Stallman is making more and more sense to me.
Yeah, this talk is great, I hadn’t listened to it before so thank you for sharing.
You know what? Despite being an avid Apple user, mostly because it’s ease of use, how pretty does it look, and how private and secure they claim it to be, many of the statements of Stallman resonate with me. We deserve freedom.
And on the Apple operating systems that allow it, such as macOS, I try to choose and run open software, supported by a community.
However, I reached a point of the talk, near the first third of the talk, where he says we have to, quite often, make a choice between freedom and convenience. And that’s when I recall the whole year I spent using Linux alone, as my main desktop operating system, 15 years ago.
It was a little nightmare to just make the Internet connection run… it was a harsh experience as some of the time, I spent it fixing things via the command terminal. And that was enough for me, and after a whole year with Ubuntu, I switched to OSX, namely Snow Leopard, in the year 2010. And never looked back.
Well, actually, I’m starting to look back to be honest. I’m not sure if GNU/Linux is still a compromise between usability, convenience, and freedom and privacy… maybe that has changed in the last 15 years!
But yeah, more and more, I feel like we need to keep that freedom alive, and make it “usable” for the human beings, including those that don’t code or know how to use a terminal. Because we’re most certainly being surveyed by this big corporations, but it’s getting even worse with all the AI thing getting access to more and more private data.
I’m talking about Windows 11, yes, and how they are enforcing us to update to newer versions that have more and more intrusive integration with the cloud and copilot. Where they blatantly admit to take screenshots of our computers and send it to their servers.
Honestly I know Apple is not completely private either, but at least it seems more worried about it. And it seems the route they want to take in the AI field is of local models whenever it is possible, or an optional call to a “private” cloud. Let’s cross our fingers for them to continue to work towards local LLM tools, even if that means getting an M4 computer or newer…
But the main point I wanted to make, before I resume the video, is that I agree with Stallman in the needs. We need an alternative to iOS / Android. We need an alternative to macOS / Windows. And that alternative is probably the GNU project, but sadly, it needs to be also convenient (that’s what Stallman doesn’t seem to understand), stable, with no need of previous knowledge, intuitive… otherwise it won’t ever be accessible to most human beings, while iOS and Android are. Heck, I think there isn’t even a convenient smartphone running free software! And even if it did, many people will require you to install proprietary apps such as WhatsApp to be able to communicate with them and have a social life.
It’s… complicated, especially if we have to give up on convenience and ease of use. That’s why I’ll probably keep running iOS/iPadOS on my mobile devices, using as little apps as possible (better they come from a known trustable developer), and disabling many location, microphone and camera settings, while on desktop I’ll keep using macOS with mostly open sourced apps, and a few from the Mac App Store (just because the MAS version is sandboxed).
But mind you, I recently bought a micro-PC (smaller than the palm of my hand, a tiny cube with an N100 intel SoC), and after reading and experiencing how invasive Windows 11 has become, I’m seriously considering giving GNU/Linux another chance, to see if, 15 years later, it’s a more convenient, and less troublesome operating system to use.