Wow. That's an ugly phone.
This just shows how there is so much variation between what different users want. Personally I like this design alot, although I am a huge fan of the original iPhone. I want something more curved that feels good in the hand, but not the plastic feel of the 3G/3Gs. I think a fusion of the orig iPhone and iPhone 4 would be ideal, just hopefully either eliminating the fragile glass back panel in favor of aluminum or liquid metal, or finding a way to make the glass much stronger.