@Scaredpoet... I'll try to be brief...
For one, the keyboard could be more responsive. When thumbing fast, it often misses keys, which lead to typos, which lead to unwanted/incorrect auto corrections. I think a suggestion bar of some form would help. Doesn't necessarily have to be like ICS'. Blackberry has an interesting method. But either way, the lack of it hurts the overall typing experience. It's also not out of the realm of possibility for Apple to do (
http://osxdaily.com/2011/11/09/enab...t-auto-complete-word-suggestion-bar-in-ios-5/). I think giving the user control over the dictionary helps too. The ability on ICS to choose what words the dictionary remembers, and more importantly, what
not to remember, helps. Editing could also be a little easier. It's sometimes difficult to see where the magnifying glass ends up, or if you're trying to get it into a specific spot, when you let go, it inadvertently moves it. ICS' little editing cursor tab just feels easier to navigate and more accurate.
I think a big part of Safari being more usable may have to do with the screen size. Double tapping in doesn't always wrap text, and I have to scroll left to right to left to read certain things. Also, switching tabs is a bit cumbersome. On Chrome, swiping left or right gets you to the next tab. Also, little things like quick controls and magnifying links (
http://blogs.computerworld.com/sites/default/themes/cw_blogs/cache/files/u177/chrome-android-6.jpg -- this is the only pic I can find and is a poor example actually. A better example would be when the magnifier pops up for the links to the pages here on this forum. They're awfully small, and magnification really helps pick whether you want to skip to page 5 or 6, etc.) really helps stream line the experience. Also, you're allowed to open as many tabs as you want. If i recall correctly, Safari limits it to 8 or 9? There may be a few other things but can't recall off the top of my head (it's been a few months since I gave up my 4S for the GN).
I did read about iOS 6 finally not kicking you out of the App store per download. Very happy to hear about that. But other little things that bug me include:
-Being unable to toggle features on and off (I think widgets are overrated, personally, but a few things really do help make the experience better, and toggles are definitely one of them. Not just for things like WiFi, GPS, etc. but for the lock screen. I love being able to toggle off the lock screen when I'm at home and don't need the security, then toggling it back on when I go out and want my screen locked. With the 4S, I had to put in the code each and every time even when I'm at home)
-Lack of quick dials (on my GN, I have a home page dedicated entirely to direct-dials and direct-messaging of my most frequent contacts. Incredibly handy).
-Limitations of folders. I wish Google didn't follow Apple's example of limiting number of icons per folder, but I still think ICS allows for more? Was iOS' limit 12 per folder? I can't recall exactly.
-Mail I mentioned already earlier, but to add to it: For some reason, it doesn't show all my mail. I think the max is up to 2 weeks' worth? With Gmail on ICS, I literally get my entire mailbox on my phone. Labels seem to just work better too, unsurprisingly. Switching between accounts (I have 3 different gmail accounts for different purposes) is also so much more fluid in Gmail on ICS (the Gmail on iOS unfortunately doesn't allow multi-logins). Navigating through the iOS' Mail menu to get between inbox/sent/labels, etc. is just cumbersome. Then sometimes you're in the "All Inbox" and you have to navigate all the way out to the list of Mailboxes. Yeah, it's only a few more extra gestures, but on ICS, it's literally 2 taps to switch, and you get to see more (full threaded messages).
Anyway, I'd love to give more examples, but to be honest, my memory of iOS on the 4S is fading (I still have my iPad however, which I love, and feel iOS is far better represented).
I hope you're right about only seeing 5% of iOS 6' new features. And I hope one of the features that wasn't revealed is an improved keyboard. If I had to pick one area that's the sorest of all spots for me, it was the keyboard on the 4S. A larger screen might help mitigate the problem, but mainly the keyboard just felt like it couldn't keep up with my thumbing speeds. Yes, those "Damn you iPhone Auto Correct" sites can be faked, but it's difficult to ignore that the iOS keyboard gave birth to that internet phenom. Who knows which are real and which are fake, but judging by my own typing experience, I don't find a lot of them far fetched at all.
Why? For some of us the iPhone is a tool, and it hasn't stagnated. There has been steady, observable evolution.
If something isn't useful and reliable in providing for a user's needs, then it's not a tool. That's the distinction.
I feel you. That's why I think calling iOS boring isn't a fundamentally important criticism. It's the least of iOS' issues. Even as a tool, the usability of iOS is lacking in areas.