Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I'm genuinely curious to test this as I'm getting the 4K as soon as preorders open.
I'm not expect 100% accurate results, but it'll still be interesting.
 
I often find TVs at the store turn movies into looking like commercials or cheap TV shows. I wish I knew what was actually off but I take new TVs home and play with them for awhile until a movie looks like a movie. That’s not very scientific... but I don’t buy new TVs often enough to develop a system.
I think it has something to do with the scanning frequency rate at which the picture on the screen is displayed. i have noticed that on my LG OLED that the movies look stage plays and that you can tell that older tv shows were shot on sound sets.
 
Anyone else getting a error message it’s unable to measure when trying it out? Seems about as unreliable as the wireless audio sync calibration.
 
Actually no. Generally you want cooler colors for an accurate picture. People are more attracted to warmer colors because they pop more but it’s not a color accurate picture.

Does your calibration make every person look tan and red? If so, it’s way too warm and that was what I was afraid of.
Most TVs are calibrated cooler from the factory in their "standard" modes than they should be. The warmer modes tend to be their "cinema" settings, but those aren't usually the default settings.

And in lot of cases, the "cinema" settings are closer to accurate than the "standard" settings.

So how do you have the new Apple TV4K when it can’t even be pre-ordered until 4/30? Hmmmm?
You don't need the new Apple TV. Works on old models as long as you're running the latest beta.

I wish Apple had gone even further, and help users also calibrate optimal brightness/backlight, contrast, and sharpness.

I am not entirely sure why Dolby Vision isn't supported, as I was able to use Calman Home for LG to calibrate Dolby Vision on my LG OLED TV.
Well, on some TVs Dolby Vision triggers a specific set of settings built for that particular TV.

Furthermore, Dolby Vision is dynamic, so its effect changes from scene to scene.

That said, there still may be room for improvement, since TV calibration varies from unit to unit.
 
Last edited:
This feature as well as the wireless audio sync doesn’t work for me, no matter, what I try: I never get beyond the “Preparing…” step. Apple TV and iPhone meet the proper requirements and settings, the process starts and comes to the “preparing…” step, there it hangs for a couple of minutes and then aborts. Any idea?
 
  • Like
Reactions: QuarterSwede
This feature as well as the wireless audio sync doesn’t work for me, no matter, what I try: I never get beyond the “Preparing…” step. Apple TV and iPhone meet the proper requirements and settings, the process starts and comes to the “preparing…” step, there it hangs for a couple of minutes and then aborts. Any idea?
I have the same issue.
 
I tried it on a cheap 4K Samsung TV and the after the colour balance it seemed to lower the green level ever so slightly, did look better but surprised how little it changed for an uncalibrated cheap TV. The TV was always set to the warmer side and I only tried to originally calibrate it by eye.
 
I have a nice 4K HDR Samsung but the color is all over the place so hopefully this helps!
I noticed a difference in my Samsung 4K for sure. It wasn’t earth shattering, but could definitely see an improvement of the colors - especially the beach in the stock image.

As @EugW said above - on the default settings mine was much cooler.
 
Keep in mind that this calibration applies only to the Apple TV. If you switch to a different device (game console, Blu-ray player, etc.), your TV will not be calibrated. As someone else already pointed out, Apple’s slick approach to calibration only modifies the output of the Apple TV...not the advanced picture settings on the television. If Apple TV is all you care about, I think this is a great little tool. If you switch between devices and want better picture quality across the board, invest in a proper calibration tool or hire an ISF calibrator.
 
you guys ever think that colors are different for everyone. like this is one step closer to getting the ideal experience, for sure, but remember some people think the black and blue dress was white and gold. so maybe we're trying to find an optimal goal that isnt the same for eveyrone
 
  • Like
Reactions: augustrushrox
Maybe not but most people don’t do any form of calibration, so potentially even if it’s not perfect it could be an improvement for the majority.
you guys ever think that colors are different for everyone. like this is one step closer to getting the ideal experience, for sure, but remember some people think the black and blue dress was white and gold. so maybe we're trying to find an optimal goal that isnt the same for eveyrone
The purpose of calibration is to get the output to match how it is intended to look by the creator, not to make it look the best in the opinion of the viewer.
 
I tried the calibration during the normal lighting conditions of when I normally watch TV (don't know if that affects the accuracy) and while I'm certainly by no means a pro at color calibration, the "balanced" outcome looked significantly "warmer" than the original. So much so to the point that it is still jarring after 3 days. I know I can change back, but I've looked around online and of the dozen or so people that have commented on the coloration, probably like 10/12 of them have said their outcome was also "warmer" as a result.

Are "warmer" colors "more accurate" in general?
most people seem to say Warner is better. I personally like whites to look white to me. Not white with an orange hue. I’m more of a fan of white/blues. I know it might not be perfect calibration wise but I always seem to go back to that side of the color of things. Colors look more natural that way to me.
 
It's a gimmick the way Apple is promoting it !

It needs to be Dynamic, to be of any real value.
No calibration of TVs are dynamic. A professional calibrator might give you a Night and a Day profile, but you have to switch manually.

The TV itself usually has a light sensor, and you can enable that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GregoriusM
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.