Where's my proof? It isn't that hard to tell that the material is hard plastic. You can tell by how its shaped and how it fits around the headphone jack. Also keep in mind your argument was trying to prove that your opinion is somehow superior to mine, not the other way around.
Oh and even if the case WAS silicon and rubber, the buttons would still already be pushed down. There's logic for you, this case is retarded.
lol, how are you failing to understand the simple concept?
look, the green case on the left is not the same as the one on the right. the left picture is hard plastic all the way around. The right picture is what *looks* like hard plastic with silicone sides, or at least rubber. It is not plastic as you would need force to depress the material against the volume buttons in order for them to work. Hard plastic would not achieve this.
just because the case is silicone or rubber does not mean the buttons will already be pushed down, how is that logic? i used a silicone skin on my 3GS which covered the volume rocker without any risk of the buttons 'already being pushed down'.
your responses are mind boggling and lack any form of common sense.