Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
This would be awesome. I hate having to have Facebook open in a Firefox tab just for people to be able to talk to me. A desktop app is ideal
 
Despite all the negative comments, for a minute I thought having a message app would be nice to be notified for my new messages, but then I remembered that OS X does that already.
 
What are you saying that you want to hide so badly? I usually don't say anything on FB Messenger that I wouldn't mind people hearing. At the very worst, a friend will ask about how my relationship is going or whatever, and some random person will see what I say; big deal. If anyone is reading all those mundane messages from me and all the other Facebook users, I feel bad for that person.


... which also looks a lot like Messages for Mac. I'd be slightly less frustrated if it at least looked a bit different. Having two similar-looking messaging clients open reminds me of how much I'd rather just have one messaging client open.

Tell me you're not that naive. You're the kind of person that scares me. Ready to give up our freedoms. And proud of it.
 
Tell me you're not that naive. You're the kind of person that scares me. Ready to give up our freedoms. And proud of it.
I think a lot of things scare you that shouldn't. You can encrypt your messages about where you want to eat lunch if you're so concerned.
[doublepost=1452451706][/doublepost]
A phone call or a message actually makes thing easier / faster / better than smoke signal (and no there's nothing wrong about them they are just passed by new tech), Facebook does not make anything easier / faster / better than a message or a phone call.

Again, it might let you know about your friends / relative bowel movement, not sure that is a good thing though.
Facebook does make it easier because it puts the contacts all in one place. I mean, it's only easier because almost everyone uses it. If everyone used AIM still, that's what I'd use to contact them. Facebook also has pages and events, which are especially useful for us college students because of all the random things people invite us to. And the pages are like forums, comparable to Reddit.

Yeah, people also use it for posting junk. It's easier to ignore the junk than to make it the one reason you avoid using what most people use to contact each other. On a phone, you have telemarketers calling you, which is definitely worse.
 
Last edited:
Tracking is needed for desktop market isn't it? For mobile market, it's been covered. I feel incomplete if no one is tracking me. For iMacs powered from mains, there will be no complaints of phantom battery drain issue. Development should be easier.

I will also leave a glowing 5 star review for weekly update change logs like "We update the app regularly so that we can make it better for you"

Facebook, Thank you very much for this.

-your die hard fan.

This made my day LOL!

How they are allowed to be so vague with their update details on the App Store is something I always wondered.
 
"What are you saying that you want to hide so badly? I usually don't say anything on FB Messenger that I wouldn't mind people hearing."'

So you are OK with installed key loggers on your computer and cameras in your bedroom, monitoring every move you make and have it reported to the government?

I mean, there are rapists, and camera access to all bedrooms would help fighting crimes…

Are you OK with getting rid of search warrants, so the police can go into any house whenever they like, without suspicion or OK from a district attorney? Why complicate the police work, let them catch the bad guys…You have nothing to hide…

If not, why should we allow the same, just because it happens in cyberspace?

(Of course, Facebook is a private company, and Zuckerberg may decide to run it like Erich Honecker ran DDR, but I will never buy products from such a company, which includes Oculus Rift CV1 they just released)
There's absolutely no reason why I need to care about random people seeing me, but it could be a problem if the government were doing it and if they started abusing it later. That's how it goes with freedom of speech, too. A country like France doesn't honor freedom of speech, and it sounds fine because they're just banning the Nazi party and such, but it eventually becomes a debate in politics what kind of speech should be allowed.

But we're talking about a totally opt-in service like Facebook that's just gathering messages. There's nothing they can use against me in my messages, but they might be able to use things against me with cameras and key loggers. If I want to say something secretly, I can do it somewhere besides Facebook. It's extremely rare that I'll need to do that outside of work. I'm not going to pretend like I'm so important that I need to hide even 1% of what I'm doing.
 
Last edited:
I think a lot of things scare you that shouldn't.
[doublepost=1452451706][/doublepost]
Facebook does make it easier because it puts the contacts all in one place. I mean, it's only easier because almost everyone uses it. If everyone used AIM still, that's what I'd use to contact them. Facebook also has pages and events, which are especially useful for us college students because of all the random things people invite us to.

Based on your posts you are either very young or naive. I hope you're young. Do yourself a favor and bone up on privacy issues including the impact FB has on our life from an authority, legal, and employment perspective. It is a serious issue.

back to the OP topic ..... :D
 
Based on your posts you are either very young or naive. I hope you're young. Do yourself a favor and bone up on privacy issues including the impact FB has on our life from an authority, legal, and employment perspective. It is a serious issue.

back to the OP topic ..... :D
My age is hinted at in my signature and my name, if you want to know. I explained above why FB collecting messages is different from the 1984 government. TL;DR, Facebook is a private, opt-in service. You can easily choose what not to say on it, but there's no rational reason to be so secretive about most of what you say, and you guys are acting like you're way more important than you are by avoiding using Facebook at all just because of that.
 
On a phone, you have telemarketers calling you, which is definitely worse.
You make a good point for student I give you that (nothing that a school site could not do anyway but i get your point), but using Facebook would not stop telemarketers calling you ;)....IF ONLY.
 
My age is hinted at in my signature and my name, if you want to know. I explained above why FB collecting messages is different from the 1984 government. TL;DR, Facebook is a private, opt-in service. You can easily choose what not to say on it, but there's no rational reason to be so secretive about most of what you say, and you guys are acting like you're way more important than you are by avoiding using Facebook at all just because of that.

