Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
67,494
37,783



We've already seen iPad Pro reviews from media sites that Apple invited to test the tablet ahead of its release, but now that the iPad Pro has officially launched, first impressions from regular Apple customers are now available.

New iPad Pro owners on Reddit, Twitter, and the MacRumors forums have been sharing their opinions on the device, and for those considering a purchase, opinions from average consumers provide useful insight.

ipadprosmartkeyboardapplepencil.jpg

MacRumors reader TrueBlou shared some images of the old 12.9-inch iPad Pro next to the sleeker, slimmer 2018 12.9-inch version, providing a look at just how much smaller the new model is. He says the difference is an "incredible improvement."

ipadpro129inchcomparison.jpg
It's an incredible improvement, I really cannot overstate just how much of a difference it is. It's one of my favourite things about the new iPad.

It's not just that it's smaller, lighter and thinner - which of course it is. But the combination of all of those things also changes its centre of gravity a little and it's really noticeable.
Reddit user SlightCriticism offered up a look at the 10.5-inch iPad Pro on top of the new 12.9-inch model, which gives a good idea of how much bigger the 12.9-inch model is.

105129ipadprocomparison.jpg

He says he's ultimately going to swap the 12.9-inch model for the 11-inch because the 12.9-inch model is still too heavy for one-handed use.
I had a first gen 12.9 which was too big and sprung for the 10.5 when it came out last year. I found the original 12.9 to be too difficult to hold on the train etc but the 10.5 has been the perfect companion. I did miss the extra screen space, but its size was harming my productivity and I decided I valued that more. I really thought the size decrease of this gen was going to be the perfect solution for me, and my first impressions were positive, but after using it for a while I've found it still a bit too heavy for prolonged one-handed use. Of course this isn't the case for everyone and I'm sure a lot of people will find it a terrific size.
MacRumors reader ryuok pointed out that because the new 11-inch iPad is using a different aspect ratio, apps that are not updated have black bars on both sides. Apps will get updates eventually, but it's something to be aware of.

ipadproblackbars.jpg
A 12.9-inch iPad Pro with black bars via MacRumors reader jun180
There are two kinds of black bars:

1) Rounded corner black bars: This is similar to the iPhone X situation, before apps are updated to accommodate the extra spaces extended by the rounded corners. This affects both the 11" model and 12.9" model.

2) Aspect ratio black bars: This only happens on 11", and it is far worse and far more notifiable than the "Rounded corner black bars". If an app is not coded to dynamically adapt to aspect ratio, you'll see horrifyingly large black bars especially in landscape mode. It's almost like seeing an iPad mini sized app, inside an 11" screen. Populars apps such as Facebook and Netflix are affected by this.
Reddit user atru22 said the new Smart Keyboard Folio takes some getting used to, but he likes it a lot more than the previous-generation keyboard. He also says the 12.9-inch model feels surprisingly small.

ipadproredditatru22.jpg
Image via Reddit user atru22

On the topic of the Apple Pencil, Reddit user essjay2009 said that the Pencil feels quite different in the hand and that there's more friction when using it. Charging and pairing is much improved, of course, since it just needs a magnetic attachment to the iPad Pro.
I will say that the pencil feels very different in the hand. It's a little shorter but that makes a huge difference. I always thought the gen 1 felt a little ridiculously large (length wise). This feels more like a normal pencil. The double tap feature is really nice and far more forgiving than I was expecting. I thought you'd have to tap specifically on a certain spot, but it seems to just pick up double taps pretty much anywhere reasonable.

Pairing and charging is soo much better. And that's coming from someone who didn't have any particular issue with the way the old one charged.
Reddit user dvegi also thought there's much better drag with the Apple Pencil 2 and the iPad Pro's new display.
So, just wanted to let you guys know that there is a much better drag with the Apple Pencil 2 and the iPad Pro, than before (a lot of people didn't like how the pencil felt on glass so resorted to getting a matte screen protector-- but no need with the new iPad Pro!)
Reddit user GottaDeal confirms that the new 11-inch iPad Pro on-screen keyboard has a 12.9-inch keyboard layout thanks to the extra room from the removal of the bezels. It offers up tab, caps lock, and left side shift keys, unlike the 10.5-inch iPad Pro.

