That would be a big contrast to the default reason why plenty of Apple's customers buy Apple's stuff - they want the mix of hardware and software out of one hand.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
India to Crack Down on Pre-Installed Apps Under New Smartphone Security Rules
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Well - just see where this has let other companies. Basic apps that used to be included in windows I now have to browse through MS's app store to find. And I have to figure out which are free and which are bloated with adds. Sometimes being faced with a gazilion choices is not the best.
If I buy a smart phone I expect it to come with phone, text message, email, calendar and webbrowser right out of the box. And I don't want to waste time on figuring out what browser might be best at protecting my privacy or who will just sell my data for highest bidder.
Apple is not preventing me from installing 3rd party options for these. They just provide it for my convenience. Not even sure they are profitting on these apps?
Last edited:
The reason nobody cares when Apple includes their own apps is because they arguably aren't bloat. Notes? Calendar? Photos? All these apps for example are severely useful and used by the majority of iPhone owners, some of them crucial to the operation of the phone, like Photos and some other ones like Phone and Messages. And you can remove most of the pre-installed apps if you don't use them.
Samsung is heavily criticized for having bloat because they tend to go the route of "oh hey lets duplicate apps like the Google Play Store and such by creating our own versions of them", which by the way are arguably worse than Google's offerings in almost every definition, especially the Galaxy Store for instance which is in general just a very crappy storefront.
Last edited:
Commenters here understand that. This regulation is positive in many ways. The problem is if it applies to all apps, it means someone will have to be able to uninstall the Settings app on an iPhone. Then what will someone do to do almost anything? Is India going to provide the support to fix the phones in those instances or require Apple to?
Maybe the law is written to avoid situations like that. If so, it shouldn't be a problem. However, politicians don't always understand technology and don't always understand all the ramifications of bills they pass. At least the politicians were talking with some of the companies.
[sarcasme]
No no no... next step is that you are provided with 3 identical options for an app store during install process. You have to guess which app store is the legit apple app store and which that are some scam attempts, that will bloat your device with adds and sneak-install other sh***y apps. That's total freedom which is in fact really good for you.
[/sarcasme]
I think one of the issues is that those device that do this, do this because they don't actually have officially access to the play store because they are running cracked insecure roms to begin with. And then they advertise it as a possitive that they've preinstalled cracked versions of those common apps. You see this a lot on android car stereos as well, with cracked reverse engineered apple carplay and android auto support. It's all rubbish. But the crack down should be on those manufacturers not on having apps preinstalled.
Apple is not investing in India because they are so nice but because they have to!
If I remember correctly:
The Indian government requires that a certain % must be produced in India.
It has been ages since I've switched from Android to Apple, but I do remember going through a significant number of Android phones that had apps I couldn't remove. Carrier apps from Sprint, I remember some third party apps I couldn't remove that I would never use. I remember using custom roms just to remove them.
I don't know if it's the same way now, but it was one of the benefits of switching to Apple--no carrier or advertising bloat. So I'm all for ALLOWING the removal of preinstalled bloat, particularly in cases where you can't uninstall it, but one of the nice things about the latest versions of iOS is the ability to delete apps I don't use like Stocks and such.
I don't know if it's the same way now, but it was one of the benefits of switching to Apple--no carrier or advertising bloat. So I'm all for ALLOWING the removal of preinstalled bloat, particularly in cases where you can't uninstall it, but one of the nice things about the latest versions of iOS is the ability to delete apps I don't use like Stocks and such.
And calculator. We know how important the calculator app is to some people here 😂
Money over the security of a country's citizens? Dystopian/American thoughts my dude.
Ok, so remove safe preinstalled Apple apps.
Won’t this just lead to an increase in users to download from a multitude of potentially spyware or scam alternatives?
Great policy.
Won’t this just lead to an increase in users to download from a multitude of potentially spyware or scam alternatives?
Great policy.
iPhone should have nothing pre-installed, it should just come to a empty home screen when you turn it on. Let your ingenuity guide you as you figure out what to do next. It will also make the Apple iPhone presentations way shorter.
Yes! Give users the option of selecting Chrome, Firefox, Edge, or Safari instead of defaulting to Safari.
In a country with a trillion people they need ways to keep everyone employed doing lots of bureaucratic things that add no value.
Maybe he can release some Indian flag watch bands! When in trouble, pander to an ethnic group.
Agreed. Almost seems ungrateful. I believe VPN companies no longer have servers there because of the security requirements.
Last edited:
Well… look at the options on the iPad. There’s (for some reason) no calculator so you have to navigate through the options of “free” (add filled) or payed options in the App Store.
So imagine they’re forced to remove that on the iPhone!
I'm all for the consumer having the ability to uninstall apps, regardless if they were installed by Apple, Google, Samsung.
Apple preinstalled apps never bothered me much, but recently I got a Samsung for app testing and spent 15 minutes deleting crapware from it. Must have been 30 apps at least.
Back to a pigeon with a note tied to its legs. But do I really trust that pigeon?🤔