Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I think the only kind of useful thing it adding it to a key holder. I feel for remotes these are still to bulky, and how would you add them ? With duct tape ? Same for Glasses and all these other smaller items you would misplace. Maybe you can them into your wallet. But thats it. I mean when was the last time you missplaced your backpack ? Or carry-on bag ? Stolen: Yes, misplaced: No. But the airtags are not made for recovering stolen items (30m aren't helpful for that case) and also for privacy reasons anyone can deactivate them (which is good). As written in another comment, I really feel AirTags aren't a good product.

To make them useful you would have to make them much smaller and increase range drastically but then you would basically create tracking beacons which have huge privacy implications and give anyone the possibility to track and stalk anyone else.

Whilst I agree with your first few sentences, I think you (and lots of other people) are also misunderstanding how these things work. You don't have to be within 30m of the item to locate it - you just need anyone of the millions of people with a suitable iOS device to be within 30m of it.
 
It won’t beep unless the owner of the AirTag makes it beep.
No, if the owner of the AirTag isn't nearby, and the Tag itself is "following" another person (stalking), it will start beeping by itself, of the person doesn't have an iPhone but an Android device.
 
My primary use case was to put in my kids backpack/jacket when they go to school. Does this mean I won't be able to do so?
No, but only because you misunderstood what they can do. They are not GPS trackers.
They are the wrong solution for this type of use.
You'd need a GPS tracker (which could be purpose built or just a cheap phone)

Theres so many posters in here that seem to think these are global always on tracking devices. They are not.
They are local to you, with some happenstance ability to be located should someone with a phone pass near them and want to get involved returning them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SirAnthonyHopkins
I keep posting this but stalkers are rare to the point of fictional and theft is common. This is a very silly trade off to favor irrational fear instead of practical reality.
I think your image of a stalker is some random dude. There are many abusive relationships where the abuser will try to use any tool at his/her disposal to exert control over their victim.
 
LOL, I can’t believe so many of you guys think that a device can track you when it only has a range of 30 meters at most. For that to work the person tracking would have to stay within 30 meters of you. If they stay within 30 meters of you, do they really need an AirTag? LMAO. The AirTags are for finding your keys, remotes, or other items you misplace around your home. They are not James Bond style trackers.
LOL at your complete misunderstanding of how this works. The air tag only needs to be within 30 feet of ANY iOS device globally to be tracked 🙄
 
Apple really ought to have put out a comprehensive FAQ for these things.
You really think people would read it? ;)

If you visit the Nomad Goods website they have already designed a glasses Airtag tracker and it looks quite clever.
I really like that (and their keyring holder) - only trouble is that if I put a cord on my glasses, rather than me putting them down in random places around my house, they'll be hanging off my neck which kind of defeats the purpose of the AirTag... YMMV.

Ships by July 20 though, that's a shame.
 
Last edited:
What about this? My wife put one in her purse to keep track of it. I work from home. When she’s going to work, she leaves her purse at home. Will I get annoying lost messages all day long? Or will it learn not to produce them around your own home?

Thats an interesting use case. If it works the same as similar devices, no because it will be set not to alert if in range of your home wifi. But I guess we need to wait to see.
 
"Even if you don't use an iOS device". How does this work? How can an Android user receive a notification about unwanted tracking?
The notification is the beep of the Tag then.
I think the AirTag recognizes other bluetooth devices nearby, even if they don't support Apples FindMy.
And if the iPhone of the owner isn't nearby, it will start to beep.
 
