Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I know that, but I had to give a logical reason why I need it back asap.
Fair enough. A core part of Apple support is to under-promise so over-delivery is easier. They try to keep expectations (especially of timeline) in check, but there are outliers. I doubt it’ll be months, but parts in transit can be unpredictable. Hopefully it’s made right soon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: progx
The person I spoke to was supposedly a manager. There was no chance a replacement would even be on the table in the future. Even with no ETA.

Don’t replace it with another iMac. Replace it with a Mac Studio + Studio Display.

Ask about this combination specifically.

So I asked for a new iMac and that was a no. Again, I asked about a timeline for repair and there was none given. Other than "20" people ahead of me waiting for the same display.

Because there are numerous cases that people have posted online about M1's getting lines on their displays after about 2 years or so. It's a design flaw of the iMac. And since M1 to current M4 are the same design, expect this to gain even more traction as time goes on.

As you’ve already noted, the design is flawed, so asking for a replacement iMac is not a great idea.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dylan33x
I took it to Apple on January 24th to be repaired. It's now February 12th and zero update.
It hasn’t been 2 business weeks.
It's business week #3 already.

Jan 24 was a Saturday.

Business week #1 = Monday, Jan. 26 to Friday, Jan. 30
Business week #2 = Monday, Feb. 2 to Friday, Feb. 6
Business week #3 = Monday, Feb 9 to Friday, Feb 13

Unless we (you) have a different understanding of what a business week is.
 
You bought some random m1 iMac, not 500 Mac Studio/Mac Pro to ask for replacement like You're a president of the planet, it's 5 years old device, making brand new display takes few days, it's not like You're waiting 3 months for a replacement, jeez, it's You problem if you have no backup system, Apple stopped exchanging/replacing devices just like that in 2010
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: whitestar27
You bought some random m1 iMac, not 500 Mac Studio/Mac Pro to ask for replacement like You're a president of the planet, it's 5 years old device, making brand new display takes few days, it's not like You're waiting 3 months for a replacement, jeez, it's You problem if you have no backup system
be nice, we've all read (or seen) Harry Potter in action, a twitch of the wand and all is good
 
It even crossed my mind to buy a new iMac and just sell the repaired iMac whenever I get it. BUT I'm afraid in a couple years I will be in the same position again because Apple is not addressing this design flaw with a cable overheating behind the display causing lines.
You like macs? But don't want to deal with Apple's engineering? Buy a mini.

Use your own display, one that will not have display cable issues that are present in laptops. Minimize the number of Apple components that can fail. Even if your display fails, you won't be wihout your computer, and if you want to replace your computer, you won't have to get a new display.
 
  • Like
Reactions: klasma
The machine is 5 years old. It is not unreasonable to take a little longer for items not in stock. It hasn’t been 2 business weeks. The repair is not costing him anything outside of what he paid for AC+ already. Apple will take care of him and if it ends up that they can’t get the panel, they will make him whole with a newer machine. No need to start chewing Apple employees out because of a hard to source part.
Where did that happen? You’re the one fan fictioning that here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnWick1954
I just went to the Apple Store. I was reasonable and didn't come at them aggressively.

The Apple associate tried finding an exact M1 replacement but couldn't find any inventory.

So I asked for a new iMac and that was a no. Again, I asked about a timeline for repair and there was none given. Other than "20" people ahead of me waiting for the same display.

So I left without any resolution and thinking it could be months before I get my iMac back.

I am done with Apple.
Phone support is usually much more helpful In these cases. The people at the stores seem to have tighter limits on what they can provide, or at least are a little less giving due to dealing with frustrated humans all day.
 
I had this issue a while ago with a MacBook Pro.

Here's what I did:
- Gather up your repair number and dates you checked the machine in, plus any dates they called you/gave you status update
- Set aside some time
- Call the main AppleCare phone number, tell them you need a working iMac because it's affecting your business
- Escalate to a supervisor / senior / manager, whatever they're calling them now
- Say "I understand you don't have the part available, but that doesn't solve my problem with my business. What *alternate* options can you offer me?"
- You *might* get offered a loaner, but super rare - most of the time at this point I've had a replacement machine granted.
- If they don't offer either, wait 2 business days, and try again. Keep repeating that your business is affected and you have a valid warranty contract with Apple to provide a reasonable timeframe of service which has been exceeded

It may take some pushing, but you'll likely get a new machine out of it. My MBP needed a new logic board and it was out of stock for 3 weeks so I just became a pain in the ass about how I have a valid extended warranty and two phone calls later they replaced it. It's their fault for not stocking enough service parts; not yours.

Also make sure they refund/transfer/whatever portion of your remaining AppleCare to the new machine.
 
OP apparently has never dealt with HP or Dell. I understand your frustration, send a nice email to Tim Cook with facts. It usually goes to a senior customer care manager if you are not over dramatic in the email.
 
  • Like
Reactions: conmee
Don’t replace it with another iMac. Replace it with a Mac Studio + Studio Display.

Ask about this combination specifically.





As you’ve already noted, the design is flawed, so asking for a replacement iMac is not a great idea.
Unfortunately thats not how it works. They will replace with comparable model of same type. I can’t go and ask for a MBP with MBA or other machine types.
 
Last edited:
Drop a sweet new loaded M4 iMac (or better yet M4 Pro Mac mini) on your Apple Card, get 3% cash back, then sell the M1 iMac when you finally get it back (by the time your display replacement is ready there will probably be M5 iMacs if you’re determined to wait it out). How much is this downtime costing your business/work? It sucks you’ve been paying for AC+ this entire time and when you finally need it things aren’t going to plan, but how much longer do you want to go without your workhorse? And at what cost to your business? If you keep getting the runaround, bite the bullet and buy a replacement if every day you don’t act negatively affects income/revenue.
 
