I hate to be "that guy" but Steve Jobs would've never released a phone with software that was "incomplete"
He also wouldn't let almost 2 years slide between Mackbook Air and Macbook Pro updates.
No 3.5mm phone socket - No buy.
I agree, but phones age gradually. At some point, upgrading will become essential. But is silly to do that comparison year over year.I agree with everything you said, but slightly disagree here. iOS 7 made my little iPhone 4 completely unusuable and I had to say goodbye. An upgrade was essential![]()
You joined MR in 2006. You should really know better than that.
The early iterations of iPhone OS were terribly buggy. Plus you mention "incomplete" software, yet the first iPhone didn't even have an App Store. Or video recording. Or even copy/paste, for crumb's sake.
Anyone that cares about sound quality is already using an external DAC. Oh... you mean anyone that pretends but doesn't really care...Or anyone that doesn't care about headphone sound quality.
You joined MR in 2006. You should really know better than that.
The early iterations of iPhone OS were terribly buggy. Plus you mention "incomplete" software, yet the first iPhone didn't even have an App Store. Or video recording. Or even copy/paste, for crumb's sake.
No 3.5mm phone socket - No buy.
From the conclusion of the Engadget review:
Boy they really are twisting themselves into a pretzel here. They're "serious contenders for best smartphones", they're "very very good" but they don't meet some arbitrary definition of innovation or something groundbreaking so.... Either the phones are good or they're not. None of this "they're really great but" nonsense. All my friends and family who are on older devices just want to know should they upgrade or not? They don't give a crap if some tech writer thinks it's groundbreaking or not.
Apple only gave reviewers 5 days to use the phone. Most of the reviews feel rushed, have a let's get them over with feel. Not good.
What really got my attention was the iPhone 4, now THAT was special. The retina display was unlike anything I'd ever seen on anything... The touch response was in a league of its' own. The design. The camera. Generally at that stage iOS and the iPhone experience had been refined enough to make it one hell of a product. I was hooked ever since.
You joined MR in 2006. You should really know better than that.
The early iterations of iPhone OS were terribly buggy. Plus you mention "incomplete" software, yet the first iPhone didn't even have an App Store. Or video recording. Or even copy/paste, for crumb's sake.
I'll wait for an objective review. These reviews are well vetted by Apple.
The same reason why if a new Mac is released, reviewers wouldn't compare it to a Core 2 Duo MacBook Pro.
How can you reasonably tell how much better something is, without comparing it to the most recent iteration?