I have to agree I don't understand why iTunes has become the holy grail of UI. Some of it makes sense-- the sidebar is actually more useful this way.
The sidebar is actually quite useful in Tiger for two reasons: 1) it's completely user configurable, you can put anything you want in there (and take it right back out), put it in any order you want, and, 2) that exact configuration is propagated to the sidebar in open and save dialog boxes. That feature of Tiger's sidebar alone is worth it's weight in gold.
The problem with the iTunes-inspspired sidebar is that it appears to be hard-coded, what you see is what you get. I don't see (at least in the screenshots) where you can add your own stuff - if you can at all. And it reamins to be seen if you can drag Apple's hard-coded catagories into any order you see fit, or delete the ones you don't need.
If the sidebar isn't as user configurable as it is in Tiger, that's an absolute deal breaker for me.
I'm not warming up to Leopard's iFinder at all. It's bad enough that they used iTunes 7, the ugliest duckling of all Apple apps, as a basis for it - but why? Back when Tiger was introduced, Steve Jobs climbed onstage and told us that, with the advent of mass storage on modern computers, it was too hard to find stuff nowadays because of the thousands upon thousands of files and folders that everyone accumulates on their hard drives. Enter Spotlight, Apple's answer to your prayers. Now you can find just the file you're looking for in an instant. No more wasting time plowing around looking for your stuff.
Fast forward to 2007. Advancing the world's most advanced operating system, thanks to coverflow, now it's actually good to "browse" the files on your computer. Thousands and thousands of 'em. Who cares what you're looking for. Just stare at your screen in amazement as thousands upon thousands of those giant icons roll on by. It may not be productive, but who cares? It looks cool!
Someone suggested they were meant to be like "footlights" showing which apps are active.
The problem is that they look too much like the sunlight reflected water droplets on the leaves on the desktop pic Apple used. They may be more prominent and noticeable with some other desktop pic.
october is a great month - my belly button birthday and...
Wait! When was the rest of you born?