Seen this a couple of times.

If you need a replaceable machine it’s best to have an off the shelf configuration and one that is less than 2 years old. Seen horrible repair times on anything else.

I keep a couple of trash machines around for emergencies as I can’t afford any downtime as mine is required for work.
 
  • Like
Reactions: conmee
UPDATE: I got a replacement!

I called AppleCare and explained to them what was said to me at the Apple Store and how I was given no estimate time of repair after almost 3 weeks.

AppleCare then called a repair depot. I was not on this call but I am going to assume the repair depot said it was going to be a long wait for a lcd panel.

AppleCare then reached out to my Apple Store and I am guessing what was said to me at the Apple Store today was not accurate and/or appropriate.

They asked me to come back down to the store tonight and I was able to get a new M4 iMac.

While I don't think the Apple Store handled the situation appropriately at all, and I do think there is a display issue with iMac's which will require a recall in the future, I am satisfied with how this was resolved. It just took a lot of effort.
 
+
You are lucky to even get a new machine. Try dealing with HP or Dell or Lenovo with out a corp/business contract. Apple usually does it right.
Can't speak for HP or Lenovo, but the "corp/business" warranty that my firm pays for on all our Dell laptops is about the same price as AppleCare and we get next-day on-site support. I've had to use it once in the 19 years I've worked here for a laptop that needed a motherboard replacement. My total downtime was less than 3 hours.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TechnoMonk
UPDATE: I got a replacement!
...
While I don't think the Apple Store handled the situation appropriately at all, and I do think there is a display issue with iMac's which will require a recall in the future, I am satisfied with how this was resolved. It just took a lot of effort.
Despite what so many of the "don't be a Karen" types in this thread would want you to believe, the saying "the squeaky wheel gets the grease" is as true today as it was 100 years ago. As proven by you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Unami
+

Can't speak for HP or Lenovo, but the "corp/business" warranty that my firm pays for on all our Dell laptops is about the same price as AppleCare and we get next-day on-site support. I've had to use it once in the 19 years I've worked here for a laptop that needed a motherboard replacement. My total downtime was less than 3 hours.
Now try non corp/business. I have HP or even Lenovo guys come onsite and replace arts or machines. They don’t offer anything close to consumer what Apple does.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZZ9pluralZalpha
Now try non corp/business.
I will (see below), but why? The dude who started this thread uses his machine for business purposes. He bought the best warranty and service plan available to him at the time.

I have HP or even Lenovo guys come onsite and replace arts or machines.
I don't think you quite understand what I'm talking about here. We are only a small firm of about 35 employees (we were closer to 25 employees when I had my run-in with Dell service). We buy maybe eight new machines a year at most. We are not a large corporate client and we're not talking about services that require some special kind of corporate contract (we have never been on a Dell support contract). We're talking about a pro-level warranty offered to anyone buying Dell equipment.

1770955341446.png


They don’t offer anything close to consumer what Apple does.
Well, that much is clear to me. Apple's consumer offering (also its small-business offering) is a slightly-less unprofessional in-store version of the Geek Squad tartted up with a wood-vaneer storefront and a clownish self-aggrandizing name. AppleCare offers a warranty extension and maybe a number to call for help, but that is about it.

Apple certainly doesn't offer anything close to a professional level support plan unless you are buying coverage for at least 200 devices at once.
 
I will (see below), but why? The dude who started this thread uses his machine for business purposes. He bought the best warranty and service plan available to him at the time.


I don't think you quite understand what I'm talking about here. We are only a small firm of about 35 employees (we were closer to 25 employees when I had my run-in with Dell service). We buy maybe eight new machines a year at most. We are not a large corporate client and we're not talking about services that require some special kind of corporate contract (we have never been on a Dell support contract). We're talking about a pro-level warranty offered to anyone buying Dell equipment.

View attachment 2604336


Well, that much is clear to me. Apple's consumer offering (also its small-business offering) is a slightly-less unprofessional in-store version of the Geek Squad tartted up with a wood-vaneer storefront and a clownish self-aggrandizing name. AppleCare offers a warranty extension and maybe a number to call for help, but that is about it.

Apple certainly doesn't offer anything close to a professional level support plan unless you are buying coverage for at least 200 devices at once.
OP isn’t part apple business plan, just regular apple care. Dell will do remote troubleshooting asking to remove screws and run lot of diagnostics, and they don’t promise LCD or display repairs next day. Most often they ask them to be shipped to their warehouse. I have dealt it, some devices like laptops or if it’s logic board issues get better support. Dell service guys don’t walk around with display panels and replace onsite. Corporate customers, usually have loaners for these issues.
 
You're still dealing with a few weeks of time, and it sounds like they gave you an update - when was that? Just recently or two weeks ago?
I think that is the issue, he has chased them up, rather than Apple updating the customer. I took my MBP into an Apple Store (Perth, Australia) in early January, due to a screen issue, and they wanted to replace the display panel, so shipped it to Sydney (where Apple do most of it's repairs). The advised it would take approx 10 working days. If the customer in this case had a timeframe given to them, then the reasonable course of action, if the time frame is to exceed this, would be to update the customer.

I agree, don't get angry or annoyed at the Apple staff, better to be 'disappointed', when dealing with them in store, or over the phone. I find a little sadness, appeals to peoples empathy, and moves things along faster. Just like at a check in counter, don't ask for anything, be sympathetic and nice, and you'll be luckier than not...
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.