Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
no thanks, had my fair share of java apps prior to android then android apks. Not looking to go through this if available. I'm sure there will be a big warning and opt in process for the user to be warned prior to sideloading
This sounds more like a user error thing. While we're at it, do stay vigilant because things like social engineering with phishing and scam links... that's something even current iOS users fall victim to.

If this is done similar to how you become a “developer” on an Android phone, where you have to very consciously perform a set of actions, then I can at least see the sideloading working out.

I used to do that on Android to use games bought on Humble Bundle, for example.
Got Monument Valley for $5, along with a slew of other, DRM free games. Man, those were the days! :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: BanjoDudeAhoy
And for people who will inevitably say "You don't have to use side loading if you don't want to!"...I find it hard to believe companies won't make whatever the third party App Store version of their iOS/iPadOS app cheaper than on the official App Store. It is quite literally inevitable since it gives them leeway to not be as scrutinized in Apple's privacy efforts 🙂
History seems to indicate otherwise.

For Ebay, sellers tend to lose a lot of business if payment isn't gone through PayPal.

I used be a big, Palm OS techie back in the 00s and into the mid 10s. How people are geeking out on their Android and iOS devices... I and others used to do for Palm OS devices, and the competing Windows Mobile (NOT to be confused with Windows Phone, which came much later, but is now also defunct). Most people didn't trust their purchases on "non-established" sites.

Hell, on Android, the vast majority of folks don't want to go outside of Google Play.
 
And if Apple didn't put restrictions on doing so, it could be even easier peasier to sideload or buy an app from an alternative app store but Apple doesn’t let iPhone users vote with their $$$ to do so.
Other than the EU it’s a take it or leave it package. You don’t get to pick and choose what you want to vote your $$$ with.
 
I wish they would, actually.

Google didn't/doesn't like the way China operates, and chose to leave that very large, very lucrative market. Money isn't the only consideration, and I think Apple should take a stand here.
I'd imagine part of Apple's calculus here is the rising populism in the US as well-- can't exit all the markets...
 
I’m interested in how this applies to other ecosystems. Will Nintendo, Microsoft, and Sony be required to open up their video game consoles to installing software outside their official app stores?
Go ahead, get the ball rolling, and sue them! It seems iOS is a big enough player for this to have happened (rightfully so, as they do have large market share)

I am a German. I don’t like the EU constantly telling private businesses what to do.

If people don’t like how apple handles this they should buy an android or whatever else or the EU can come up with their own phone (lol).

20% of global revenue, what a joke.
Likewise, if Apple doesn't want to do this, they're welcome to pull out of the EU. I doubt it though b/c they couldn't leave China alone either.

Also consider that if you want to work for or with Apple, you're subject to their terms and conditions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: louisitou
I wish they would, actually.

Google didn't/doesn't like the way China operates, and chose to leave that very large, very lucrative market. Money isn't the only consideration, and I think Apple should take a stand here.
Yes. Also interesting that Apple does not have any scruples doing business in China. Maybe that's a good prediction of how this Apple vs. EU spat is going to play out.
 
The requirements for Apple and Google are very different in China. China wants Google to actively participate in disinformation/misinformation campaigns required by the Communist party. I'd hope if Apple were asked to do anything similar that Apple would stop sales in China too.
You know how Apple is constantly making a fuss about privacy and about how they want to protect their customers data with enryption? The Chinese government demanded from them that all customer data needs to be stored in data centers controlled by Chinese entities seperate from Apple, including encryption keys. What did Apple do? They caved and handed everything over. That's how principled they are.

The App Store is also curated to the gusto of the party, but that's probably not so suprising.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ackmondual
EU is kind of amazing, 27 different countries, able to agree and lead globally on standards that protect consumers, the environment and secures a level plying field for businesses. Not perfect, but quite good.

I'd argue that the EU is mostly two countries and that it's not that amazing to pass protectionist regulations that affect foreign businesses to the potential benefit of local ones. They may very well have higher motivations than that, but at the end of the day if they damage a business with this nonsense it won't be a European one.

I've admired the EU up until fairly recently. The EU is a peace initiative more than anything, and it's done ok over the years but I think those benefits are showing they aren't ironclad. I think a lot of their environmental regulations were quite admirable. I think their free movement of people and goods model was a triumph of (social) science over protectionism. I think the 2 nation quality of the EU became painfully evident during the post-2008 financial crisis, and I think they've begun to badly overstep in how they regulate spectrum and now consumer electronics.

All together, I'd probably try to look past recent events and agree with "not perfect but quite good".
 
You know how Apple is constantly making a fuss about privacy and about how they want to protect their customers data with enryption? The Chinese government demanded from them that all customer data needs to be stored in data centers controlled by Chinese entities seperate from Apple, including encryption keys. What did Apple do? They caved and handed everything over. That's how principled they are.

The App Store is also curated to the gusto of the party, but that's probably not so suprising.
That's not completely true. Apple controls their encryption keys in China.
 
That's not true. Apple controls their encryption keys in China.
"Ultimately, the encryption keys ended up in China, a decision that "surprised" two unnamed Apple executives who worked on the negotiations and who said that the decision could potentially endanger customer data."

Quote from the article you linked to. Thank you for looking it up!
 
"Ultimately, the encryption keys ended up in China, a decision that "surprised" two unnamed Apple executives who worked on the negotiations and who said that the decision could potentially endanger customer data."

Quote from the article you linked to. Thank you for looking it up!
Keep reading. They are in China under Apple's control.
 
Keep reading. They are in China under Apple's control.
So what? And when a Chinese security service asks for a key, they will give it to them. Or do you think Apple will sue the Chinese government over this? They would be loughed out of the court room, buy the judge 🤣.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ackmondual
I don't think so. Apple claims they have the keys. But they have to store them in China. Which means effectively they handed them over to the Chinese government.
 
I'll remain on the ios version prior to this feature roll out for as long as possible. The only way to not permit the feature even if not opted in on the device.
 
  • Like
Reactions: strongy
No, it doesn't. That's just speculation and fearmongering.
I would suggest to you to read up on how the Chinese society works. It would be very naive to assume that Apple is in any way able to protect their customers data from the Chinese government once they are stored in China by companies most likely affiliated with state-owned enterprises.

There is an excellent Podcast from the Economist I can recommend to you about China. I think they also covered the Chinese tech sector several times. It's called 'Drum Tower' and you should be able to find it on Apple Podcasts. But don't try to find it on a Chinese iPhone, I'm 100% certain it's censored there ;).

Edit: I just noticed that the Podcast is now paid. It used to be free with ads.
 
Last edited:
I would suggest to you to read up on how the Chinese society works. It would be very naive to assume that Apple is in any way able to protect their customers data from the Chinese government once they are stored in China by companies most likely affiliated with state-owned enterprises.

There is an excellent Podcast from the Economist I can recommend to you about China. I think they also covered the Chinese tech sector several times. It's called 'Drum Tower' and you should be able to find it on Apple Podcasts. But don't try to find it on a Chinese iPhone, I'm 100% certain it's censored there ;).
None of that changes the fact that Apple controlling the encryption keys in China is different than the keys being in the control of the Chinese government.
 
without this legislation, the Vision Pro would lack the necessary component for success; porn apps. The timing is flawless.
I know you are joking but we need to reign p*** in. It’s far too accepting in society today it’s going to destroy us.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.