Become a MacRumors Supporter for $25/year with no ads, private forums, and more!

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
55,018
17,396


Apple's new 14-inch and 16-inch MacBook Pro models will feature a redesigned row of function keys that replaces the Touch Bar, and each modifier key will have the same width and height as the alphanumeric keys on the rest of the keyboard, according to rumors and leaked schematics seen by MacRumors.

touch-id-magic-keyboard-for-imac-e1634547211386.jpg
Full-size function keys and Touch ID button on iMac Magic Keyboard

It's been a hectic few days for the Apple rumor mill, which has seen multiple last-minute MacBook Pro leaks concerning a possible notch on the top of the display. We don't yet know whether the notch rumor will turn out to be true, but what we do have high confidence in, and what may have thus far been overlooked by some, is the layout of the redesigned keyboard.

Before Apple introduced the Touch Bar in October 2016, the MacBook Pro featured a narrow row of function keys that individually had a smaller profile than the alphanumeric keys. However, in lieu of a Touch Bar, the new MacBook Pro models are expected to have a full-size complementary row of function keys, similar to Apple's Magic Keyboard that comes with the 24-inch iMac.

The first suggestion that function keys would return to the MacBook Pro came from reliable analyst Ming-Chi Kuo in January, when he reported that Apple was working on two new MacBook Pro models featuring significant design changes. Since then, Bloomberg's Mark Gurman has consistently stopped short of saying that the Touch Bar will be removed this year. Instead, Gurman states that Apple has "tested" versions of the MacBook Pro without the Touch Bar, implying that it may choose to remove it. Given the accumulation of evidence since, summarized below, we're almost certain the OLED touchscreen strip above the keyboard will not be returning.

The first real evidence of the change appeared in April, when schematics of an unreleased MacBook Pro were stolen from Taiwanese Apple supplier Quanta Computer by the ransomware group known as REvil. Despite demanding payment in exchange for keeping the information private, some of the schematics still leaked on the dark web, and subsequently corroborated the lack of Touch Bar, the return of an HDMI port, SD card slot, and MagSafe, and in hindsight, potentially a notched display.

The schematics showed a full keyboard layout, including a top row of function keys and a Touch ID button, all individually diagrammed to the same height and width as the alphanumeric keys, and as a result of the larger keyboard area, a smaller trackpad below it.

One month after the REvil leak, the new keyboard layout was also seen in renders, supposedly based on leaked images, of Apple's next MacBook Air, courtesy of Jon Prosser. As in the stolen schematics, the larger function keys were shown to have forced the entire keyboard down, thereby reducing the size of the trackpad.

prosser-macbook-air-keyboard.jpg
Render of rumored new MacBook Air by RendersByIan

The most recent rumor about the new MacBook Pro keyboard is that the area surrounding the keys is black, rather than just the keys themselves, in what is "probably the biggest visual change on the keyboard since the Unibody redesigns over a decade ago," according to details leaked by a Weibo account last week.

The Touch Bar has been a divisive feature among users, with some decrying the lack of physical controls for functions such as volume or brightness. Apple already made a slight concession when it re-introduced a physical Escape key on the latest 13-inch and 16-inch MacBook Pro models, after users complained about the virtual Escape key on the Touch Bar from previous models.

The return of function keys, in full-size implementation, appears to be just one indication that, after some perceived missteps in recent years, Apple is all-in on making the MacBook Pro a true professional's machine once again. We'll know for sure in a few hours.

The new MacBook Pro models are widely expected to be announced later today, Monday, 18 October at Apple's "Unleashed" event. Apple will live stream the event on its website and on YouTube. For those unable to watch, MacRumors will have live coverage of the event both on MacRumors.com and through our MacRumorsLive Twitter account. Be sure to stay tuned.

Article Link: Full-Size Function Keys Expected to Feature on New MacBook Pro Models
 
Last edited:

WilburMercer

macrumors member
Nov 20, 2020
71
779
This would be great.

I've had a MacBook Pro with the Touch Bar for about five years and (a) I miss having an ESC key (b) I missing having function keys (c) I miss using muscle memory to find things and (d) I like the fact real function keys don't crash and become unresponsive until you reboot.
 

samifathi

Editor
Feb 9, 2021
21
67
What if the f keys are the default choice and a touch bar is optional?
This idea has been floated around, and I'm curious if the Touch Bar has enough of a fan base (I'm included) to entice Apple to make it an option. It further complicates the lineup (more SKUs), so it's hard to think this will be an option unless there's a real market for it. Luckily, not very long until we find out.
 

PaulLll

macrumors newbie
Oct 18, 2021
1
19
I had the earlier MacBook without physical escape key. That really annoyed me as I code, and I use vi on linux to edit things - an escape key is kind of essential. I moved to the newer MacBook with Touch Bar and physical escape key (mainly to get away from the butterfly keyboard, which was killing me). I really like it. I'd find going back to physical function keys a retrograde step - I don't really use function keys, but I do use all the features you can get in the Touch Bar. I particularly like it for music and videos - one uncommented benefit is that it makes it really easy to skip YouTube ads.

I'm hoping they make the Touch Bar optional rather than removing it entirely.
 

MacFin

macrumors newbie
Oct 17, 2015
22
77
The touch bar will be gone - excellent! And while you are on it Apple, please ensure that the left and right keys aren't as wide as all of the other buttons. I constantly confuse the left arrow with the option when doing stuff since they feel the same. Just make it half the size like the up and down arrow keys and everything becomes easier. Not everything has to be so symmetrical.
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: ijbond and XXPP

NewUsername

macrumors 6502
Aug 20, 2019
411
773
I like it. My MacBook Air has smaller function keys than my Magic Keyboard and I keep pressing the wrong function key on my MacBook Air keyboard unless I look at them.

First world problems, for sure, but still…
 

JoshDoug

macrumors member
Apr 25, 2014
60
110
I had the earlier MacBook without physical escape key. That really annoyed me as I code, and I use vi on linux to edit things - an escape key is kind of essential. I moved to the newer MacBook with Touch Bar and physical escape key (mainly to get away from the butterfly keyboard, which was killing me). I really like it. I'd find going back to physical function keys a retrograde step - I don't really use function keys, but I do use all the features you can get in the Touch Bar. I particularly like it for music and videos - one uncommented benefit is that it makes it really easy to skip YouTube ads.

I'm hoping they make the Touch Bar optional rather than removing it entirely.
I highly recommend remapping the Esc key to something more comfortable, personally I use
Code:
:imap jj <Esc>
to jump from Insert mode to Normal mode. If you have to manage machines where you can't configure the .vimrc then you have my condolences.
 

BootsWalking

macrumors 68000
Feb 1, 2014
1,517
9,095
I had the earlier MacBook without physical escape key. That really annoyed me as I code, and I use vi on linux to edit things - an escape key is kind of essential. I moved to the newer MacBook with Touch Bar and physical escape key (mainly to get away from the butterfly keyboard, which was killing me). I really like it. I'd find going back to physical function keys a retrograde step - I don't really use function keys, but I do use all the features you can get in the Touch Bar. I particularly like it for music and videos - one uncommented benefit is that it makes it really easy to skip YouTube ads.

I'm hoping they make the Touch Bar optional rather than removing it entirely.
Tangential to your post, I switched away from using the Esc key in vim long ago because even on a regular keyboard it's not all that conveniently placed. I use <ctrl-c> instead, which is much faster for me. Give it a try and see if that works for you.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.