Pretty similar experience here.
I had a similar experience a long time ago when trying to get a second MacBook for travel as I didn't want my new one getting tore up. Naturally the seller says it's in perfect condition with an upgraded HDD from the 80GB original to 250GB. Also said it was upgraded to 250GB of memory.
He didn't give me a machine revision code to look up info on it (I use Mactracker a lot when it comes to thinking of buying and selling used hardware to refurbish and sell.
He wanted to trade for my current road machine (back then) which was a Sony SZ series notebook. My Sony was a very expensive PC but also starting to show it's age. It could run Windows Vista Ultimate without a problem despite being a 1.83Ghz Core Duo.
Anyway, I meet up with this guy and the MacBook is TRASHED!!! the case had the crack issue which I know would be fixed by Apple but had other issues with the backlight flickering and the screen bezel separating from the lid.
I fire it up and the battery is shot holding with a runtime of less than an hour (I could see the battery meter dropping while in use. Scratches everywhere and of course, an 80GB hard drive installed and less than 2GB of memory. He wanted cash on top from me on this deal since his mac "was more valuable" (in parts imo), and I told him hell no, my Sony SZ was in perfect condition but I reverted back to XP and all of Sony's shovelware to go with it.
I managed the trade, but missed a few details as I didn't have Mactracker handy, and after getting home. I found out I had the same 1.83 Ghz 32bit Core Duo that ran
very hot. The 250GB hard drive was in a wrapper and used (most likely a pull from another machine, but it did work) my final pet peeve was he promised me the latest iLife with it which was a copied disk image on the 80GB drive.
I felt like I got kicked in the head that day but did get it refurbished but it cost me more to fix it up than most and should have just kept my Sony notebook. Oh well. We all learn a hard lesson.
Come to think of it, my latest posting I have up is I want a 27" Intel Core i7 iMac. I offered up for trade more than plenty for the value which is my 13" MBP (upgraded to 8GB of memory and a 750G Western Digital Scorpio Black series 7200 RPM Hard Drive) all under warranty and a 27" Apple LED Cinema Display. I can't count how many stupid offers I've gotten from Nigerian shipping scams to people offering me previous generation 21" Core 2 iMacs... One would think that the hardware I have well over $2000 worth of barely used equipment and getting $800 dollar lowballs for the entire setup.
I decided hell with it, I'm keeping it. I love my 27" ACD.
