Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I understand it would take a lot of money and engineering to develop a screen with a front facing camera with the smaller real estate possible. But it’s been done many times.
I also understand apples face recognition and LiDAR sensors take up space.
But apple had the LARGEST development budget on the planet when it comes to phones.
But it doesn’t feel like it. Apples a master of engineering a problem for us, then slapping a glittery bandaid over it. It’s been the modus for a decade now.
If Steve Jobs were still alive the notch, island wouldn’t exist. He would have told them.
“ no one wants a chunk of their display taken from them, they don’t want the distraction”
But here we’re are. Being distracted.

Innovation hasn’t been apples strong suit when it comes to form factor.
When they get rid of these Fantasy islands and slap an “ M “ chip into my iPhone I’ll start enjoying my new iPhone again. After I pay $1500 for it…
Wait! Did someone say: ‘if Steve was still alive...’ out loud? My bingocard is filling up pretty fast with these gems!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ankaa
This seems to be built into how the phone notifies us, so I don't think it will be a gimmick. I think it looks good and seems to be making use of previously dead space from the notch.

Yeah but now notifications are forked. This is why I wish they'd find a way to make this work with existing notched phones. It's just a fancy banner with a floating area above it anyway.
 
Yeah but now notifications are forked. This is why I wish they'd find a way to make this work with existing notched phones. It's just a fancy banner with a floating area above it anyway.
They absolutely could do that if they wanted. With notch we have the same dead space as with pill just a little bit larger. On iPhone 13 they can just make space around notch interactive in the same way dynamic island works. But ofc they wont do that, its Apple.
 
  • Like
Reactions: aky and CarAnalogy
A lot of really upset people here due to, of all innocuous things, the dynamic island. Weird. Not shocked.

Deep breaths. Life goes on.
I know it's off-topic, but comments like this always confuse me. It seems like every thread there are comments about unclenching, calming down, deep breaths, etc. Why is it people are allowed to be excited but not unimpressed? Both seem like equally valid opinions to share.

On-topic, it's a stupid name but it looks cool. I don't think it's worth sounding the trumpets and declaring that it's the most innovative thing to happen to the world in decades, though. It's just a fancier way of displaying banner notifications and status icons in a way that helps you forget about the hardware elements. Cool, but not world shattering.

*unclenches*
 
Indeed. It's going to be fun the moment people start playing a video that is larger than 16:9 (like many YT channels, most movies, etc) and find that the new "notch" is invading the picture even without going totally fullscreen.

I don't know, man, we're talking about watching a movie on a frigging cellphone.

If I care that mouch about things like that, wouldn't I watch it on a big screen with good sound in a quiet comfortable setting such as my living room?

Seriously, this. is. a. phone. Not a TV. For occasional watching. Your brain will filter out the pill in no time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: spcopsmac21
It's clever and aesthetically-pleasing, very much what Apple is known for. Functionally it adds very little though, and doesn't change the feeling of any non-screen area being a stopgap until under-screen camera and Face ID becomes viable.

Way better than the early hole-punch concepts though, thank goodness...
 


Following the introduction of the iPhone 14 Pro and iPhone 14 Pro Max with the all-new Dynamic Island feature, which intelligently integrates the new pill-shaped notch replacement into iOS for system alerts and functionality, internet users have reacted in an overwhelmingly positive way to Apple's new UX design.

iPhone-14-Pro-Dynamic-Island-3.jpeg

In the US, "iPhone 14 Pro‌" and "Dynamic Island" were trending on Twitter after Apple's "Far out" event as users praised Apple's implementation of the pill shape directly into the user experience. "By a long mile, this is my favorite feature of the new iPhones 14 Pro and 14 Pro Max. Apple really made good use of that long pill hole cutout," is how one Twitter user reacted following the event.



"Dynamic Island may be the best design work from Apple in years," another user said. Dynamic Island includes smooth animations for how alerts and other information such as Now Playing intelligently morph around the camera cutouts to free up space in other parts of the display. Carl Pei, the CEO of Nothing, even chimed in, calling it "smart" and saying that Apple's always-on display on the iPhone 14 Pro and iPhone 14 Pro Max is the "best implementation" of the technology he has ever seen.

iPhone-14-Pro-Dynamic-Island-5.jpeg

"The Dynamic Island is one of Apple’s best designs in recent history. Turning what should be a downside into a useful feature," said Ian Zelbo, a popular concept creator known for his realistic renders of Apple products based on leaks and rumors. Other users also shared their thoughts:



The iPhone 14 Pro and iPhone 14 Pro Max, other than the new Dynamic Island, include an always-on display, a new Main 48MP camera, and more. They will be available for pre-order on Friday, September 9, and begin arriving to customers a week later on Friday, September 16.

