Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I lost my 17” 2007 MBP in 2021. I mourned it since it served me very well for 12 years and it was completely user serviceable.
It just gave up turning on. It’s still on a shelf somewhere.
Good luck.
If you’ve cleared the data from your device and want to dispose of it, you can recycle it at a local Apple Store through Apple Trade-In. While it won’t have trade-in value, you can still get some discounts. During Earth Day, you can also get discounted AirPods, OEM Apple Watch bands, iPhone cases, and other accessories. I did this earlier this year when my Apple Watch Series 1 gave up after eight years. The screen separated, and the battery was shot.
 
My MacBook Pro M4 Pro still has a low cycle count! I last checked it, and it was around 37 cycles, and I’ve had it since July. It’s always plugged in on my desk and only unplugged when I’m traveling or heading to the living room. My iPhone 15 pro, while it’s battery is dated may 2024 but I owned it since January, is at 486 cycles at 91% battery health. My Mac is still at 100% like the beginning.

I also use the Al Dente app, the battery stats and charge limit app that my friend uses, and he has a similar MacBook Pro like mine. Also got the full version from an in app purchase. We both bought our Macs around the same time.


Good call! A single beep rly makes sense that it’s a RAM problem associated with the restricted 🚫 screen at startup. So was the RAM sticks faulty or is it the amount that isn’t compatible with your MacBook Pro 💻?
Not sure it's all down to them. I bought 2 x 4GB from Megamac in 2018 so the 8GB lasted 7 years. I don't know what the life of those RAM modules are supposed to be or why they suddenly fail, but they certainly don't work now. The original 2 x 2GB didn't beep when I put them back in, and they did start it up, but it's still a fail. More amazed I still had them and found them. I didn't realise you could put 2 x 8GB in them. Thought it would be incompatible. Had I known, I'd have bought some of them years ago. Don't know if it would have speeded much up, but sure would have been a help with multi tasking?

I lost my 17” 2007 MBP in 2021. I mourned it since it served me very well for 12 years and it was completely user serviceable.
It just gave up turning on. It’s still on a shelf somewhere.
Good luck.
Thanks. I feel your pain. So about the same shelf life as mine then. I think it's also something to do with giving up the power with those old MBPs, because it was so easy to change the battery, SSD, RAM etc., which you don't have on the current iterations. You get what you get now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Luis Ortega
I always found the cycles a bit off. When battery was new, Coconut always showed me more than I thought I'd charged. When it wasn't a full cycle, and only charged half, it still counted as a full cycle, so was never sure how accurate it was.
It's just reading the cycles from macOS. If you look in System Information, you can see the same number there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Peter Franks
Not sure it's all down to them. I bought 2 x 4GB from Megamac in 2018 so the 8GB lasted 7 years. I don't know what the life of those RAM modules are supposed to be or why they suddenly fail, but they certainly don't work now. The original 2 x 2GB didn't beep when I put them back in, and they did start it up, but it's still a fail. More amazed I still had them and found them. I didn't realise you could put 2 x 8GB in them. Thought it would be incompatible. Had I known, I'd have bought some of them years ago. Don't know if it would have speeded much up, but sure would have been a help with multi tasking?


Thanks. I feel your pain. So about the same shelf life as mine then. I think it's also something to do with giving up the power with those old MBPs, because it was so easy to change the battery, SSD, RAM etc., which you don't have on the current iterations. You get what you get now.
You can get away with higher than 16gb ram if you open core your MBP, but that’s all good as long it’s 8gb or higher ram for newer macOS versions
 
  • Like
Reactions: Peter Franks
You can get away with higher than 16gb ram if you open core your MBP, but that’s all good as long it’s 8gb or higher ram for newer macOS versions
I think it's too knackered to cope with that or open core. I did ask about that once before, but I think that ship has sailed?
 
  • Like
Reactions: goldmac2006
I think it's too knackered to cope with that or open core. I did ask about that once before, but I think that ship has sailed?
Just a heads-up: the Open Core Legacy Patcher is going away soon, as macOS Tahoe is the last macOS version for Intel Macs. 💻

It’s not often that pre-2015 or non-Retina MacBook Pros get macOS Tahoe because Liquid Glass needs modern hardware and graphics. I’ve even seen videos of older Macs with OCLP not working because of that, and many Liquid Glass features wouldn’t load or took ages to load.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Peter Franks
Just a heads-up: the Open Core Legacy Patcher is going away soon, as macOS Tahoe is the last macOS version for Intel Macs. 💻

It’s not often that pre-2015 or non-Retina MacBook Pros get macOS Tahoe because Liquid Glass needs modern hardware and graphics. I’ve even seen videos of older Macs with OCLP not working because of that, and many Liquid Glass features wouldn’t load or took ages to load.
I'd have been happy with something remotely more modern than High Sierra on the MBP, not Tahoe, but something in last 5 years or so
 
  • Like
Reactions: goldmac2006
In all honesty, I don't know, anything past Mohave and a dark mode would be an improvement, But I know I should upgrade the MBP rather than try and repair
 
  • Like
Reactions: goldmac2006
In all honesty, I don't know, anything past Mohave and a dark mode would be an improvement, But I know I should upgrade the MBP rather than try and repair
What kind of things do you do on your Mac?

