Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Probably hard to explain, but why would I tip someone who carries my bag to my room, but not someone who scans my shopping and packs my bags? Aren't they both giving me a service?

Couldn't tell you why but its usual and customary.
[doublepost=1461668174][/doublepost]
It's not optional to tip the housekeeping staff. Actually, it's pretty rude to stiff the people cleaning up after you.

I always leave a $10 bill with a note when I check-in with any preferences I have and also asking that my room be cleaned as early as possible. If they comply, I leave another $10 upon check out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: D.T.
It's unclear to me and I have lived in the US for 25+ years.

Tip food service people that isn't fast food (bartenders, wait staff), bellhops, valets and you're probably good. A number of those positions include tips as part of their income, and therefore is a big part of their livelihood.

I always tip bellhops, concierges and valets well, these people can get things done for you during your stay.

Hotel maids get a hefty tip on the first night, this way you can always get fresh towels, extra coffee, etc.

If I am sitting at a bar and service/conversation is good, I will give a great tip after the first drink, you will get good pours and bartenders will tell you more about a city then anyone else.
 
It's not optional to tip the housekeeping staff. Actually, it's pretty rude to stiff the people cleaning up after you.

This sort of highlights the pitfall of tipping culture. If they're being stiffed, it's not by me, it's by their employer. I would support the housekeeping staff unionizing - I might even donate to their union efforts. They should be paid fair wages, and those wages should be reflected on the price of my hotel stay. When it comes to paying for hotel services, my responsibility ends at the bottom of the credit card slip.

Typically above that, tipping is a quid-pro-quo business or an added optional services business. Tip the bartender for faster attention and better pours, tip the waiter for better service, tip the valet for parking your car when you don't feel like doing it yourself, tip the bellhop for bringing your bags up when you don't feel like doing it yourself, etc. All of those are basically paying for special attention and establishing a relationship with the service provider, or opting in to optional extra services.

However, with housekeeping staff, what am I tipping for? They never see me, they don't know who I am, they don't know if I am a regular and they won't recognize me the next time I'm at the same hotel. And the cleaning service is not optional - it's a necessary service offered by the hotel as part of the price of staying there. I'll leave cash under the TV remote at the end of my stay if I was more messy than usual, or if I had exceptionally great service and feel really good about it, but those aren't normal occurrences.
 
A lot of fast food restaurants will have a tip jar or an option to tip on the credit card receipt. I do not tip when anything is handed to me over a counter.
 
  • Like
Reactions: maflynn
I've never tipped hotel staff other than on a cruise. And I don't know anyone else or at least many people that do it regularly.

A cruise is the only place I've ever tipped the people/person that cleans my room. Most of my travel has been for work, I can't expense gratuity for room cleaning.

Last time I traveled for work was in Sept. The person didn't deserve it anyway. I was there over a weekend, on Friday I left the card indicating I wanted full cleaning with fresh sheets and towels as I did not want them in the room over the weekend. They did that but never left a fresh card for Monday or any other day the following week. I got fresh towels when I left them on the floor and the bed was straightened up but not changed (not that I don't go more than a couple days before changing sheets at home).
[doublepost=1461686361][/doublepost]
A lot of fast food restaurants will have a tip jar or an option to tip on the credit card receipt. I do not tip when anything is handed to me over a counter.

A mom 'n pop type place like a local pizzeria maybe. Some franchised places like Subway and Mcdonalds are not allowed to due to corporate policies.
 
A lot of fast food restaurants will have a tip jar or an option to tip on the credit card receipt. I do not tip when anything is handed to me over a counter.

If I have a special order - like, a special order bordering on annoying or weird - then I'm more likely to leave a tip. Otherwise yeah, I don't tip at walk-ups.
 
We're generally really good tippers, especially with local restaurants/bars where we're regulars.

A little extra tip (that was on top of excellent service), has gone a L O N G way. Just one example: local Italian/pizza place, big tippers there, the last visit we got 10% off the bill, a free round of [very good micro] beer free, and when we had our leftovers packed up to take home, they dropped in a whole loaf of their crazy delicious garlic/cheese bread.

I always leave a $10 bill with a note when I check-in with any preferences I have and also asking that my room be cleaned as early as possible. If they comply, I leave another $10 upon check out.

Outstanding, same here. We get extra, EXTRA towels, double/triple pillows, asked for extra ice buckets, got 'em, mentioned we like a late afternoon room service, no sweat.
 
15% is minimum, but if service is exceptional I'll leave 20%. Maybe even a few slips of cash whilst shaking hands as some establishments monitor employee tips. That's disgusting.

