Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I have never dropped my iPhone 4, 3GS, or 3G the way this guy "tested", especially outside. A phone doesn't typically spin 10 times when being dropped like this salesman, I mean tester does it. The one time I dropped it outside was my 3G and i dropped it pulling it out of my pocket and it landed face down on a rock, putting a hairline crack straight across the screen.

The only other fumbles came back before I stopped smoking ganja and would forget the phone in my lap and it would go flying when I would get out of a vehicle.

The reason I case my iPhone is mostly for finger prints and scratch protection. How anyone can take a "test" done by a company that fixes iPhones seriously is beyond me. Certainly not Front Page material.


Blonde Buddhist


You're missing the point.

No one intentionally decides to drop it in any particular fashion. It can fall in safe way or a harmful way. A bumper is supposed to protect the device from such accidental falls.

A real testament to a products durability is that it WILL stand up to this kind of drop. Not that it can't. You all seme to have things backwards. The demonstration was real-world. This type of fumble/spin can happen easily. I'll give you an example. Let's say you lose your grip on the phone and its beginning to come loose from your hand. In an effort to prevent it from falling, we bobble the phone in our hand, trying to secure it, so as to prevent it from falling. Sometimes you are able to recover before it falls to the ground. Other times you're not. As youre reaching for it, and bobbling it in your hand, you will inadvertantly create a "spinning" inertia.
 
You're missing the point.

Let's say you lose your grip on the phone and its beginning to come loose from your hand. In an effort to prevent it from falling, we bobble the phone in our hand, trying to secure it, so as to prevent it from falling. Sometimes you are able to recover before it falls to the ground. Other times you're not. As youre reaching for it, and bobbling it in your hand, you will inadvertantly create a "spinning" inertia.

So then it passed with flying colors on the first drop.
 
So then it passed with flying colors on one drop.

This may be more a game of statistics and probabilty. IT could have broke on the first or the last (obviously the last!) try.

One would think that it could hold up to more than a few attempts. What makes number four more unique than attmept one? The recovery time is really not a factor for this material, althouh the person in the video certainly allowed enough time to pass.

The only thing I can think which might cause doctored results is the temperature of the iPhone. Its possible he placed it in a very cold freezer and took it out into the hot summer temperature and THIS is what caused it to break so easily. The coefficient of expansion, that is.
 
The iPhone 4 with bumper lasted only 3 drops before the front glass cracked.

While I'm not going to argue that the bumper had a direct impact on the number, lets stop for a moment and note.

IT TOOK 3 TIMES BEFORE ANYTHING CRACKED.

how many folks walk along and drop their phone 3 times on concrete, much less anything else, in a short period. Probably not that many. In fact I know several folks that in 2 years haven't dropped a phone more than once.

So that it took 3 times of being dropped on purpose, on a very hard surface, for anything to happen is actually pretty good.

Not that ifixyouri wants you to think about that. cause they are in the business of fixing stuff. they want you to think about the tragedy etc. So you will come to them blah blah. My first question to them would be "May I see your certification as an Apple Authorized Service Provider" cause several of the things they claim they can do just seem rather off to me and I suspect they are not approved warranty repairs.

The existence of bumpers just proves that Apple knew about the iPhone antenna issues before they released the iPhone 4.

Hardly. And if they did know about this 'major design flaw' (that seems to only be affecting some .1% of owners, 90% of whom are in an admittedly ****** reception area for all phones) they would have put a bumper in the box to encourage use and thus no one would know about this 'known flaw we are trying like hell to cover up' cause they wouldn't experience it.

Apple now has a PR nightmare on their hands. And yet - the iPhone 4 still sells like crazy. Amazing.

If the iphone is still selling like crazy there's hardly a PR nightmare out there. A nightmare would halt sales. Rather like those defective cars shut down sales and forced huge marketing campaigns to convince folks that the defects were only in a small percent of cars
 
While I'm not going to argue that the bumper had a direct impact on the number, lets stop for a moment and note.

IT TOOK 3 TIMES BEFORE ANYTHING CRACKED.

how many folks walk along and drop their phone 3 times on concrete, much less anything else, in a short period. Probably not that many. In fact I know several folks that in 2 years haven't dropped a phone more than once.

So that it took 3 times of being dropped on purpose, on a very hard surface, for anything to happen is actually pretty good.

Not that ifixyouri wants you to think about that. cause they are in the business of fixing stuff. they want you to think about the tragedy etc. So you will come to them blah blah. My first question to them would be "May I see your certification as an Apple Authorized Service Provider" cause several of the things they claim they can do just seem rather off to me and I suspect they are not approved warranty repairs.


Here's something you might not be considering.

Perhaps it does take 3 drops on a hard surface to break (kind of like the Wise owl and the Tootsie Roll Pop - 3 Licks to the center!!).

Perhaps the iphone was indeed damaged after the FIRST drop. That small microscopic cracks/spiders dveloped not percevieable to the naked eye. After a few more drops, it does indeed break entirely. There could have been tiny cracks at the edges which ave not yet spidered out until the 4th drop.

My point is this, what if you droped it 3 times in 1 month or 3 months (or whatever) without any noticeable damage, and then on the 4 th isolated drop it breaks.

Could it be a cumulative effect which is taking place? If so, thta would mean that each time the iPhone drops, its glass is compromised slightly. Drop it enough and it can no longer stay intact.

Just something to think about.
 
It's a glass phone. I've seen people with Speck cases (3GS, haven't heard about the 4) or similar cases break their iPhones via dropping.

Most cases aren't going to help.
 
It's as simple as "don't drop your f'king phone."

