I figure I am kind of out of luck. I have a pretty annoying defect on the finish of the metal sides. But I am in a bit of a "catch-22." I was dumb enough to activate the phone, and it is part of the Upgrade Program, so the new loan has kicked in.
I called, and Apple did approve a return/replace, but I have to mail in the 11 Pro now, and wait until mid to late October for a replacement. As you might guess, I can't be without a phone for that long. Heading to the Apple store today to see if a Genius can come up with a plan.
To be honest, my phones live 100% in a case so I could wait this out for a year if I have to and get the new and improved 12 . . . But it's rather annoying.
Update to the above. I took it to an Apple store, and they just happened to have a replacement! They keep a few around for unusual circumstances. New one is great!!
FYI, here is a photo. The metal edge is smooth to the touch, but they either did not get it flat enough or screwed up the coating. [Click to enlarge]