Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Well, I guess I'll be the one of the few that is not impressed at all.
If you are an artist of any sort (I do some painting), you know how to look at colours and replicate them very closely.
The integration into the pencil would simply force me and people like me to pay for a tool they don't need.
I'm also a painter (mostly acrylics, some oil, but mostly digital these days), and would buy one yesterday if I could. You're not being forced to do anything by anyone - don't want it? Don't buy it - simple.
Selecting or mixing colours... this would help make that quicker and easier. If you do actually paint, you'll know how long it can take to get exactly the right colour, tone and intensity by mixing paints, before you can even make a mark. And then when it dries, it might dry darker or lighter than you intended, no matter how accurate you tried to get it. And I've been doing this for the thick end of 40 years so I've had a bit of practice!
Actual painting attached, just so you can see what I do. Acrylic on board, about 30x40cm.
 

Attachments

  • 01_Paulette's-Piano.jpg
    01_Paulette's-Piano.jpg
    113.1 KB · Views: 182
You're not being forced to do anything by anyone - don't want it? Don't buy it - simple.

Very simple indeed... if and when the option is given.

If new iPads only work with a hypothetical 'Pencil 3', then you will not have any choice other than paying the premium if you want to use the pencil (which I definitely do).
In any case, if there is a market for it, it would be stupid for Apple not to implement it, but in an ideal world I'd rather not pay for stuff I don't need.

Nice painting by the way.
Here is one of mine. Oil on canvas, 50x60cm
 

Attachments

  • fullsizeoutput_6.jpeg
    fullsizeoutput_6.jpeg
    434.8 KB · Views: 115
I'm also a painter (mostly acrylics, some oil, but mostly digital these days), and would buy one yesterday if I could. You're not being forced to do anything by anyone - don't want it? Don't buy it - simple.
Selecting or mixing colours... this would help make that quicker and easier. If you do actually paint, you'll know how long it can take to get exactly the right colour, tone and intensity by mixing paints, before you can even make a mark. And then when it dries, it might dry darker or lighter than you intended, no matter how accurate you tried to get it. And I've been doing this for the thick end of 40 years so I've had a bit of practice!
Actual painting attached, just so you can see what I do. Acrylic on board, about 30x40cm.

Your talented. Feel better now?

He just said for him it would not work well. So defensive of an gesture that may never happen
 
Another innovative idea from Apple. Hope it is something that makes it way into an actual product. Would be interesting to see the future debate of the Apple Pencil vs the s-pen, since there seems to be one-upmanship in play.
 
Well, I guess I'll be one of the few that is not impressed at all.
If you are an artist of any sort (I do some painting), you know how to look at colours and replicate them very closely.
The integration into the pencil would simply force me and people like me to pay for a tool they don't need.

If you're an artist of any sort that earns a living from the skill then the time savings alone would make such a feature worthwhile. There's a lot of things illustrators can do but choose to use software/hardware alternatives for because they are more efficient.
 
I could be wrong about this, but... If you had the skills to make a good looking sketch (what you describe as drawing the shape, add the shadows and so on) wouldn’t you be able to quickly guess the colors to apply to the sketch just by looking at the product with your own eyes?

I’ve never seen anybody good at drawing having trouble guessing the color of an object.

Why guess when you have the product in front of you?
 
  • Like
Reactions: bobob
Is there something unreal about Apple devices? Don´t these devices and their software belong to the real world, too?
 
Your talented. Feel better now?

He just said for him it would not work well. So defensive of an gesture that may never happen

What about his talented?

We all see so many posts where people reject something because it's not for them. We get that, but why do people feel that every product has to be for everyone? ;)
 
An old idea that’s now possible to make it small enough to fit in the Apple Pencil took them long enough like
[automerge]1595081740[/automerge]
The idea is cool, but I don't see any practical application that justifies the increased complexity and cost.

It feels like something I would try a couple of times out of curiosity and then not even remember this feature exists after a month.

most probably just stick with the app based method, Apple should just integrate colour sampling into iOS as an API

it’s all that this is, they adding cost by adding a sensor that they already have on the iPad just use the camera
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: jonblatho


Apple is exploring new Apple Pencil technology that could allow the device to sample colors from the real world to use in digital art, drawings, edits, and more, according to an Apple patent application published by the United States Patent and Trademark Office this week.

Apple-Pencil-Color-Picker.jpg

Titled "Computer System With Color Sampling Stylus," the patent describes a computer stylus that "may have a color sensor."

The color sensor would be equipped with several photodetectors able to measure light for different color channels, which would let it detect and sample a color from a real world object, like a flower.