11inchipadprokeyboard.jpg

MacRumors reader ninethirty wasn't a fan of the Smart Keyboard Folio, calling it a "design nightmare."
Got my 12.9 today. The iPad itself is absolutely beautiful, but the design of the smart folio keyboard is awful. It doesn't fold around as easily as the previous keyboard, it makes everything a lot thicker, and quite frankly, the materials of the folio itself feel cheap, which is a shame. But worst of all, when you fold the folio to the back of the ipad, to hold and watch a video or something, the keys are exposed on the back.
MacRumors reader largefarrva disagreed, though, saying that he likes it a lot and is impressed with the key feel.
I actually like it quite a bit. I was a bit worried that the keyboard would feel like the butterfly keyboards of the MacBooks nowadays but it doesn't at all. Hell, if the MacBooks had keys that felt like this they wouldn't be nearly as bad. Granted it is very little travel in a keystroke, but the feedback is a ton times better than the MacBook keyboards.
Have a new 2018 iPad Pro? Share your first impressions and photos in the comments below. We'll have an unboxing video and our own hands-on later today, so make sure to stay tuned to MacRumors for more iPad Pro coverage.

Article Link: First Impressions From New 2018 iPad Pro Owners
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mezelluf
Have to admit... Raised an eyebrow when it said the pencil has more friction. I currently have Paperlike on my iPad and am not overly impressed. I'm anxious to see how this stacks up ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: profmjh
Be interested to see a photo of the smart connector on the inside of the keyboard folio case. Is it visible or is it under the material?
 
I got the 11" model. Absolutely love the new iPad itself, it feels like an enormous step up from my 9.7" pro. The new folio case will take some getting used to. I hate the color, so I'm going to have to find some stickers or something, and I don't really like that the keys are exposed on the back. I do like that it has two screen positions, and the keyboard itself is nice and responsive. The pencil is lovely, but the magnets that hold it on are not super-strong, so I keep knocking it off the ipad when I go to reach for it. I think this is something I'll get used to, or I'll just keep the pencil separate in my bag, it's not a big deal.

All in all just a few small quibbles, I am delighted with the iPad itself.
 
I went from 10.5” to 12.9”. The device itself is phenomenal, you are just holding the content on the screen, and that is it. The bezel size is perfect, any smaller and you would be constantly touching the screen.

I like the Smart Keyboard, and I actually don’t mind the keys folding behind as much as I thought I would. The keyboard “locks in” via magnets when folded back, so it feels more solid than the last gen. The two angles make it worth it IMO, and I prefer ripping the keyboard off when just using it as a tablet anyways.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Precursor
I have a late 2015 iMac without any USB C ports....Kinda hard to Sync now.
Guess I´ll have to buy a cable/adapter. *Sigh*
Yeah I had to also. I cannot believe Apple doesn’t make one too. Had to get one from some shady guy at one of those mall kiosks who didn’t even know iPads had USB C. He was trying to force me to buy a Lightning cable.
 
Looks great, but unless you have some rather limited or very touch specialized workflow this just won't cut it for most people. It sure looks nice and I bet the performance is stellar but that folio keyboard just doesn't give the same typing experience as a "real" keyboard.

A lot of applications and services are offering web-applications these days so you can do most things directly in the browser. But the experience isn't comparable to using the full desktop applications and alot of them won't even work in mobile web-browsers.

Combine this with the fact that we are starting to reach the same price-point as MacBook's and other decent notebooks on the market its not all that compelling. It sure has it benefits, but its limitations just outweight's all its benefits unless you have a workflow where the Apple Pencil and the artistic values it provides will be essential to you.