Don't forget our taxes if you decide to go shopping. You'll have to pay sales tax and so it's wise to keep extra money on you if you decide to purchase anything. If you've got a credit card that's been ok'd with the creditor for international shopping, just use that. It's easier.

I don't really do hotel chains, but I'll tip anywhere from 20-50 depending on the hotel I stay at. Usually when I'm traveling overseas for business, I'll leave a larger than necessary tip to get the attention of staff longer.
 
OP, please do the right thing and tip the housekeeping staff at your hotel. They clean up after you and have a physically demanding, low-paying, thankless job.

As well, it's considered proper etiquette to tip them, and here it is straight from the horse's mouth http://emilypost.com/advice/general-tipping-guide/

However, with housekeeping staff, what am I tipping for? They never see me, they don't know who I am, they don't know if I am a regular and they won't recognize me the next time I'm at the same hotel. And the cleaning service is not optional - it's a necessary service offered by the hotel as part of the price of staying there. I'll leave cash under the TV remote at the end of my stay if I was more messy than usual, or if I had exceptionally great service and feel really good about it, but those aren't normal occurrences.

Ok, print that out and leave a copy for the housekeeping staff in lieu of a tip.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
A lot of fast food restaurants will have a tip jar or an option to tip on the credit card receipt. I do not tip when anything is handed to me over a counter.
Same here, I don't see any exceptional service in handing me my meal from the counter.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huntn
OP, please do the right thing and tip the housekeeping staff at your hotel. They clean up after you and have a physically demanding, low-paying, thankless job.

As well, it's considered proper etiquette to tip them, and here it is straight from the horse's mouth http://emilypost.com/advice/general-tipping-guide/

Ok, print that out and leave a copy for the housekeeping staff in lieu of a tip.

If you feel so strongly about this that you will use your own money to subsidize the things that should be paid for by billionaires like Arne Sorenson (CEO of Marriott), Christopher Nassetta (CEO of Hilton), and Thomas Mangas (CEO of Starwood), I won't object. But it is my opinion that those guys, and their respective companies, that should make sure their employees are paid properly.

If you really care about the wages and working conditions of hotel workers, then I suggest you make sure the hotel you are staying is approved by http://www.fairhotel.org (a website that supports unionized hotels, and encourages hotel workers to organize), and not on their boycott list. That $10 or $20 you leave for the housekeeper isn't really addressing the underlying problem, is it? If you insist on voting with your wallet, check out that site.

I think the OP understands now that tipping culture in the US can be summed up as a shtishow. :) No single website or book can explain it fully. Also, OP, most tour guides expect a tip. Bus tours or biking tours, that sort of thing.

Overall, I think we should strive for less tipping, not more. Many studies have shown that tipping is linked to corruption, and countries with more tipping culture have higher levels of corruption. (e.g., https://dash.harvard.edu/bitstream/...ipping-and-Bribery-6-6-12-SPPS.pdf?sequence=1). It's an anachronism that should be done away with. In the meantime, I will keep tipping (1) my waiter, (2) my bar tender, and (3) my cab driver; because I don't want (1) my food pooped on, (2) my drinks spit in, and (3) to be dropped off on the wrong side of town. Isn't extortion great?
 
As a European, I'll admit that I am uncomfortable with a business model where - in essence - the customer is expected to pay the wages of staff as well as pay for the service provided.

My sense is that if staff were paid a decent basic wage, then the way tips are viewed would be different. This would be because customers would not have the responsibility of having to determine the degree to which service would - or should - be rewarded (which matters when wages are so risibly low), and staff would have the security and stability of a guaranteed wage, and not have to wonder whether or not their efforts will be rewarded irrespective of how good the service they supply actually is.

Thus, there wouldn't be this massive power imbalance, where the employer incurs hardly any costs, the customer (not the employer) is on the receiving end of employee resentment, and whether or not the employee gets paid at all is entirely dependent on the discretion, or goodwill, or just the mood, of the customer.

To be quite candid, intellectually, (and hypothetically), I would be a lot more comfortable in a system where signs are openly and prominently displayed, signs which could state clearly, if with an uncomfortable candour, as you entered the premises, something along the lines of: "We cannot be bothered to pay our staff, as we'd prefer to use every opportunity to squeeze profit out of them instead, and that means it is up to you to give them something by way of remunerative reward if you feel like it, but - and, meanwhile, get this - they are free to make your life miserable with poor service if you don't, or, if you choose not to. Meanwhile, this has nothing to do with me, any of it; I merely supply the space where this can happen."

In Europe, the staff are paid a salary, - below which it cannot go by law - and can be expected to be able to afford a basic - if not massively decent - living on that.

Thus, tips are discretionary, not mandatory, and are usually tendered if service has been very good. That means, that if service is indifferent or poor, you don't tip.

