Public libraries in the US loan books and DVDs without charge -
that's the basic purpose of a library. One of our local libraries
even loans ebooks.
Public libraries are paid for by taxes, so Eidorian is actually
paying for the content - just not at the point of consumption.
Assuming that Eidorian doesn't digitize the books or rip the DVDs
to his system, it's legally (and ethically) proper.
yes assuming that you are right
if he does not rip from internet, he is not stealing
hard to understand though from the tone of his reply