jhomayne said:
that is to say to be able to have one file listed in 2 places in my library. For example, if a track appears on a film soundtrack that i already have on an album in my library i could just tell itunes to link both songs to the same file.
I want the opposite - to link two (or more) different files, in different albums, to have the same metadata. Why? For precisely the same situation as you.
In your case, let's say the album is fairly old but the movie soundtrack is brand new. Chances are the movie soundtrack was mastered so the sound levels are much higher than the original album. Even if not, you can be sure that it was mastered so that it presents a consistent sound level from one song to the next. Therefore the album version and the soundtrack version will be different volume levels, even if they came from the same exact mix. If you use the album file in the soundtrack, then that song will sound quieter than the rest of the soundtrack. If you use the soundtrack version in the album, it will sound louder than the rest of the album. I hate discontinuity like that, which is one reason why I don't shuffle songs very much.
If my wish comes true - and let's face it, it won't; 0.001% of users might agree with me, which isn't enough for Apple to pay any attention to that detail. Urg. But IF it comes true, then I keep the original files in both cases, both mastered to be at the appropriate level to blend in with the rest of the CD they came from. But when I play the album file, the soundtrack's play count and last played time update. Same for vice versa.
I have numerous songs in my library that are "the same" (from the same original tapes) except for mastering targeted to their respective albums. One that comes to mind is Van Halen's
Dreams. The studio recording appears on the original album (
5150) and remastered on
Best Of, Volume 1. The remastered version sounds way better, but if I used that file in place of the album version of
5150, it would lose all continuity. Likewise if I were to go the other way around. Thus I end up keeping both versions, but to get a true count of how many times I've listened to that song, I have to add the play counts of both. And therefore my "200 Most Played" Smart Playlist is flawed!
Yeah, I'm picky. But that's just because unlike Steve and co, I'm actually a music lover!

I know there isn't a chance in a million years that this will be implemented...