Re credit cards, for that matter, I have heard too many horror stories of how the 'discretionary service charge' may or may not get paid to staff. However, if there is an added service charge on the actual bill, - as there usually is, the kind that is not discretionary - I will not tip unless the service has been exceptional, as I have already been charged for it, and, even then, I will do so in cash - that way the server gets it - rather then on a credit card.
 
Last edited:
Ok, print that out and leave a copy for the housekeeping staff in lieu of a tip.

That would be rude.

I generally don't tip hotel housekeeping staff. There have been a few unusual cases where I have:

- When I'm staying for several days and it's personal travel
- When I've left more of a mess than what I would consider typical
- When service has been truly exceptional (this has never happened to me outside of a resort hotel)

I can't wrap my head around tipping people I never actually encounter. That makes no sense to me. And I generally tip fairly well in instances where I feel tipping is called for.
 
That would be rude.

I generally don't tip hotel housekeeping staff. There have been a few unusual cases where I have:

- When I'm staying for several days and it's personal travel
- When I've left more of a mess than what I would consider typical
- When service has been truly exceptional (this has never happened to me outside of a resort hotel)

I can't wrap my head around tipping people I never actually encounter. That makes no sense to me. And I generally tip fairly well in instances where I feel tipping is called for.

Oddly enough, probably precisely because I actually worked one summer as a chambermaid in a hotel when I was a student, I almost always tip hotel staff, even if I do not tip that many others, as traditions in Europe are different.
 
That would be rude.

I generally don't tip hotel housekeeping staff. There have been a few unusual cases where I have:

- When I'm staying for several days and it's personal travel
- When I've left more of a mess than what I would consider typical
- When service has been truly exceptional (this has never happened to me outside of a resort hotel)

I can't wrap my head around tipping people I never actually encounter. That makes no sense to me. And I generally tip fairly well in instances where I feel tipping is called for.
But then these are people that directly affect you by cleaning up after you and leaving you with a clean and tidy room. I'm not sure directly seeing a bellboy bring your bag somehow makes that more personable or meaningful to someone compared to someone who cleans up a fairly personal area where one sleeps and does many other things.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
But then these are people that directly affect you by cleaning up after you and leaving you with a clean and tidy room. I'm not sure directly seeing a bellboy bring your bag somehow makes that more personable or meaningful to someone compared to someone who cleans up a fairly personal area where one sleeps and does many other things.

Yes, I would be pretty much of this opinion, too.

As I have already said, I do tip the cleaning ladies, almost always. I remember what that job was like. Not always nice.
 
But then these are people that directly affect you by cleaning up after you and leaving you with a clean and tidy room.

For the most part, they're cleaning up before me. I gain nothing by them cleaning up after me unless I'm staying for several days.

I'm not sure directly seeing a bellboy bring your bag somehow makes that more personable or meaningful to someone compared to someone who cleans up a fairly personal area where one sleeps and does many other things.

For the record, there is NOTHING "personal" about a hotel room, at least not in my mind. It's a bed thousands of others have slept in and a toilet thousands of others have **** in. Very little different from a public restroom in that regard.

Do you regularly tip a chef when you dine out? Or the dishwashers? When you have pizza delivered, is your tip for the driver, or do you instruct the driver to share it with the crew who made your pizza as well?

To me, there IS something meaningful and personal about interacting with someone, especially someone like a bellhop or a parking valet, someone who is doing something for me that I am normally expected to do myself.
 
For the most part, they're cleaning up before me. I gain nothing by them cleaning up after me unless I'm staying for several days.



For the record, there is NOTHING "personal" about a hotel room, at least not in my mind. It's a bed thousands of others have slept in and a toilet thousands of others have **** in. Very little different from a public restroom in that regard.

Do you regularly tip a chef when you dine out? Or the dishwashers? When you have pizza delivered, is your tip for the driver, or do you instruct the driver to share it with the crew who made your pizza as well?

To me, there IS something meaningful and personal about interacting with someone, especially someone like a bellhop or a parking valet, someone who is doing something for me that I am normally expected to do myself.

Well, some women might make the exact same argument about the sort of cleaning that is usually done in bedrooms, and that is precisely the reason I leave tips in bedrooms, as I remember what that work was actually like.

Indeed, that sort of cleaning up after someone very often falls to women in the domestic sphere, or, at least, used to in more traditionally inclined households.

Anyway, I like fresh sheets, and towels, and returning to a nicely made up room.
 
Well, some women might make the exact same argument about the sort of cleaning that is usually done in bedrooms, and that is precisely the reason I leave tips in bedrooms, as I remember what that work was actually like.

