Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
64,465
32,294



Three days ahead of the HomePod's launch in the United States, United Kingdom, and Australia, Apple has now allowed the first full reviews of the device to be shared online. While opinions regarding specific features of the smart speaker fluctuate among reviewers, it appears that one constant remains: HomePod provides great, high-quality sound that beats most devices in the price range, at the cost of an underperforming AI assistant and the user getting further tangled into Apple's walled garden.

jbareham_180202_2266_0295-800x533.jpg
Image via The Verge


Nilay Patel with The Verge emphasized this feeling of being trapped in Apple's ecosystem by stating that he thought the HomePod as one of the "loneliest" of Apple's devices. He liked the audio and build quality of the speaker, which he said provided an impressive amount of bass that never overwhelms, and ultimately sounded "richer and fuller than almost every other speaker we've tested."

Still, his recommendation for HomePod was specific: it's only for those who live in Apple's walled garden and "prioritize sound quality over everything else."
All of this is why I started thinking of the HomePod as "lonely." It feels like it was designed for a very demanding person to use while living alone entirely inside Apple's ecosystem. It's tied more closely to a single iPhone and iCloud account than any other smart speaker, and Siri has none of the capability or vibrancy of what's happening with Alexa. Apple can try to move mountains by itself, or it can recognize that the HomePod is a little iOS computer for the home and let developers build on it as they have for so long and with such great success with the iPhone, iPad, and Mac.

The HomePod is a remarkable new kind of audio device. It does more to make music sound better than any other speaker of this kind has ever done before, and it really, truly works. But unless you live entirely inside Apple's walled garden and prioritize sound quality over everything else, I think you're better served by other smart speakers that sound almost as good and offer the services and capabilities that actually fit your life.
Joanna Stern with The Wall Street Journal noted that during her week of testing the HomePod, Apple's device "nails the speaker but struggles at smart." Stern noted that while Siri is a "good butler" for various HomeKit tasks, all of the usual issues remain when asking Siri other normal questions.
The HomePod has an iPhone processor and pairs with your iPhone--yet it can't make a phone call? To use it as a speakerphone, you need to start the call on your iPhone then select the HomePod as an audio source. You can, however, send text messages from the HomePod with just your voice.

There are more things the HomePod can't do, despite being hooked to your iCloud account and iPhone. It can't tell you your next calendar appointment. It can't alert you to new emails or texts. It's also missing crucial third-party apps like Uber and Venmo.
Matthew Panzarino with TechCrunch noted that HomePod's ability to recognize commands at a distance, even while music is playing, is one of the device's strong suits, but also explained that most of these commands are still limited by Siri. Panzarino provided a few further details of other parts of HomePod, favoring the attention that Apple paid to the flexible, braided power cord and "seamless" ability to move HomePod from room to room and have it automatically connect to "any network known by your phone" within a few seconds.

img_9266-800x533.jpg
Image via TechCrunch


Panzarino also went further into details about the sound quality of HomePod, describing it as "precise."
The sound that comes from the HomePod can best be described as precise. It's not as loud as some others like Google Home Max or as bright (and versatile) as the Sonos Play 1, but it destroys the muddy sound of less sophisticated options like the Amazon Echo. To genuinely fill a large room you need two but anyone in a small house or apartment will get great sound from one.

The HomePod was the "best" sounding. It's nuanced and subtle with great separation and clarity across all kinds of music. The Play 1, for instance, had decent mid range but an overly bright high end with just the out of the box calibration. At maximum volume, the Play 1 became shrill and painful where the HomePod maintained balance.
There are plenty of other reviews and opinions on HomePod coming out today, so below we'll list a few other reviewers and a quick snapshot from their respective articles.

Megan Wollerton with CNET:
With the HomePod in the center of the room, for example, I heard distinct wedges of good (and less good) sound around the speaker. Sometimes the front sounded great and the back not so much. Sometimes the best sound came from 90 degrees on either side.

Apple says the speaker adjusts itself based on room position, and as I moved the speaker around I could hear the difference as it recalibrated. Overall I found that the HomePod sounded best placed against a wall or in a corner, which is fine since that's where most people will probably place it anyway.
Jim Dalrymple with The Loop:
To be absolutely clear, there was no comparison in sound quality. HomePod offered so much more quality that it was quite literally laughable to hear the others. The only speaker that sounded decent was the Sonos One, but even it couldn't compete with HomePod.

It's hard to explain the sound of HomePod, but you get a feeling that the sound is enveloping you, even when using just one speaker. There is a sense that this is how the songwriter and producer wanted the song to be heard when they recorded it.
Brian X. Chen with The New York Times:
The result is a speaker with a deep bass and rich treble that is loud enough to fill a large room with superb sound. HomePod makes the Amazon Echo and Google's Home sound muffled and tinny in comparison.