Article Link: Internet Reacts to iPhone 14 Pro's Dynamic Island: 'One of Apple's Best Designs'
 
I don't know, man, we're talking about watching a movie on a frigging cellphone.

If I care that mouch about things like that, wouldn't I watch it on a big screen with good sound in a quiet comfortable setting such as my living room?

Seriously, this. is. a. phone. Not a TV. For occasional watching. Your brain will filter out the pill in no time.
 
I don't know, man, we're talking about watching a movie on a frigging cellphone.

If I care that mouch about things like that, wouldn't I watch it on a big screen with good sound in a quiet comfortable setting such as my living room?

Seriously, this. is. a. phone. Not a TV. For occasional watching. Your brain will filter out the pill in no time.
Well seeing as how it’s also a calculator and a camera and a day planner and a calendar and a health monitor and well 100,000 other things…..
We have billions and billions of hours of media played on these “ phones “ and guess what you might be in the 0.00000023% that have this opinion.
It’s a media device.
And guess what? People watch movies on it.
Get over it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: aky and FUTDomi
Well seeing as how it’s also a calculator and a camera and a day planner and a calendar and a health monitor and well 100,000 other things…..
We have billions and billions of hours of media played on these “ phones “ and guess what you might be in the 0.00000023% that have this opinion.
It’s a media device.
And guess what? People watch movies on it.


Exactly, it's so many things. And it does amazing at those things. But that also ineviteably means compromises. It's just the nature of trying to fit as much as possible into a single format.

Get over it.

Oh but I have gotten over it as I'm not getting all worked up about getting minor intrusions into the screen while watching a movie on a tiny 6" screen.

Your brain is an amazing thing. It'll will tune it out. Just as it tunes out your nose which technically is *always* in your view...
 
Don’t hype it so much. Look what Apple did to Stage Manager. Anyway I hope it works as smoothly as advertised and doesn’t end up like touch bar. Lack of 3rd party support killed the wel though out feature.
Agree. I still use an like Touch Bar!
 
I think it's kinda impressive that no news about dynamic island leaked at all. Sure, we got rumours about the pill cutout, but the context was missing in those leaks. The rumours came across as more scattered and less coherent overall. I know people were criticising the pill-shaped cutout, saying that it didn't really save any more space compared to the old notch design.

These people weren't wrong, but it's telling that nobody was able to connect the dots and piece all the rumours together to get a clearer picture of just what Apple was trying to get at.

Not a bad effort made in doubling down on leakers this year, Apple. Not a bad effort at all. :cool:
 
  • Like
Reactions: _Spinn_
It's amazing how people are cheering Apple making the notch bigger and moving it into the display area.

The only thing revolutionary about the dynamic island is Apple's talent in selling it. It proves the reality distortion field is still alive and well I suppose.
Coudn't agree more. Samsung did a great Job @ the galaxy s22. Fantasy island was only made to cover those ugly holes and made it worse.
 

Attachments

  • galaxy-s22_highlights_pro-grade-camera_device-front.png
    galaxy-s22_highlights_pro-grade-camera_device-front.png
    139.5 KB · Views: 75
I was surprised so many commenters on Ars Technica disliked this. This is something I expect will rush to copy. It just looks amazing how they embraced this dead space.
It's dead space because they kept it so big, punch holes are all over the place now and barely noticeable - not saying it's the only solution, but I feel like Apple just sells their gimmicky solution as something revolutionary when it's really just a fancy visual effect. Clever but not actually useful.
 
It's dead space because they kept it so big, punch holes are all over the place now and barely noticeable - not saying it's the only solution, but I feel like Apple just sells their gimmicky solution as something revolutionary when it's really just a fancy visual effect. Clever but not actually useful.
Fancy visual effects make people happy. That’s useful.
 
The best software implementation to compensate for a hardware limitation in a long time. If we have to have notches or cutouts this is clever solution. Is it better than the notch? Not sure but I am glad apple still has people and talent to pull off something like this.
Agreed. It’s like hanging a painting over a stain on the wall: Suddenly everyone’s applauding the artwork!

One masterstroke and the conversation’s changed.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.