Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
66,724
36,097


Android users, later this year, will have the ability to opt-out of tracking across apps on Android devices, limiting the ability for apps to access their unique advertising ID, Google announced in a support page update (via Bloomberg).

play-store-google.jpeg

The new change, in theory, is similar to Apple's recently launched ATT, or App Tracking Transparency framework; however, it differs in direct implementation. On iOS 14.5 or later, when users first open an app, a prompt is shown with the options "Ask App not to track" or "Allow." According to Google, users won't see a pop-up for each app, nor will they have granular controls over each individual app's ability to access their IDFA.

Instead, according to the support document, a new toggle within Android settings will let users opt-out completely of all tracking, for all apps.
As part of Google Play services update in late 2021, the advertising ID will be removed when a user opts out of personalization using advertising ID in Android Settings. Any attempts to access the identifier will receive a string of zeros instead of the identifier
Initial reports suggested that Google was hesitant to implement a framework similar to Apple's due to concerns over the impact it would have on its advertising business. In the weeks and months leading up to Apple's ATT launch, which was first previewed at the company's developers conference last year, Facebook and other companies voiced concerns that the new privacy-focused change would hurt their bottom line.

Google says the new change, which will come as part of an update to its Google Play services, will be rolled out in phases starting later this year and "will expand to affect apps running on devices that support Google Play in early 2022."

Article Link: Google Announces Plans to Allow Android Users to Opt-Out of Tracking Later in 2021
 
  • Haha
Reactions: rumormiller
People outside the tech bubble seem to understand and appreciate A LOT Apple’s anti-tracking push, much more than I was expecting. It’s quickly becoming a selling point.

Google have to begrudgingly react somehow.
 
People outside the tech bubble seem to understand and appreciate A LOT Apple’s anti-tracking push, much more than I was expecting. It’s quickly becoming a selling point.

Google have to begrudgingly react somehow.

Facebook has ~1.88bn daily users, before you factor in their other apps.
The privacy bubble is akin to a fart in a jacuzzi.
 
I am almost disappointed by the lack of Apps that I am using that seem to have tracked me that way before due to the lack of pop ups I am receiving compared to the specific ads I always get. Instagram is still as specific with ads as before which is down right creepy. Yesterday I was meeting a friend with our dogs outside and my friend was mentioning how he is on his 50 day streak of learning spanish with duo lingo and just as I get home I am getting an ad for learning spanish in 30 days
 
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: cocoua and subi257
Last edited:
opt-out ad tracking scheme << knob to allow apps to _ask_ for tracking

it means it will allow tracking until you decide not to. not a great plan.
 
The article says a string of zeros will be returned instead of the advertising ID.
This will limit app developers abilities to personalise/monetise apps using the advertising ID.

It does not say Google will stop tracking the user.

 
Proof that opting out will not really stop Android app tracking will arrive approximately 1 week after this is implemented. Google does not deserve your trust.
I think the new move is an extension of this that came 2 months ago already:


So in essence, "we stop tracking you, so that we can track you better...."
 
Instagram is still as specific with ads as before which is down right creepy. Yesterday I was meeting a friend with our dogs outside and my friend was mentioning how he is on his 50 day streak of learning spanish with duo lingo and just as I get home I am getting an ad for learning spanish in 30 days
Just a funny coincidence.

Instagram isn’t listening in the background to you or me or anyone in dozens or hundreds of languages, with zero effect on battery life, and it’s impossible for an app to get rid of the small “recording” dot.

Also, toggling off tracking has zero effect in Instagram’s ability to show you relevant ads based on accounts you follow, what posts you like and whatever information they already have on your profile.
 
I wonder what the catch is? 🧐
It means things are changing and companies like Google and Facebook is going to implement user facing choices that is uncircumstantial to their business acumen and modus operandi. Their user is the the product and how they make money. It is a lark, a stalking horse, a fib, corporate propaganda and a new way to market themselves. Until their business model changes, there’s no reason to believe them. A matter of fact, they’ve proven it on multiple occasions. https://www.theverge.com/2021/5/29/22460070/google-difficult-android-privacy-settings-arizona
 
I am almost disappointed by the lack of Apps that I am using that seem to have tracked me that way before due to the lack of pop ups I am receiving compared to the specific ads I always get. Instagram is still as specific with ads as before which is down right creepy. Yesterday I was meeting a friend with our dogs outside and my friend was mentioning how he is on his 50 day streak of learning spanish with duo lingo and just as I get home I am getting an ad for learning spanish in 30 days
It's less likely that you were listened to, and more likely that your location was tracked, which allowed advertisers to see that you were together with your friend for an extended period of time, so you began to get ads for some things your friend is already into.
 
The article says a string of zeros will be returned instead of the advertising ID.
This will limit app developers abilities to personalise/monetise apps using the advertising ID.

It does not say Google will stop tracking the user.

Exactly.

No one else will be allowed to track the user across apps... except Google themselves.
 
  • Like
Reactions: planteater and msp3
Instagram isn’t listening in the background to you or me or anyone in dozens or hundreds of languages, with zero effect on battery life, and it’s impossible for an app to get rid of the small “recording” dot.
More likely they inferred from his friends activity what he might be interested in, the user data is analyzed throughout the entire friendship / coworkers / family networks, not just one person at a time.
 
I don’t know where the rumors of hesitancy are coming from—I would have expected Google to be delighted Apple gave them an excuse to do this. The key word in “third party tracking” is “third party.” Google makes Android.

“Excellent—no other company will be able to track Android users. Only we will. All the data is ours.”
 
I am almost disappointed by the lack of Apps that I am using that seem to have tracked me that way before due to the lack of pop ups I am receiving compared to the specific ads I always get. Instagram is still as specific with ads as before which is down right creepy. Yesterday I was meeting a friend with our dogs outside and my friend was mentioning how he is on his 50 day streak of learning spanish with duo lingo and just as I get home I am getting an ad for learning spanish in 30 days
They are probably using your IP address as well. Best thing is to delete any app that is owned by Facebook.
 
I don’t know where the rumors of hesitancy are coming from—I would have expected Google to be delighted Apple gave them an excuse to do this. The key word in “third party tracking” is “third party.” Google makes Android.

“Excellent—no other company will be able to track Android users. Only we will. All the data is ours.”
Following apples lead!
 
  • Like
Reactions: MacBH928
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.