Which again reminds me of this:
So, if I shouldn't make assertions because I "have no concept of the engineering", and you're happily making assertions, then you must have a concept of the engineering. But you have yet to make a single technical argument, and I'd love to hear one from someone. Teach me. I'm a quick study.
Or at least throw me a bone and convince me you understand the technical arguments. "Another company is working with them and they must know what they're doing so it's obviously all going to work", is not a rebuttal to a discussion of field strengths, path loss, and antenna arrays.
Because so far it sounds like it's ok to speculate that this never before possible distance charging works despite all available evidence, but it's improper to bring up anything that suggests it might not be technically feasible to do what you're claiming (and what Energous themselves are admitting they can't do).
I can't tell if you're just an Energous True Believer who can't tolerate skepticism, someone who thinks every rumor is connected ("Apple is the unnamed company and their 10th anniversary iPhone will include distance charging from HomePod!"), or if we're being astroturfed...
So you said there's only one way, then gave two and ignored the obvious third: Qi could get rid of lightning. There's nothing magic about 3 feet except that it happens to be the suggested range of the hypothetical Energous midfield transmitter.
And 3 feet hasn't been shown to offer anything "impactful":
View attachment 713461
That's from 2015, so you'd think maybe they'd upped their game, but their big demo now is charging a keyboard from 1 foot, not 3. Something
Logitech does with some small solar panels.
View attachment 713459
So you're right-- I don't know for certain that there's not some here-to-fore undiscovered magic happening, but you've given me nothing so far that convinces me that's true. No technical loop hole, no flaw in my argument, not even an existence proof showing something working.
Until you do, I'll remain skeptical that we'll see anyone charge a working phone at 3 feet from a 1W source under FCC part 15, or that we're going to see FCC part 18 consumer products pumping hundreds of watts of RF energy directly adjacent to the high speed WiFi band into the room and focusing it next to people's ears to charge a phone while talking.