Are you using Xcode, engineering tools like AutoCAD and F360, and/or maybe video or graphic editing? Or do you enjoy playing video games a lot on your Mac?

I’d love to hear more about what you do, and I’ll do my best to help you! .
 
  • Like
Reactions: Peter Franks
What kind of things do you do on your Mac?

Are you using Xcode, engineering tools like AutoCAD and F360, and/or maybe video or graphic editing? Or do you enjoy playing video games a lot on your Mac?

I’d love to hear more about what you do, and I’ll do my best to help you! .
Sorry man, just seen this. In a nutshell …
👇

I’ve used Garageband and iMovie, but have zero experience of Logic or Final Cut. I mainly use for Photoshop, a lot of emails, listening to music, web, plenty of YouTube, I do need to do Film and Music editing, but does Garage/iMovie still exist now, and will have to try web building again. 32GB would maybe be nice, but 24 it is, but hopefully won’t need with what I do. Although….. I’m amazed the M5 doesn’t come with any kind of Power Adapter.

I don’t know whether the CPU or GPU will make a difference to me? I don’t really understand it much if I’m honest.For external drives I assume the Thunderbolt 4 or 5 is negligible. Not sure what else I’d need them for?
 
  • Like
Reactions: goldmac2006
Sorry man, just seen this. In a nutshell …
👇

I’ve used Garageband and iMovie, but have zero experience of Logic or Final Cut. I mainly use for Photoshop, a lot of emails, listening to music, web, plenty of YouTube, I do need to do Film and Music editing, but does Garage/iMovie still exist now, and will have to try web building again. 32GB would maybe be nice, but 24 it is, but hopefully won’t need with what I do. Although….. I’m amazed the M5 doesn’t come with any kind of Power Adapter.

I don’t know whether the CPU or GPU will make a difference to me? I don’t really understand it much if I’m honest.For external drives I assume the Thunderbolt 4 or 5 is negligible. Not sure what else I’d need them for?
For photoshop 24GB RAM will cut it. It ain’t Hollywood level photo and video editing stuff so it should be fine.

Web development you should get a pro or max chip for faster compiling times. Do you code a lot or build iOS apps?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Peter Franks
I have tried numerous times to switch on, and if I ever get past the log in, in less than a minute the first ‘problem’ pic appears, followed by the second, and then sits on apple logo till I power off. Or more often than not, it turns itself off. Nothing seems to help. I tried to start in safe, but that fails also, and I dare say would switch itself off again if it ever did.

Question being, I realise this is a 2011 MBP running High Sierra and it owes me nothing, but I’ve relied on it most days and it would be good to get something out of it. I don’t find the iPad I’m on now as easy to do stuff on at all. I’d like to think the SSD is still OK, but I’m beginning to wonder, as my last back up is a fair while ago. Any advice, other than throw it away, would be most appreciated.

I assume the problem isn’t because of the drive as it switches off and is deeper than that? Or I’d swap out drive.

Thanks for any help.
Install High Sierra* on an external drive (good time for a cheap SSD), and use Migration Assistant to import from the internal.

(*Or Mojave, with the DosDude1 patch; it works very well on the 2011s. Either way, you'll want to disable MRT, MDS_stores, Spotlight Indexing, and Reportcrash in Terminal to save a gig of ram and speed up noticeably. Install FindAnyFile as a replacement for the built-in search function. Note: do not run either OS in an APFS file-system on a rotational drive save as a stopgap before using a tool such as Carbon Copy Cloner 5 to clone it to a Disk Utility-created MacOS Extended-journaled partition.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Peter Franks
For photoshop 24GB RAM will cut it. It ain’t Hollywood level photo and video editing stuff so it should be fine.

Web development you should get a pro or max chip for faster compiling times. Do you code a lot or build iOS apps?
Definitely not that advanced. Code? Wouldn’t have a clue mate. I’m probably quite basic.
Install High Sierra* on an external drive (good time for a cheap SSD), and use Migration Assistant to import from the internal.

