It's just what Steve said about him, and I get what he meant now. He seems better at the financials than the actual end product vision. That's all. And that's really what Apple needed then, when they were experiencing explosive growth. He is managing the business very well.
And yeah compared to other CEOs he looks quite good. Like I said, my main worry is for what comes next. Next for their products, next for their leadership.
I wouldn't sell Cook short on product vision. He's fully immersed in that and sharp as a tack. That's backed up by Apple's success and massive customer base.
It's sad that people sell him short for really no good reasons, other than simply his optics - how he looks, how he dresses, the glasses he wears, how he talks, his chosen lifestyle, etc.
What's interesting is people *choose* to forget that Lisa, PowerMac G4 Cube, Apple HiFi, Apple Socks, etc came to market while Jobs was CEO and leading Apple. A "product guy" as so many here tout. Funny how people forget about that.