Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Blorzoga

macrumors 68030
Original poster
May 21, 2010
2,560
66
Is it just me or does this whole music-in-the-cloud thing seem a bit boring? I mean, I have my music on my phone and my iPad and my computer. Is it really that exciting that I can access it from the cloud? I have plenty of storage space on my devices already. How many songs could one possibly have that they needed to store them in the "cloud".
 
That is a good point, one which I share. It does not make sense and I believe it won't be much of a deal, maybe Apple is launching this "revolutionary app" to make up for MAYBE the lack of a new phone. It's my opinion at least...
 
How can something that has not been announced and we know no facts about be boring?
 
Personally I like the idea. It will make it easier with multiple computers. I am VERY interested in the amount of storage available as videos take up a LOT of space on my HD. I would like to put them all in the "cloud" so I have room to put windows back on my MBP.

Hopefully it lives up to my expectations. :)
 
wait until Apple announces what it will be ... every service and product is not for everyone

you may just very well like it
 
Is it just me or does this whole music-in-the-cloud thing seem a bit boring? I mean, I have my music on my phone and my iPad and my computer. Is it really that exciting that I can access it from the cloud? I have plenty of storage space on my devices already. How many songs could one possibly have that they needed to store them in the "cloud".
14GB of legit music (not counting videos) and a 16GB iPhone. That leaves 2GB for pictures, video I take and apps. Not happening. I selectively sync and would love the cloud.
 
Based on the rumors and speculation that I've heard so far I agree with the OP... But just because I dont find it exciting and wont really find a need for it that doesnt mean a bunch of other people wont.
 
Last edited:
I have 16GB on my iPhone and my iPad. I made a huge mistake thinking that it would be enough space for me. I have around 50GB of music on my computer. I can't sync most of my music to my devices. To a person like me, iCloud is the solution to everything. I can't wait to get this, I don't even care how much it costs. I wanna be able to finally access all of my music on all my devices.
 
I don't see the appeal either, I enjoy having my music on my iPhone/Computer, I don't want to ever have to wait for it to connect to a cloud or need to have service to use that.
 
OP, I think you're missing the point of cloud storage in general. There are a few good things about cloud storage (not just icloud but cloud storage in general). You can have the same files across multiple computers and platforms, meaning you don't have to remember to copy a file to each one of your devices. It also serves as a great backup in the event something happens to one of your devices (if something happens you'll at least still have it in the cloud).
An example of how that can be beneficial on a phone is the ability to save and sync to the cloud. For example, on my G2X I use Dropbox. I have all sorts of files saved on there like saved html advertisements for my company, resumes, pictures, videos, music, etc. I also have it so that any time I take a picture or shoot a video, it's uploaded to my dropbox (which automatically makes the files show up on my computer in the dropbox folder) automatically. I never have to worry about losing my pics or videos. Also, I can click files in my dropbox and generate links to them and send them to people which makes it very easy to share various types of files.
All in all I think if icloud incorporates these types of features I think it will be a very good app/service to have. I'm curious to see what all features it will have.
 
14GB of legit music (not counting videos) and a 16GB iPhone. That leaves 2GB for pictures, video I take and apps. Not happening. I selectively sync and would love the cloud.

The big question is how is it going to be implemented. And there are potentially huge drawbacks to storage in the cloud as well.

1. What happens when I'm on an airplane, in a tunnel, or in the middle of the fracking desert and don't have a signal? My phone has become a very expensive paperweight.

2. Data charges. With unlimited data seemingly going the way of the dodo bird, how much is it going to cost in data charges to have our media (music, movies, & apps) in the cloud and use them?
 
14GB of legit music (not counting videos) and a 16GB iPhone. That leaves 2GB for pictures, video I take and apps. Not happening. I selectively sync and would love the cloud.

Actually, that doesn't leave any room for pictures because the phone comes formatted with around 14.7 gigs :p.
 
This is the very thing that's forced me to hold onto my unlimited data plan. I could survive just fine with the 2GB plan for less $$. This may or may not be worth it, but we shall see. I'm rooting for Apple, but it could always end up being a turd.
 
Sounds boring, but Apple will find some way to make it sound enticing. Trust me on that one. Can't wait for tomorrow. (not really for iCloud, but more for iOS 5 and Lion)
 
Sounds boring, but Apple will find some way to make it sound enticing. Trust me on that one. Can't wait for tomorrow. (not really for iCloud, but more for iOS 5 and Lion)

What seems "boring" to me is Lion... I mean, Launch Pad (or whatever it is) seems cool, but other than that... it's just basically merging iOS with better incorporation of the apps. What else is different? Mind you I've hardly done any research but it just seems the same to me. I thought that "preview" we got last year was a joke. Of course, my excitement for new OS's was always stemmed from UI changes and such and not so much the functionality.
 
To those that say it sounds boring: I'd have to say that if done right icloud has a lot of potential to change the way your data is accessed and shared on your device. If they're smart they will also make it so that itunes sync to it through the cloud also (from a connected computer) so that it will give you the option of not having to be tethered to a computer to sync.
 
If iCloud it's only Music, then for me it will suck because I live in Argentina and probably it won't be available here. Notice that we don't even have iTunes Music Store, Just the App Store.
 
i dont think anything apple will announce will make us happy

face it they bring out incremental improvements not crazy updates

remember guys

copy and paste was a big deal at one of these events.
:p
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.