Problem is with AirTags... and a huge flaw with them is... you can just remove the battery... this makes them a no from me, I was hoping to use them in things like a bag or wallet for theft reasons... but a removable battery destroys it being used for this purpose.
You envisage the thief finding a tag, removing the battery and then putting the airtag back again??
Not sure you thought this through.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SirAnthonyHopkins
You envisage the thief finding a tag, removing the battery and then putting the airtag back again??
Not sure you thought this through.
A thief would likely think it’s worth something with it having an apple logo on it, especially if they don’t know that they’re only £29
 
Why can't they go on a dog? I would imagine dogs/cats would be the most lucrative potential market for these things. Can you imagine the tens of thousands of collar designs from third parties?
But then the collar can just have the owners details on it in the first place.
And its not dependent upon turning up near someone that has an iPhone.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I was so fascinated and intrigued by the presentation yesterday and liked the idea, but reading now all these valid questions I can’t keep up with how exactly it’s supposed to work and what it eventually means as a customer. I just hope this is not one of those totally bizarre releases because I was feeling ready to order - not sure now anymore.
 
It’s a shame there isn’t a safe solution to the anti-privacy/stalking issues. To those saying use a GPS tracker for kids etc, the advantage of AirTag is the long battery life and no data contract required.

We’ve been researching trackers for a relative with dementia, they all have battery life measured in days and require paying for data.

Although AirTags have some limitations, the use case for us would almost always involve him being in range of other people. The discreet size, battery life and cost would make this very useful. If the alarm when away from iPhone is a couple of hours this might be enough for us.
 
  • Like
Reactions: derekww
This was exactly what I was going to post. I want these to put on my items of value. If they take my bag and get away, then couldnt they just deactivate them?
The solution might be to develop a stolen mode. That can be activated by giving the id of the tag to the police who can then work with Apple to find it. Stolen mode would keep the tag from making noise or alerting the thief the stolen item has a tracker.
 
It’s a shame there isn’t a safe solution to the anti-privacy/stalking issues. To those saying use a GPS tracker for kids etc, the advantage of AirTag is the long battery life and no data contract required.

We’ve been researching trackers for a relative with dementia, they all have battery life measured in days and require paying for data.

Although AirTags have some limitations, the use case for us would almost always involve him being in range of other people. The discreet size, battery life and cost would make this very useful. If the alarm when away from iPhone is a couple of hours this might be enough for us.
Wouldn’t an Apple Watch serve this purpose while providing other benefits?
 
This sounds like AirTags are mostly to find missing things in your house or things misplaced during a short period of time.

I NEVER lose or misplace anything. Theft protection, however, is my primary use case for these. I was imagining tagging all of my bicycles, motorcycles, travel bags etc. I will really need to know precisely how all this works, time durations before audible alerts etc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bostonsox
i think this was explained, but what if someone stole your bag and then did this? wouldn't that defeat the purpose of having an airtag in it?

Basically they’re useless at finding stolen goods 🤦‍♂️

This was exactly what I was going to post. I want these to put on my items of value. If they take my bag and get away, then couldnt they just deactivate them?
AirTags are not intended as anti-theft devices. They’re for convenience tracking- there’s a difference.

There’s nothing to prevent a thief from rummaging through your bag and tossing your AirTag, or cutting off the fancy leather keychain your AirTag is in (which is exactly what they would do). You would have to actually build or stitch (hide) these into your personal belongings for it to have the sort of anti-theft effect you’re thinking of.
 
i think this was explained, but what if someone stole your bag and then did this? wouldn't that defeat the purpose of having an airtag in it?
I'm thinking 'extended period of time' means longer than say 24hrs or something that can rule out public transport and theirs who hardly keep your stuff with them for more than 24hrs.
 
Wouldn’t an Apple Watch serve this purpose while providing other benefits?
Apple Watch costs hundreds of dollars, would require the user to want to wear it, needs a cellular data plan and requires charging every day.

For someone with dementia this wouldn’t be practical.

I realise this isn’t the intended purpose of AirTags but it’s tantalisingly close!
 
  • Like
Reactions: derekww
I keep posting this but stalkers are rare to the point of fictional and theft is common. This is a very silly trade off to favor irrational fear instead of practical reality.
I think you're wrong.

Look at how serious an issue domestic abuse is globally: those are the sorts of untrusting people who will jump on an opportunity to nefariously track their partner's movements.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.