Indeed, that sort of cleaning up after someone very often falls to women in the domestic sphere, or, at least, used to in more traditionally inclined households.

Anyway, I like fresh sheets, and towels, and returning to a nicely made up room.

Oh I wholeheartedly agree, on all counts. But I also appreciate clean plates and flatware. Is the reason we tip housekeepers and not dishwashers, then, because they're female? Surely not.

(Anectotally speaking, I do believe most hotel housekeepers I've seen are women - but most janitors I've seen are men. So while ladies change the sheets, it's men who scrub the toilets. Food for thought.)
 
Oh I wholeheartedly agree, on all counts. But I also appreciate clean plates and flatware. Is the reason we tip housekeepers and not dishwashers, then, because they're female? Surely not.

(Anectotally speaking, I do believe most hotel housekeepers I've seen are women - but most janitors I've seen are men. So while ladies change the sheets, it's men who scrub the toilets. Food for thought.)
I think part of it is access too--it's somewhat hard to tip a dishwasher or even a chef since they are away from you and are not easily accessible so the tip ends up basically being a waiter/server one, even if you meant it more for the chef perhaps because the food was so amazing, but not much else was that amazing.
 
Oh I wholeheartedly agree, on all counts. But I also appreciate clean plates and flatware. Is the reason we tip housekeepers and not dishwashers, then, because they're female? Surely not.

(Anectotally speaking, I do believe most hotel housekeepers I've seen are women - but most janitors I've seen are men. So while ladies change the sheets, it's men who scrub the toilets. Food for thought.)

No, you don't tip them because they are female - you tip them because they do a job that can be unpleasant, and yes, it is your own personal mess that is being cleaned.

Re bellhops, my experience in staying in hotels is that I am expected to bring my luggage to my room myself. Again, maybe that is the European experience…..

Re janitors and chambermaids, well, my experience - whether this is European or not, I cannot say, as I haven't worked such jobs in the US - but, I can say that what you have written was not the case - at all - when I worked as a chambermaid (granted, all of some time ago when I was an undergrad; things might have changed since then).

In any case, then, - my experience was that - the (female) chambermaids also cleaned all of the rest rooms in the public areas of the hotel - the male restrooms as well as the female restrooms, in addition to the bathrooms in the bedrooms. Not the janitors. And yes, we scrubbed the toilets. And the urinals. Happy memories.

However, this tended to be done in the very early hours of the morning - say, 5 a.m., or 6 a.m, when the public areas of the hotel were unlikely to be visited by guests, unless they were checking out to catch an early flight.
 
Last edited:
Overall, I think we should strive for less tipping, not more.

As a European, I'll admit that I am uncomfortable with a business model where - in essence - the customer is expected to pay the wages of staff as well as for the service provided.

There is a restaurant local to me that has abolished tipping. When the whole discussion about wage increases came up, the owners took it upon themselves to do something about it for their employees that were working for tips. The restaurant raised the wages of all employees, they all make better than minimum wage (depending on the place, tipped workers will make less than minimum and have to claim at least enough tips to make minimum for the shift if they made at least that much) and tipping is discouraged. They might even have a statement on the menu or in the store suggesting the patron consider a donation to a charity instead of the tip.
 
OP everyone here seems that everyone that does a service deserves a TIP. Yet I haven't seen anywhere that many know what TIP stands for.. Here it is, To Insure Promptness. Years ago tipping was really reserved to wait staff for promptness, but everyone thinks that ANYONE that is getting paid should get a tip just for a service. TIP waitstaff, taxies, bartenders and bellhops. As mentioned above, 15%is the base starting number. If you tip everyone that performed a service, you will go broke in just a couple of days. Also, as mentioned above anyplace that has a jar out for tips, just forget. They are getting a paid wage probably somewhere between minimum wage and whatever. Another place to tip is at valet parking where you choose the amount. Some valet parking charges up front, then they expect on top. Don't fall for it.
 
OP everyone here seems that everyone that does a service deserves a TIP. Yet I haven't seen anywhere that many know what TIP stands for.. Here it is, To Insure Promptness. Years ago tipping was really reserved to wait staff for promptness, but everyone thinks that ANYONE that is getting paid should get a tip just for a service. TIP waitstaff, taxies, bartenders and bellhops. As mentioned above, 15%is the base starting number. If you tip everyone that performed a service, you will go broke in just a couple of days. Also, as mentioned above anyplace that has a jar out for tips, just forget. They are getting a paid wage probably somewhere between minimum wage and whatever. Another place to tip is at valet parking where you choose the amount. Some valet parking charges up front, then they expect on top. Don't fall for it.
http://www.snopes.com/language/acronyms/tip.asp
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tomorrow
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.