What I would prefer would be to have something like a 2-in-1 device where you have a device that combines this iPad Pro and the MacBook Air with a detachable display. Have it run macOS when docked to the keyboard, giving the full desktop experience with a great keyboard and touchpad. And when you detach it starts running iOS and becomes just like this iPad Pro. It doesn't seem all that far-fetched when we look at how far the hardware on these iPad's have come and how powerful their SoC's really are.

We need a way to get macOS running on ARM, and Apple needs to find a elegant way to integrate the iPad Pro with a detachable keyboard and we are pretty much Golden.
 
Just a word of caution. Do NOT try and use any of the glass screen protectors currently available for the new iPad Pros. The touch response becomes SERIOUSLY wonky. It is so bad I thought I had a hardware issue with my brand new 11" iPad Pro.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JRobinsonJr
Yeah I had to also. I cannot believe Apple doesn’t make one too. Had to get one from some shady guy at one of those mall kiosks who didn’t even know iPads had USB C. He was trying to force me to buy a Lightning cable.

Was kinda surprised that Apple even didn’t sell an adaper or cable for this issue.
My late 2015 iMac isn’t THAT old...
It’s a bummer, not the biggest of deals... just a bummer
 
  • Like
Reactions: mariusignorello
First impressions (12,9" one):
1. Lack of USB-C- USB-A adapter is a joke.
2. Heavy (compared with 10,5 inch Pro)
3. With keyboard on it almost looks like Surface Pro
4. I expected "wow" effect, but at the end of a day I am considering keeping 10,5 one for a while.
 
Purchased the 12.9 Inch, 64GB LTE model. It is everything I hoped it would be:
  • Gorgeous screen
  • The size is very manageable
  • Blazin fast
  • Looks very sleak
  • Good speakers.
  • USB C works as advertised. Hooked it up using USB C to Digital AV Multiport Adaptor to my HD TV to mirror BT Sports live football coverage. Have not tried charging my iPhone via the IPP. Plugged in a USB C hard I’ve and it cannot read the contents. I am hopeful USB Drives will be added in iOS 13.
  • The Suppliued plug (UK version) is very small and the pins collapse. The Supplied USB C cable is too small so use the 2m Cable I ordered.
  • The Apple Portfolio Keyboard looks very neat and matches the space grey IPP nicely. I really like the portfolio keyboard as typing is nice, the two angles you can use it are welcome and is very much more sturdier when using on your lap. The Apple Pencil Gen 2 is much better in terms of design. I really like the magnetic way it clips on and that it automatically charges as well. Not an artist at all, it feels nice and is slightly smaller.
  • Apps wise I am able to use my macbook desktop apps on IPP so will be selling the MacBook. I do a lot of writtten work, Mind mapping, Project management, basic photo editing, and very basic vector graphics stuff. I do though look forward to more desktop class apps porting to IOS. I have found using IOS on the IPP a pure joy. Everything is smooth and no RAM management issues. Coming from an anemic MacBook 12 inch which struggled at times to this IPP is like light and day in performance. Was easily able to run two apps in split mode and have streaming picture in picture to watch football.
  • Battery is okay and will meet the advertised length.
  • On the downside, the weight of the ASK and IPP combined will put some off.
  • The ASK has no backlight which is a shame however, I hope Logitech and other 3rd party manufacturers will bring out such keyboards.
  • Some will bemoan IOS which I can understand if you need Final Cut Pro or Adobe Premier. The lack of Xcode is something also noticeable for app developers. Microsoft Office apps are excellent but do not offer the full range of some basic features still seen on their desktop counterpart.
  • Welcome to a life of dongles which will not be as painful if you have or do own a MacBook. This again is an added cost.
  • No Headphone jack is not an issue for me but will be for music developers/DJs, however, there is a dongle for this.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: sp3k0psv3t
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.