Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I don't feel sorry for Samsung one iota. When the original iPhone came out, nobody could come up with a better design and Apple ruled. So Samsung comes along with their copycat tactics and blatantly rip off Apple's design and tells them TFB (Too *** Bad). To try and get a leg up and I guess prove to the world they can produce a superior product they rush to push out the Note 7. What they have succeeded in doing is showing the world that they are just posers and wannabes!
 
Not this will change profits first, consumers second...but really Samsung?

I am glad everyone was safe on that plane. Aren't there laws against this? (This would be one of those extremely rare times I'd be all for lawsuits).
 
It's unbelievable. A phone so fundamentally flawed it had to be recalled and people defended that by googling isolated incidents of iphones having battery failures. Now the replacement devices are doing the same and people still think they look any less than insane pointing out that other things have gone on fire. That sKoolaid must taste good.
 
I don't feel sorry for Samsung one iota. When the original iPhone came out, nobody could come up with a better design and Apple ruled. So Samsung comes along with their copycat tactics and blatantly rip off Apple's design and tells them TFB (Too *** Bad). To try and get a leg up and I guess prove to the world they can produce a superior product they rush to push out the Note 7. What they have succeeded in doing is showing the world that they are just posers and wannabes!

How myopic.
 
Back in the late 1990's I worked for a company that had a datacenter filled with about 3,000 servers from a PC vendor I won't mention (located in Texas). Over the course of a month or so we had three separate incidents where individual servers caught fire. The server would first completely stop responding - lights were on but you couldn't see anything on a monitor, couldn't connect to it over the network, couldn't even power it off by pressing & holding the power button. In the end the only thing we could do is pull the power, wait a minute, then plug it back in. Each time we did that the video chip on the motherboard would erupt in a geyser of flame.

A few weeks after we reported these incidents to the manufacturer they informed us that they had implemented a recall on a batch of motherboards, and about 700 of the servers in our datacenter were subject to it. It was my task to go into the datacenter and identify those 700 servers. The manufacturer sent a team of workers to the datacenter who set up an assembly line to replace all those motherboards, which took about a week to complete.

At some point well after that little nightmare we learned that the manufacturer had traced the fault back to a vendor in China that had provided the capacitors used in the power regulator circuitry on the motherboards. The capacitors had been apparently manufactured with faulty dielectric material, and after time they started failing in spectacular fashion. They'd apparently build up a huge charge and maintain it until power was cut & restored, at which time it would release a surge of all that stored up power all at once. Something about the design of the motherboard caused that surge to go directly into the video chip.

My completely unscientific guess is that Samsung will likely eventually trace this to something similar - a fault in a component provided by a third party that under certain conditions results in an overload.
I always enjoy reading the thoughts of those actually in the industry that know way more than I do. Rather than mud slinging you tell us if an experience you had and what might be the issue here.

There's a reason I still read the comments here and this is it! Thank you.
 
What, some isolated incident about an iPad apparently burning down a barn? No real confirmation or definitive proof that it even was the iPad?

The Note 7 began combusting within weeks of shipping. Samsung confirmed the issue (read: "yes, we released phones which bloomin' explode") and did a recall. I don't think you fully grasp just how severe this is.

If Apple devices exploded due to a manufacturing defect and Apple announced a recall, then the Apple brand be irreversibly tarnished.

Your ideology is complete, and I do mean complete, rubbish, because plenty of Apple devices have blown up or caught fire along with lots of other different devices from different makes, let alone the endless car safety recalls, and yet all these businesses are still in business and doing fine.
Hence your ideology of 'Permanently tarnished brand' is rubbish, you have only stated that because this story is about Samsung and conveniently ignored ALL previous history of similar cases.
 
Last edited:
Even if the Pixel is not a perfect product, I sincerely hope Google goes to the top for Android and dethrones Samsung who doesn't deserve to be at the top after this fiasco.
 
This is a shame. Samsung is an excellent company, they make many high quality electronics. Personally, I use their PCIe SSDs extensively in my environment. And, they've pushed their competitors to get better. I genuinely hope they can overcome this issue, their engineering prowess is not in question in this house. Yet.
 
Your ideology is complete, and in do mean complete, rubbish, because plenty of Apple devices have blown up or caught fire along with lots of other different devices from different makes, let alone the endless car safety recalls, and yet all these businesses are still in business and doing fine.
Hence your ideology of permanently tarnished brand is rubbish, you have only stated that because this story is above Samsung and conveniently ignored all previous history of similar cases.

Isolated incidents of battery failure =/= fundamentally flawed design.. Trying to conflate the two, even in the face of a replacement going boom is absolutely barmy
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.