How naive.
Want to guess what one of the aspects used in investigating new employees? What they have on FB including associated posts and friends. Just went through a legal seminar on that last year. What they can legally pull is mind-numbing.
 
This is good for me, as Facebook is a primary channel of communication for many of my colleagues spread around the world. In some countries, such as the Philippines, people can get a mobile phone with only "Facebook data" access for free. I hate having to open the full Facebook website at my end just to communicate with them, although I'm sure that Facebook loves that I get distracted with stuff happening on my timeline. o_O
 
Actually I don't see why all the hate for the app. I've been using Goofy since it was released (a nice web-wrapper of messenger.com) and I always wanted it to feel native. This would fix it.
 
Actually I don't see why all the hate for the app. I've been using Goofy since it was released (a nice web-wrapper of messenger.com) and I always wanted it to feel native. This would fix it.
Because it used to work in Messages and iChat, and that was the best. The new app by itself is good to have, but I'm really annoyed that they removed their Jabber support. I think a lot of people on this forum don't know that anyway. They just have some irrational hatred for Facebook.
[doublepost=1452491820][/doublepost]
How naive.
Want to guess what one of the aspects used in investigating new employees? What they have on FB including associated posts and friends. Just went through a legal seminar on that last year. What they can legally pull is mind-numbing.
Yes, I'm aware. Back when I was overly cautious, after I got over the fear of using FB at all, I had a falsely named FB account with a Star Trek character as the picture that I used. And I had one with my real name and photo and a few posts that just sat there as a decoy for people. I later realized that it was more beneficial to actually put my real name and photo so people can find me since I didn't post anything incriminating anyway.

You choose what to put on there. Facebook warns you what they use the information for. There's nothing to complain about. There's almost nothing you need to hide, but you can hide what you want by not posting it. What I'm annoyed about is that people pretend like they must hide everything and avoid using Facebook at all as a result, then they boast about it. Just what we need, another way to be a hipster.
 
Last edited:
You choose what to put on there. Facebook warns you what they use the information for. There's nothing to complain about. There's almost nothing you need to hide, but you can hide what you want by not posting it. What I'm annoyed about is that people pretend like they must hide everything and avoid using Facebook at all as a result, then they boast about it. Just what we need, another way to be a hipster.
There's nothing "cool" or "hipster" about hating Facebook, it was fun for a bit but as said earlier it does not improve on any other stuff we already have.

I have nothing to hide and definetly NOT an interesting person to lurk about but when you express your opinion (be it political, sexual or personal) those things might harm you let's say during a job interview (you would be surprised to see how many company check your profile before an interview).

First rule they tought me for a job interview is to stay neutral, never say what football team you rule for for example, you never know you might have someone interviewing you who rules for the opposite team and the first impression count a lot (not that you will not be hired for that, but it helps with the rest of the interview).

True you decide what to share, but you never know how different people react in a different way to the same post.
 
There's nothing "cool" or "hipster" about hating Facebook, it was fun for a bit but as said earlier it does not improve on any other stuff we already have.
Doesn't matter if it's fun or improves upon anything. It's worthwhile to at least use it for the messenger so you can contact people. I've never considered it fun, just a utility. A hipster is someone who thinks it's always cool to do things the non-mainstream way. I know some people avoid it because they know they can't control their usage on it, but that's different.
 
Why would a dedicated desktop app let Facebook edge out line? Line has had a desktop app for years.
 
Yeah, and to think there was at one point an effort to interconnect Microsoft and Yahoo messengers, the two major IM services at that time.
Yeah that would have been cool. I just want one that everyone can use. But whatever company controls the platform will end up abusing it, so this is probably for the best.
 
Doesn't matter if it's fun or improves upon anything.
That's my main point, if it doesn't do anything better (improve on what we have) why is it still alive? As other posted we had multiple platform before but where surpassed by newer / better tech, with facebook there's nothing better....and definetly not new anymore.

I really don't understand the facebook trend i mean i tried i saw and stopped using because messages / phone calls / forums still works and are way more anonymous and less filled with c**p.
 
Ugh, it stinks that they started disallowing Jabber clients to connect. Last year, I used to be able to contact all my Facebook friends (aka most people I know) just through Messages, plus people on iMessage, SMS, and AIM. It was perfect! I wish Apple would update Messages to support whatever proprietary protocol Facebook uses because I really don't want to have to run multiple messaging apps.

EddiOS42 has the right idea. They probably did it so they can get people to use their own stuff. Unfortunate.

It's not proprietary, it's SIP. Jabber is part of the dying XMPP protocol, the one that Google ditched too.
[doublepost=1452511021][/doublepost]
When is Facebook just going to go away? Home to 12 year old girls, soccer mom's, and drama.

I think you just clearly spelled out your social circle. For many of us, we do not experience that on facebook as those people aren't in our list of contacts.
[doublepost=1452511146][/doublepost]
There's nothing "cool" or "hipster" about hating Facebook, it was fun for a bit but as said earlier it does not improve on any other stuff we already have.

I have nothing to hide and definetly NOT an interesting person to lurk about but when you express your opinion (be it political, sexual or personal) those things might harm you let's say during a job interview (you would be surprised to see how many company check your profile before an interview).

First rule they tought me for a job interview is to stay neutral, never say what football team you rule for for example, you never know you might have someone interviewing you who rules for the opposite team and the first impression count a lot (not that you will not be hired for that, but it helps with the rest of the interview).

True you decide what to share, but you never know how different people react in a different way to the same post.

Facebook absolutely improved upon other services, this is some serious head in the sand nonsense.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.