced pricing.
 
If this environmental rule is genuinely necessary, why are US customers exempt? This inconsistency suggests regulatory favoritism rather than environmental concern.

Because America is run by one man who does not care about the environment, so that even Tim Cook had to go and rub his belly with a god awful gold plated disk. America will politically not care about the future in the next 3 1/2 years.
 
EU is mean to Apple, Apple is mean to the EU
EU isn't mean to Apple. We're not talking about children at school.

EU regulates and does a lot of things, even if most readers here are only aware of those that MacRumours reports. Some of them affect Apple, but in many cases also its competitors. Ruling something that affects some company isn't "being mean". That's a ridiculously childish statement and interpretation of how the world works. (EDIT: I'm sorry for the last statement, I read it twice and realized it's very wrong because some countries do have leaders who very much make their governments act like kids, playing games and punishing who is "mean to them". But that's not the case of the EU, they're mostly very cold bureaucrats).

On the other hand, Apple has caused unjust damage to competitors (they have been proved to abuse their dominant position repeatedly, blocking their software), to their customers (for example, one of those uses basically killed forever real freeware as we knew it on mobile devices), to the environment they pretend to love for greenwashing (they have made their products as unrepairable as possible before the were pressured or forced to change it), to EU countries (they've tried to avoid taxes with all the tricks in the book).

I wish you people could stop being hardcore fans and defend soulless corporations because you enjoy their products.

And I love that we have some superior protection against companies that have more financial power than some countries.
 
Last edited:
Selling a computer without a charger is ridiculous. Apple’s greed knows no limits
Nearly everyone has USB-C chargers and cabels, I think it is good of moving away from providing tons of overproduction and waste. It would have been nice however if Apple gave buyers of new Macs a nice deal to include a charger for those that don't have one.
 
“would you like to buy a battery for your laptop sir” said apple
“Is in not includes’ said Apple fanboy
“You can buy a battery for for £250 or a £90 charger “ said Apple
“Can I have discount for buying both’ said customer
“Yes Sir it will £339.99 and before you ask we don’t do stickers “ said Apple
 
„EU Didn't Stop Apple From Including Charger With M5 MacBook Pro“

Technically, this is true. But by any kind of business logic, of course they did. They mandated that there has to be a version without charger and Apple would never go to the insane logistics trouble of creating two separate SKUs for every MacBook just to include the charger in one of them. And the EU absolutely knew this would be the outcome, because their goal was to reduce the production of unnecessary chargers.
 
And like every other company, they're passing on the increase of costs to us.
Apple actually decreased pricing.

In France for example:

€1899 - M4 MacBook Pro with charger
€1799 - M5 MacBook Pro without charger
€1864 - M5 MacBook Pro with separate 70 W charger

BTW, we just use a 35 W charger for our M4 MacBook Air. Actually we sometimes even just use the 15 W USB-C port built into our electrical wall outlet. I was gonna swap that wall outlet to 30 W USB-C but it turns out we haven’t needed to.
 
Last edited:
After research, Apple will start selling laptops without the Q, X and Z keys from 2027.

"These are the least-used keys on our keyboards. Most of our users have older keyboards with these keys still in pristine condition, which can be prised out and placed in their new MacBooks".

It's noted that these keys can be purchased from the "Accessories" section of Apple's website for $69 each.
 
EU didnt force Apple to remove the floppy disk, optical drive, headphone jack and so on...

Take a look at the comments in the EU articles: "EU is to blame".
And yes, Apple's propaganda has managed to convince most non-EU-Apple users (at least here at Macrumors) that every (perceived negative) decision Apple makes is the EU's fault.

No OLED on the MacBook? Blame EU!
Problems with AI? Blame EU!
Sexual allegations? Blame EU!

For these people, the EU is to blame for everything.

Just a quick reminder that Macrumors always reports pro-Apple on EU issues, twisting the truth beyond recognition.

And the result this constant pro-Apple writing can be seen here: The editorial team must write against the conspiracies of the specially cultivated “EU-is-to-blame-for-everything” readership.
 
If they cut the cost of a charger from the RRP that would be one thing. But they didn’t and its unlikely you will keep the charger from your old laptop as its new owner will need it!
 
What a misleading headline!

While the EU might not prohibit including a charger in the box, not including a charger is the logical consequence of the EU legislation. It is a distinction without a difference.

“It also stipulates that consumers must be offered the option to buy a device without a charger to limit unnecessary e-waste” means that retailers are burdened with the cost of shipping, storing and stocking a whole extra SKU. Why would retailers burden themselves with this extra cost when they can simply comply with the law by not including a charger in any of their products?
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.