Jetson said:
Yes, you can use the Join CD Tracks feature which is nice, but it's still a bit clunky and could use some refinement. It would be nice to be able to select "no pause between tracks" for playlists or selected portions of playlists.
The "Join CD Tracks" feature is flawed, IMO. Once you join tracks, yes the gap is gone. But you lose the actual "tracks" in the process!
Ex: If you rip Tracks 1-3 joined, then your track 4 will be listed as track 2 once ripped.. And you can't skip to the real tracks 2 and 3 anymore.
I'm not against the actual "joining of tracks" on the technical side (maybe the iPod's decoder has limitations, I dunno), but at least put some metadata in the joined tracks so the result is transparent to us (except that you cannot separate the joined tracks anymore, while updating the iPod for exemple. Just warn the user "tracks 1 to 3 are joined, you cannot separate them" or something).
Join tracks 1-3 on rip? Sure. But put metadata in the ripped file to say where track 1 begins/ends, where track 2 begins/ends and where track 3 begins/ends. Then, hide the single file from my sight in iTunes and iPod (still works/displays as usual, from the metadata inside that "3-tracks-in-one" file).
In fact, iTunes should be able to detect zero gap between the tracks and link the tracks itself, without any user intervention! (it's not about deciding if the end of a track matches with the start of the next track, there really is a written gap between tracks. It's usually 2 seconds, but for "gapless tracks" it's zero). Why can't iTunes also do that on top of my idea above? <g>
It's not THAT hard, is it?!
That's my only real complaint about iTunes/iPod right now.
Edit: just tried ripping Les champs magnétiques again (Jean-Michel Jarre), and I end up with a single "track 1 of 5" instead of 5 tracks.
Steve, tell your guys to fix that!