But Siri on HomePod is embarrassingly inadequate, even though that is the primary way you interact with it. Siri is sorely lacking in capabilities compared with Amazon's Alexa and Google's Assistant. Siri doesn't even work as well on HomePod as it does on the iPhone.
Other reviews: USA Today, iMore, Telegraph, Pocket Lint, The Independent, and iJustine.

Article Link: HomePod Reviews: Outstanding Sound Quality, but Siri 'Struggles at Smart'
 

lsutigerfan1976

macrumors 68030
Sep 14, 2012
2,751
1,734
This is where they’ve failed. I keep stressing this over and over. You cannot have a smart speaker assistant that’s not smart lol. There is a a percentage of people who will still buy the HomePod regardless. But the market isn’t in the speaker. The market is in the assistant!
 

gnasher729

Suspended
Nov 25, 2005
17,980
5,565
Overall I found that the HomePod sounded best placed against a wall or in a corner, which is fine since that's where most people will probably place it anyway.

In a corner is exactly where you shouldn't put traditional speakers, because that's where they sound worst.

One market will be all those people who want decent sound quality, while the housewife doesn't want any big, ugly box in the living room.

On the other hand, still no reviews comparing HomePod to quality traditional speakers.
 

Baymowe335

Suspended
Oct 6, 2017
6,640
12,451
Apple's ignorance on Siri's development in recent years is really starting to show up. Siri has become the Village idiot among smart assistants.
Nonsense. Post some real examples.

Siri = Alexa and is better than Bixby.

GoogleHome appears to be better, but how often do you ask Siri things she can't do or answer? What specifically does she struggle with?

I honestly think people here just repeat their negative thoughts on Siri based on what they read.
 
Last edited:

gnasher729

Suspended
Nov 25, 2005
17,980
5,565
This is where they’ve failed. I keep stressing this over and over. You cannot have a smart speaker assistant that’s not smart lol. There is a a percentage of people who will still buy the HomePod regardless. But the market isn’t in the speaker. The market is in the assistant!
As I said, totally wrong. Actually, for playing music I find an "assistant" quite pointless. I prefer scrolling through the music that I have on my Mac, see lots of album titles, and pick one. Or do you think I can remember 1,000 artists, 2,000 albums and ten times more songs and tell some assistant what to play?
 

Frobozz

macrumors demi-god
Jul 24, 2002
1,146
95
South Orange, NJ
“unless you live entirely inside Apple’s walled garden and prioritize sound quality over everything else”

Stop right there. I do, and mine is arriving on Friday. Second, I want a HomeKit hub that is always at home. This is a no-brainer for me.

I first and foremost want an amazing speaker and, ideally, the future features planned will open up functionality along the way. I’m looking forward to pairing speakers with an additional HomePod, and really would like the ability to discern between multiple people. Siri features are great, but I already have an Apple Watch, an iPhone, an iPad, etc.
 

The Game 161

macrumors Nehalem
Dec 15, 2010
30,581
19,783
UK
Siri does what’s required..can’t imagine ever needing a smart speaker to be really smart

Just do basic tasks, play music, switch lights on and off, reminders for shopping list, play podcasts etc
 

Centris 650

macrumors 6502a
Dec 26, 2002
576
308
Near Charleston, SC
There is nothing smart about any of them. All i need is weather sometimes, control my lights and play music which it does just fine.
Same. I get the news and weather from my Echo while I get ready for work. Sounds like the HomePod can do the same thing.

On a side note: Every review I've seen blasting the HomePod for not allowing Spotify to work with it. Does anyone blast Amazon or Google for not being able to use iTunes? I'm firmly tranched in the Apple ecosystem and it sounds like the HomePod would work for me just fine.
 

scottlitch

macrumors regular
Oct 8, 2008
155
243
Columbus, Ohio
.. and the problem with homepod is *drumroll* SIRI!

hey siri t.. DING
HEY SIRI - DING
HEY SIRI - nothing happens
hey siri, turn off the lights

(me every evening talking to my iphone, while my gf is laughing at me)

no thanks i stay with sonos for now :)
This is my experience every day. She's not that great. Apple should also take a cue from Alexa and have "Skills" like abilities.
 

Frobozz

macrumors demi-god
Jul 24, 2002
1,146
95
South Orange, NJ
So, Apple’s entry into the smart speaker/home assistant game focuses on sound and not smart. Feels like a miss to me.

I’d argue this is Apples entry into home audio, not home assistant. I’m not saying they shouldn’t compete there, or extend HomePod to include home assistant features beyond HomeKit. They should. But they have been pretty clear about their initial focus.
 

The Game 161

macrumors Nehalem
Dec 15, 2010
30,581
19,783
UK
.. and the problem with homepod is *drumroll* SIRI!

hey siri t.. DING
HEY SIRI - DING
HEY SIRI - nothing happens
hey siri, turn off the lights

(me every evening talking to my iphone, while my gf is laughing at me)

no thanks i stay with sonos for now :)
Actually no for all those tasks it seems to work great
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.