So you're trying to argue that the OP wanted to argue that the 2019 MBP was a dud in
2017
Just admit it, you totally missed the date stamp of the thread and my post.
I get it, you want to say the 2019 MBP is not a dud, and I'll not argue that, but you cannot use 2019 as a means to justify 2 year old posts are wrong.
You asked what model, I was talking about, well, I was referencing the 2017 model year. I didn't think I had to spell that out to you when I pasted the datestamp of my post in my reply - but there you go I guess I did ¯\_(ツ)_/¯