Had the original AirPods since launch and skipped AirPods2 and bought these to supplement them. The main reason for that is having a pair of pods for working out (visiting the gym regularly, and oh yes, sweat will be produced) instead of using my pods, since I'm not feeling 'ok' about sweat dripping on them.
It's probably different for each and everyone, but I like having both products there for different roles.
AirPods
The AirPods being there for easy of use in my pocket on regular days. It's absolutely awesome having them close by always:
Imagine going to the dentist, and have multiple people waiting...POP! plug em Pods in, tap em twice and lose yourself in the music.
Imagine turning off your engine, walking out your car to the supermarket...POP! plug em Pods in, tap em twice and go trough them aisles like a boss.
Imagine waiting in line for the check in at the airport, your NC-headphones in your bag and it's a hassle to take em out...POP! plug em Pods in, tap em twice and smile to the stewardess while gloriously flashing your passport
Imagine
Imagine arriving too early for your date...POP! plug em Pods in, tap em twice and hit on that other girl anyways while not even listening to her.
> Granted, all those imaginations can be done with regular (wired) headphones...but you can't POP! those in like you can easily POP! em Pods in, much less tap those twice!
Powerbeats Pro
While the PBP are there for working out/in my bag, it's revitalizing to know they're close by just like the Pods.
Unlike the video I managed to get them in quite naturally after the first time (maybe because of my POP! experience? The judge is still out on that one), but I wholeheartedly agree that they sound way better than the AirPods.
I have to admit it is mostly because of the PBP being in-ear as opposed to the Pods. Nevertheless I found in-ear to be a better solution—especially when working out—to zone out on the music.
I've never been one for using controls (except for the now famous "tap em twice") on the Pods, but on the PBP I've really come to like it—again because it's easier than using your phone while working out.
I literally forgot my phone once in the locker and managed to listen to music absolutely fine (lockers are close by). Because of that...'trick', I now leave my phone in the locker and just do my thing with just the PBP in.
---
In the end, it's just a luxury problem. If you got the Pods and you like them, you can manage without the PBP.
Unless you got the Pods as a gift and can convince yourself that it's therefore justified to buy the PBP with your own money this time.
> I do not speak out of experience, well okay, maybe a little.
OH!
Did I already say you can also imagine yourself sitting in that boring meeting...POP! plug em Pods in, tap em twice and pretend you're listening back an important voicemail while just blasting away on that new beat you found instead (forget you left the Pods in on purpose if people start asking them questions)?