The stylus could also be equipped with a light to make it easier for the photodetectors to accurately determine a color, and the rest of the patent describes an Apple Pencil-like design with an elongated body, a tip, and an opposing end, with the tip able to work with a touch-sensitive display.

Apple says the color sensor functionality could be located at the end of the stylus, at the tip, or coupled to the tip through a light guide.

applepatentcolorsensor.jpg

With this kind of technology, Apple Pencil users would be able to do something like hold the Apple Pencil against an object in the real world, with the Apple Pencil reading the color. It could be used for photorealistic paintings or just sampling of unique colors from grass, plants, existing art, and so much more.

According to the patent, the stylus would detect the color and then put it in a color palette in a drawing program, where the color could be assigned to a brush. Apple also suggests that color sensor could perhaps be used for other purposes such as calibrating displays, calibrating printers, making health-related measurements, and identifying paint colors for home projects, which would make the Apple Pencil even more versatile.

Optical color sensors like this already exist and have been used in various ways. In fact, we've tested a simple, rudimentary optical color sensor in the Sphero Specdrums, a product meant to turn color into sound. This product includes a little finger ring that can be tapped against real world objects to make sounds based on the color it senses, but Apple's implementation would presumably be much more precise.

Apple patents all kinds of different technologies, some of which seem plausible to implement and others that are quite fantastical. There's never any guarantee that Apple's patents will be used for real products, and in fact, most patents are for technologies that never get released.

For that reason, there's no word on whether Apple actually plans to add a color sensor to the Apple Pencil, or if this is simply an idea that's never going to make it out of the possibilities phase.

Article Link: Future Apple Pencil Could Have Sensor to Sample Colors From the Real World
I am thinking integrating this capability into the Apple iGlasses and AR Specs.
 
The idea is cool, but I don't see any practical application that justifies the increased complexity and cost.

It feels like something I would try a couple of times out of curiosity and then not even remember this feature exists after a month.

it’s useful for any kind of digital artists, digital creatives, designers, photographers and so on
 
Someone at Apple playing Astroneer?

They have a tool that does this, takes a color sample of soils from various planets and lets you use that color to create things.
 
Love the Apple Pencil. That and an iPad? And Procreate? Me and them have a future...one day.

I didn't appreciate the greed grab price hike for version 2.

Azrael.
 
The idea is cool, but I don't see any practical application that justifies the increased complexity and cost.

It feels like something I would try a couple of times out of curiosity and then not even remember this feature exists after a month.

obviously aimed to graphic designers, artists and the likes.
 
Neat, but a highly specialized feature. I would hope this to be a feature of an 'Apple Pencil Pro' and not baked into the price of the every day Apple Pencil.
This. It certainly sounds like a nifty feature and will be useful to some but not the majority of Apple Pencil users. As such I hope it doesn't further increase the price of the Pencils or make them more fragile. If it does then it should be an optional feature.
 
  • Like
Reactions: muzzy996
Your talented. Feel better now?

He just said for him it would not work well. So defensive of an gesture that may never happen

Why such a nasty response? Do you feel better now?

His words and his beautiful painting tell me his views are trustworthy. They also align with my wife's, who is also a talented painter and has spent countless hours making color charts before starting a project.
 
This will only work accurately if the ambient light has perfect white point and considerable brightness...

Exactly. Once you leave the realm of bright primary and secondary colors under controlled lighting, it's impossible to determine accurately what components make up what we perceive as "a color." In dark shades or light neutrals, the same color perception could be achieved 50 different ways.
 
This will only work accurately if the ambient light has perfect white point and considerable brightness.

Nope.

Like existing products meant to measure colour ambient light is irrelevant because the decide would make contact with the object and supply it's own calibrated light source.
 
It is pretty cool, but the tech has been out for ages and hobbyists have been playing with it for years, for example: Here's one device that measures color.
But I guess only Apple has the courage to shop in a flea market in Shenzhen, China and pretend they invented the tech.


This tech has also been around for a long time.


Pantone came out with it awhile back to sample clothing swatches but it's evolved since then. it's a nice addition, but it's not brand new.

Ok, so one of those is a raw component nowhere near small enough to be used on a stylus, and the other is a big honking handheld device used in completely different ways.

I'm not sure what you think is being patented here, but the ability to just "sense color" ain't it. That capability in and of itself has been around longer than any of the examples above. What is being patented is the application of this capability into a stylus that is integrated with a computing device i.e. tablet.

As a side note, this stylus would be great for architects and interior designers trying to match existing paints/finishes in the field, especially if they are doing illustrations on their iPads etc.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.