(*Or Mojave, with the DosDude1 patch; it works very well on the 2011s. Either way, you'll want to disable MRT, MDS_stores, Spotlight Indexing, and Reportcrash in Terminal to save a gig of ram and speed up noticeably. Install FindAnyFile as a replacement for the built-in search function. Note: do not run either OS in an APFS file-system on a rotational drive save as a stopgap before using a tool such as Carbon Copy Cloner 5 to clone it to a Disk Utility-created MacOS Extended-journaled partition.
Yeh, I did upgrade to the APFS on most but no idea why, It’s interesting you mention MDS stores, whenever I check utility and the ones that are making fan do 100 it’s usually always them in the mix.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Minghold
  • Like
Reactions: Peter Franks
I remember using Photoshop in 1gb ram on a white iMac running Snow Leopard, and it was snappy. --Everything is leaden bloatware now.
Indeed decades ago 8GB to 16GB RAM was a top notch upgrade for macs including early versions of MacBook Pro, but latest developments in 64 bit apps, AI enabled features and graphics cards demand more on RAM and CPU usage.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Peter Franks
There are some great Black Friday MacBook Pro M5 deals out there....
No there aren't. Black-Friday sales of last-year models are one of the biggest rip-offs in advertising. Especially for "newish" M-chip MBs, which are going to crater another 75% within three or four years until they're no higher valued than used intel Macs than can run twice the software (32bit access) with no security-chip headaches.
For a long while now.
Efficient coding hangs on: Reaper DAW comes to mind, under 100mb versus multi-GB LogicPro.
 
I remember using Photoshop in 1gb ram on a white iMac running Snow Leopard, and it was snappy. --Everything is leaden bloatware now.
I never wanted to give that up, Snow Leopard I would've used forever and a day. Don't know what it was about it, but it was a big fave.
Indeed decades ago 8GB to 16GB RAM was a top notch upgrade for macs including early versions of MacBook Pro, but latest developments in 64 bit apps, AI enabled features and graphics cards demand more on RAM and CPU usage.
I don't suppose I would notice any difference between the M5 and the M4Pro for what I do now.
 
No there aren't. Black-Friday sales of last-year models are one of the biggest rip-offs in advertising. Especially for "newish" M-chip MBs, which are going to crater another 75% within three or four years until they're no higher valued than used intel Macs than can run twice the software (32bit access) with no security-chip headaches.

Efficient coding hangs on: Reaper DAW comes to mind, under 100mb versus multi-GB LogicPro.
I never wanted to give that up, Snow Leopard I would've used forever and a day. Don't know what it was about it, but it was a big fave.

I don't suppose I would notice any difference between the M5 and the M4Pro for what I do now.

Apologies for the late reply—I’ve been busy!

For Mac users thinking about upgrading from an older MacBook Air or MacBook Pro, I’d suggest sticking with an ARM-based MacBook Pro. If the OP isn’t using anything resource-heavy, the MacBook Pro M1 Pro base model or anything higher should work just fine, but it’s up to you!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Peter Franks
For Mac users thinking about upgrading from an older MacBook Air or MacBook Pro, I’d suggest sticking with an ARM-based MacBook Pro.
Those persons who liked their Intel-era MBs may be and often are disappointed with Apple's more recent machines. In particular, they cannot run much if any of their existing paid-for software (such as, say, CS6, FCP7, Pro Tools, etc) and are thus trapped in subscription-model hell, and the OS is now incredibly obtuse, ram-hungry beyond any rational reason, ridden with telemetry, and has a very Microsoft mentality when it comes to honoring the user's manual changes to system settings (such as instructing it to not auto-update).
 
Apologies for the late reply—I’ve been busy!

For Mac users thinking about upgrading from an older MacBook Air or MacBook Pro, I’d suggest sticking with an ARM-based MacBook Pro. If the OP isn’t using anything resource-heavy, the MacBook Pro M1 Pro base model or anything higher should work just fine, but it’s up to you!
Because of reasons below?
Those persons who liked their Intel-era MBs may be and often are disappointed with Apple's more recent machines. In particular, they cannot run much if any of their existing paid-for software (such as, say, CS6, FCP7, Pro Tools, etc) and are thus trapped in subscription-model hell, and the OS is now incredibly obtuse, ram-hungry beyond any rational reason, ridden with telemetry, and has a very Microsoft mentality when it comes to honoring the user's manual changes to system settings (such as instructing it to not auto-update).
That's interesting and something I'd not thought about before, Are you saying that things I use like Microsoft Word and Photoshop that I've used for decades are not just one and done anymore, and I have to pay subscriptions to be able to use new versions of them? They both were pre Sierra and was told they wouldn't work on High Sierra, but they both did. I know they're finished after HS, and would have to splash out on new software?
 
  • Like
Reactions: goldmac2006
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.