If they would have dropped the phone 50 times and it didn't crack they would have ran it over with a bulldozer instead and gave the "see? you saw it here... can't even run over it with a bulldozer without breaking."

Is anyone else beginning to think all of the negative press might be competitor propaganda??
 
Apple now has a PR nightmare on their hands. And yet - the iPhone 4 still sells like crazy. Amazing.

If the iphone is still selling like crazy there's hardly a PR nightmare out there. A nightmare would halt sales. Rather like those defective cars shut down sales and forced huge marketing campaigns to convince folks that the defects were only in a small percent of cars

Here's the answer:

Is anyone else beginning to think all of the negative press might be competitor propaganda??

They walk among us.
 
Actually no part of the phone will touch the ground when dropped on a flat surface in a bumper....

That's true - - it extends slightly even over the front and back surfaces...

500x_bumperbumper.jpg


Under perfect conditions.

Avoid the spiky areas...

IMG_3777.jpg
 
MacRumors: 2 strikes. Next one you're out.

This is the second time MR has posted a "story" based solely on smack talk by Ifixyouri, whose credibility is entirely nonexistent, and whose entire purpose is to generate publicity for their repair business.

Next time Ifixyouri shows up in my MacRumors RSS feed, MR gets dumped.

If you want to be treated like a journalist, show some integrity.
 
Call me insane...

...but these guys most do something horribly wrong. My iPhone 3G fell down like literally a hundred times on the streets, on the floor, etc. And although there are some scratches the screen never cracked.

My iPhone must be made out of diamond or something :eek:
 
...but these guys most do something horribly wrong. My iPhone 3G fell down like literally a hundred times on the streets, on the floor, etc. And although there are some scratches the screen never cracked.

My iPhone must be made out of diamond or something :eek:

But this is concerning the iphone4
 
Let's solve the problem instead of complaining.

We should be asking ourselves why does it crack after three drops.
Is it the case, is the phone, the gorilla glass, does it break because of the shock from impact or small cracks in the glass. By understanding the reasons, we can then find a case that can protect the iPhone from either shock or just plain starches.
 
The real story here is being missed by everyone:

The iPhone 4 in a Bumper case was dropped TWICE by the sales-weasel, with no damage to the iPhone 4 and only minor scuffing to the Bumper.

Only on the third flipty-flip attempt did the sales-weasel finally break the glass.

So, let me ask my fellow iPhone 4 owners... When you accidentally drop your iPhone 4, are you going to pick it up and keep dropping it until it breaks?

The Bumper did its job. Both of those first two drops probably would have resulted in broken glass without a Bumper.

Next up, the sales-weasel team will shoot a bullet through the iPhone 4 and then complain about the Bumper not protecting it! :rolleyes:

Mark
 
The real story here is being missed by everyone:

The iPhone 4 in a Bumper case was dropped TWICE by the sales-weasel, with no damage to the iPhone 4 and only minor scuffing to the Bumper.

Only on the third flipty-flip attempt did the sales-weasel finally break the glass.

So, let me ask my fellow iPhone 4 owners... When you accidentally drop your iPhone 4, are you going to pick it up and keep dropping it until it breaks?

The Bumper did its job. Both of those first two drops probably would have resulted in broken glass without a Bumper.

Next up, the sales-weasel team will shoot a bullet through the iPhone 4 and then complain about the Bumper not protecting it! :rolleyes:


Mark

As much as I would like to believe that. Trust me I love my iPhone and I have a bumper. But until someone can show us that the same would happen with other phones then only i will believe you. This is why I need to know why the phone cracked so that I can buy the best case.
 
The real story here is being missed by everyone:

The iPhone 4 in a Bumper case was dropped TWICE by the sales-weasel, with no damage to the iPhone 4 and only minor scuffing to the Bumper.

Only on the third flipty-flip attempt did the sales-weasel finally break the glass.

So, let me ask my fellow iPhone 4 owners... When you accidentally drop your iPhone 4, are you going to pick it up and keep dropping it until it breaks?

The Bumper did its job. Both of those first two drops probably would have resulted in broken glass without a Bumper.

Next up, the sales-weasel team will shoot a bullet through the iPhone 4 and then complain about the Bumper not protecting it! :rolleyes:

Mark

Aaaaamen.
 
"The existence of bumpers just proves that Apple knew about the iPhone antenna issues before they released the iPhone 4. It provides just enough distance from one's hands and the antenna. What a coincidence. Apple now has a PR nightmare on their hands. And yet - the iPhone 4 still sells like crazy. Amazing."

Oh don't be stupid.
Cases for iPhones is a HUGE market,
firstly because some people want a slightly softer feel in their hands than metal,
secondly because some people want a device that doesn't slide when you put it on a car seat or dashboard,
thirdly because some people want to highlight their phone's appearance in some way.

Apple wanted to get in on that revenue action, and Bumper performs all three of these tasks pretty well. After getting used to it, I prefer Bumper to my old style case for my old iPhone. That made the case sticky on a car seat (good), but it was also sticky in my pants (because the entire back was a sort of soft rubbery plastic) and slightly a hassle to get out. Bumper provides friction against a hard surface, and some slight give so holding it is comfortable, but doesn't have a sticky back so is easier to get into pockets.

I see no need to posit conspiracy theories about why Apple sells it --- the standard explanation of selling what consumers want at prices consumers are willing to pay seems to satisfy the situation just fine.
 
Ok this is what I think. The phone didn't touch the ground because of the bumpers raised edges. However because the bumper case is flimsy and not sturdy, the shock must have been transferred to the iPhone, causing it to crack. So I think the best case would have to be a really hard case that will act like a shell. Not a soft case. Any thoughts?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.