Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Actually, I feel like there is little need for iMacs. High end MacBook Pros can run almost everything even the high end 27in iMacs can run at reasonable speeds. If you need I bigger screen, get an external monitor. If you need more horsepower than the high end mbp's, you should probably be getting an Mac Pro anyways. Just my opinion however

That is very true and I have thought of getting a laptop and always hooking having it hooked up to a external monitor or a TV. If I want to take my laptop somewhere else, All I do is unplug it from the TV and done deal.

I guess we need to wait for Macbook Pros to get just a little better, spec wise before we can really say goodbye to the iMacs.

I feel that with the Macbook Pro and Airplay to stream to the TV we will see less a need for iMacs.
 
Large screen needed for developers

I am primarily a developer and also support other normal users in my company. I find that the majority of normal users (non-developers), extending even to AppleCare support, who are dealing almost entirely with normal users, use their computers in a different way than developers.

Of course I am generalizing, and there will be many cases where the distinctions I am about to make are not applicable. Nevertheless, it has been my experience that normal users meet their needs by "single-tasking". I see that they tend to use their applications full screen at all times, so that even if they have several applications open, say Mail and Safari, their "multi-tasking" is really single tasking as they switch between the full screen view of each.

For such users, smaller screens work fine. The extreme of smallness is naturally the smartphone.

So the opinions of such users about screen size and application design are valid within the context of this "full-screen single-tasking."

I would find it very uncomfortable to work this way, as would many others with similar situations.

For example, during a typical session I might have in multiple windows on my screen the following:

  • IDE - Integrated Development Environment
  • Browser 1
  • Browser 2
  • Quickbooks
  • File Manager
  • Mail
  • IM Client - Adium
  • Terminal session 1
  • Terminal Session 2
  • Terminal Session 3
  • MS Word
  • Photoshop
  • plus typically a few odds and ends

The above is an extreme example and I would normally not have so many of them open at once, but it could happen. But it is nearly always the case that I need three or four of these apps visible at once.

My point is that the way I use the system makes the larger screen size essential for work. The smaller screen and related ergonomics lend themselves to the causal or "lounging about" type of use. Or to stay connected. But they do not lend themselves to a full work session.

As a related issue, the trend in the design of Apple softwares troubles me to the extent that Apple's goal seems to be trying to make everything into the iOS model, which serves the normal user, but not the developer.

Bottom line: whether it is an iMac or MacPro with nice screen, the large screen size is mandatory for my daily needs. (iMac vs MacPro is a separate discussion).
 
That is very true and I have thought of getting a laptop and always hooking having it hooked up to a external monitor or a TV. If I want to take my laptop somewhere else, All I do is unplug it from the TV and done deal.

I guess we need to wait for Macbook Pros to get just a little better, spec wise before we can really say goodbye to the iMacs.

I feel that with the Macbook Pro and Airplay to stream to the TV we will see less a need for iMacs.



For many iMac users the time has come for a different idea all together.

An Apple tv set 39 inch 40 inch has been rumored on and off quite a bit.


If this comes out iMac users may drift to it. iPad or new mini iPad would be the remote.

Plus plugin a newer mac mini type piece of gear that boosts this Apple tv set to a really powerful computer.


something like this that docks to your apple tv set


http://www.ecoolgadgets.com/intel-launching-4inch-nuc-mini-pc/

It is an option as your 40 inch apple tv set would have the same exact setup inside it but plug in the second one and your machine becomes a dual cpu .


This still keeps the imac as a line of product if you make a 27 inch model and a 40 inch model, instead of a 21.5 and a 27 inch.

The 40 inch can boost docking to a mini or a better yet a macbook pro to really turbo charge it.
The 27 inch also can have the supercharge option.


This is a bit less portable if you choose to have the mini dock to boost it, but docking to a macbook pro could be the super high end option giving you full portability.


It also really gives you the incentive to own;

a) the imac

b) the new mini or a macbook pro as a booster

c) the new mini ipad as the best remote control that has ever existed.


If you are a work user you can carry either the new mini or the macbook pro to work and plug it into the work place mac.


Plus since you have all that gear you might as well have an iPhone.

The beauty of this is apple can score with tv/movie/music as streaming to this setup. Also get a monthly phone charge.

Not too shabby. With the os merging to the ios looks like a plan to me.
 
I agree with your recommended lineup unless you travel for business - iPad for portability +iMac for home use. i am returning a MacBook Pro that I received last week as I resented the 4.5 # weight and bulk for portable use around the house and missed the comfort of a desktop with better ergonomics, large elevated screen and stand-alone keyboard. (I went for the Pro vs. the Air because I want an optical drive for digitizing a large CD collection)

My quandry now is do I wait for the Ivy Bridge to show up or go for a refurbished iMac? I don't have heavy gaming needs, but wonder if non-Ivy Bridge iMacs will come down in price when the new ones come on the market?
 
That setup I have found is awesome in college… I've got a 27" iMac and 3rd gen iPad and it's a really nice combo! I see a lot of kids with 1000-1500 dollar laptops and I just smile to myself knowing that a beast of an iMac is waiting for me in my dorm :apple:
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.