I can easily do this with the app....
1. Play your video in the app
2. swipe up to go in to PIP
3. swipe down to access Notification Center video pauses. just press play on the NC media widget
4. Lock your phone and audio continues to play
It is crucial that you actually pause the currently running video from the Control Center widget, or on the lock screen the widget wouldn't know about the browser video!Does not work for me, instead offering to play some random stuff from Apple Music.
It is crucial that you actually pause the currently running video from the Control Center widget, or on the lock screen the widget wouldn't know about the browser video!
I have no Google or YouTube login, so I'm watching anonymously and this still works for me!
I have the option to turn it on in general settings. I don’t even have premium
View attachment 2330040
What I have been doing for years literally is always watch YT on Safari. You can have multiple videos opened in Safari tabs etc.There is a MUCH BETTER and easier way to do this (for me on my 13 pro at least). Just start watching any video on Youtube. Swipe up to the home screen. Hopefully the video supports PIP and you can then see the video playing on your home screen. Lock your phone next. Then swipe down to reveal the control center. In the music section of the control center it will just say 'now playing' but not indicate anything in particular. Just click the play button...and VOILA! It's playing with your phone locked. Easy peasy. The Macrumors instructions above are somewhat cumbersome. Cheers
Edit: once in a blue moon the PIP doesn't work for me, and then this method doesn't work. I do not have YT Premium for the record.
Why is YouTube allowed to lock basic OS API features like this? I thought it wasnt allowed
Yes, exactly! 🙂Yes, my mistake was that I was trying this with YouTube app, so your “browser video” bit sent me in the right direction. 😉
What worked for me was this:
1) Open YouTube in Safari (no need to switch to Desktop version);
2) Start playing any video;
3) With the video playing, slide down the Control Center and pause the video;
4) Lock the screen, so it goes black;
5) When you awaken the screen again, you should see the play control widget appear at the bottom of it, so you can press play, lock the screen again and the sound will go on playing.
PS In my case it also jumps to the Dynamic Island for a second, but disappears quite quickly from it if I do not act on it.
The scariest part is that so many don't get this, and still think google is good?Probably because Google is an extremely scummy corporation
This point is so underrated. On the free version, the ads can get annoying enough to get me to stop watching after a while. With Premium, one has to make a deliberate effort to pull away. I imagine in their minds this makes you more likely to keep your premium subscription, so they don’t have an incentive to make YouTube Premium to be less addictive. In my mind there’s a sweet spot where it’s utility is already proven and sinking any further time is a major disbenefit. I wish their algorithms learned this and made it easier to peel away once one was starting to spend too much time on it.While not everyone can or wants to afford YouTube Premium, I think it’s worth it for ad-free and background play/picture-in-picture and YouTube Music. I just wish that Premium users weren’t still subject to YouTube’s engagement-maximization algorithms, since YouTube shouldn’t care as long as you pay.
The YouTube app has settings to remind you to stop watching, with fully customizable times:I wish their algorithms learned this and made it easier to peel away once one was starting to spend too much time on it.
Another person vouching for vinegar. However the only downside is that it doesn’t remember where you were. If I’m watching something and then do something else and come back to the video (especially if safari reloads the page for whatever reason), it won’t remember where I was in the video. Start over! Also scrubbing tends to crash the page.
The scariest part is that so many don't get this, and still think google is good?
Why is YouTube allowed to lock basic OS API features like this? I thought it wasnt allowed
How do you feel Apple allowing this to happen?The scariest part is that so many don't get this, and still think google is good?
I'm not sure who's more scummy. Google not allowing this feature on non-Premium users, or the fact that Apple allows Google to abuse this privilege. But you know, $$$ talks, and Apple is ranking in that 30% cut and the $18B (reportedly) in annual revenue from Google default search.Probably because Google is an extremely scummy corporation
Or use the PiP shortcut floating around on MR or other websites so you don’t have to download stuff to your phoneOr use the free app called x.app that gives you the pip extension to the YouTube app under the share menu.
Well if you're invested in Apple ecosystem, AM is practically the only way to go. Synced lyrics, lossless, Atmos and Spatial to be enjoyed to the fullest if you have AirPods Pro or Beats. Everything goes seamlessly, the interface is synchronized and in harmony with the whole system. YT Music on iPhone is okay, but definitely just for basic streaming and not much else.The great thing about YouTube Music is that it includes music uploads by users, meaning you’re not limited to whatever the streaming service has or has not acquired from music labels. You get rare versions and recordings you won’t get on any other streaming service. To each their own, of course, but Apple Music is of no interest to me, even if it had decent player software.
YouTube Music has synced lyrics as well. I don’t believe in lossless (I did lossy/lossless blind A/B tests in the past, and all headphones are a compromise sound-quality-wise anyway, I’ve compared dozens, there is no silver bullet). Spatial sound can have a wow effect, but in the end I always prefer the original mix, and most of what I listen to doesn’t have a spatial mix anyway. The ecosystem “harmony” doesn’t help if it only has half the music I’m interested in and the UI is a mess.Well if you're invested in Apple ecosystem, AM is practically the only way to go. Synced lyrics, lossless, Atmos and Spatial to be enjoyed to the fullest if you have AirPods Pro or Beats. Everything goes seamlessly, the interface is synchronized and in harmony with the whole system. YT Music on iPhone is okay, but definitely just for basic streaming and not much else.
YouTube Music has synced lyrics as well. I don’t believe in lossless (I did lossy/lossless blind A/B tests in the past, and all headphones are a compromise sound-quality-wise anyway, I’ve compared dozens, there is no silver bullet). Spatial sound can have a wow effect, but in the end I always prefer the original mix, and most of what I listen to doesn’t have a spatial mix anyway. The ecosystem “harmony” doesn’t help if it only has half the music I’m interested in and the UI is a mess.
Apple likes to promote the illusion that it’s all integrated and seamless and worry-free, but in reality it always comes apart at the seams and you end up fighting with limitations and issues anyways.