I'm a pretty big Apple fan, and am still considering switching to a 6 Plus (from the 6 that I picked up yesterday), but I find the stuttering in the 6 Plus during certain scenarios to be readily apparent.
I can easily believe that many, if not the majority, of consumers (and even people on MR) can't see much of the stuttering. It's one of those things that some people are more sensitive to than others. I've had friends who swore that their older Android devices never showed any lag, only to switch to iOS (or a newer and much more powerful Android device) and then they suddenly realized their prior phone was "laggy".
The latency and/or stuttering is most apparent when compared directly against the iPhone 6, which is the smoothest and best-performing mobile device I've yet encountered. It also doesn't appear everywhere, but is quite noticeable when scrolling through down a large website, changing wallpapers, switching to landscape mode, and occasionally when bringing up the app switcher and control center.
That said, the 6 Plus has numerous advantages over the 6, including the sharper display and 20-40% better battery life.
If "theverge" qualifies as large website, using cellular or wifi I encounter no lag whatsoever. Maybe folks should consider the network as a possible source of contention. If that is ruled out, then resetting the iPhone.
Other than that, do some tests at a local Apple Store. I would be the first to dump the Plus for the 6 which I originally owned if Safari browsing was an issue because it is one thing I do most on a daily basis.
The Plus FLIES!