Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Here are my potentially dumb questions:
1. If I do buy a CD, would I still be able to upload the music?
2. I do create a lot of home videos. Will there still be a mechanism to import them so I can carry them on my iPad? I use iTunes to manage the (home) videos on my iPad and iPhone.

Thanks to anyone who has some insight on these topics.

All Apple has done is rename iTunes and separate some types of media. I doubt much has changed regarding syncing; Apple remove books from iTunes yet they sync normally.
 
Maybe I haven’t looked hard enough but what happens to iTunes on Mojave and prior? Does the app separation apply to OSX prior to 10.15 as well?
 
ok, time to switch over to windows!

You will be disappointed if you switch for iTunes. I'm actually disappointed to hear this news. I use iTunes to manage and sync music on my iPhone, and I can't for the life of me understand why it is one of the least reliable pieces of software that I've ever used. I used to use it to back up my iOS devices, but I've switched to iCloud after iTunes was unable to do the simple task of using a backup to set up a new iPhone. Wireless syncing almost never works for me either.

So in short, I was looking forward to a replacement that hopefully Apple had taken the time to finally improve. I'd almost swear that they make iTunes for Windows bad on purpose to encourage people to switch to Macs.
 
As someone who switched back to Windows two years ago, I'm really curious where they're going to go with iTunes/Apple Media on Windows. It would be nice if they'd offer more assurances than "iTunes is still around for now." This is especially true after they locked down the iOS/iPadOS betas to requiring a Mac to install the ipsw.

So your name is macbook guy, you regularly use iPad, iPhone, iOS and iTunes... and you switched back to windows?!? Just curious...
 
Maybe I haven’t looked hard enough but what happens to iTunes on Mojave and prior? Does the app separation apply to OSX prior to 10.15 as well?
Good question. I don’t think so, or they would have released them as beta apps for older macOS versions by now.
 
I am very happy Apple finally separated important functions that are not relative to music and videos from iTunes... Like backing up your iPhone or syncing... I always thought iSync were meant to, well you know, SYNC!

Then they started cluttering iTunes with the App Store and, okay, Podcasts... Podcasts still are multimedia... but the main goal of iTunes was lost... MANAGE AND PLAY MUSIC.

The fact that now you can sync directly from the finder is a most welcome feature... Just like plugging an external hard drive... or do you want to open iTunes to copy file to your external drives?
 
Wee!!

4ad4a84c-6bc8-49c2-b001-82aaa3f30f31


At least fix your game Apple, not everybody uses a 100% scaling.
 
I suppose it's because iOS devices are managed within Finder via macOS 10.15 Catalina. Not sure how they will get around that on Windows. Hopefully they come up with something.

In Windows, iTunes is completely self contained, as it has to work within the Windows environment and the NTFS file system. I have no insider knowledge of this, but I am betting iTunes even on Windows is not long for this world... at the very minimum it will be rebranded, or eventually split into the same 3 apps as is happening in the macOS environment now.
 
Dang, I was hoping they'd kill it with fire. Never liked itunes - has been an un-intuitive torture to use since day one and only gets worse.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheSapient
I’m thankful for this. Our iTunes library on our PC is very well organised and everything just syncs so easily.
 
lol wait, so if you install Catalina you can't access your movies and TV shows because that app isn't out yet? omg....

It's as if this software wasn't ready for primetime yet. I wish they would call it a beta or something! /s
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr. 123
I still wished there was a way to manage apps on my phone/ipad via itunes- I mean being able to easily shuffle icons around or add/remove apps like how we used to be able to do years ago.
 
Here are my potentially dumb questions:
1. If I do buy a CD, would I still be able to upload the music?
2. I do create a lot of home videos. Will there still be a mechanism to import them so I can carry them on my iPad? I use iTunes to manage the (home) videos on my iPad and iPhone.

Thanks to anyone who has some insight on these topics.

Per number two, I don't have insider knowledge but I expect this will still be true and possibly even simpler. They mentioned that sync will now happen via finder. Sync is what has done that in iTunes to date. With the new iPad support for SMB and external storage we may even just be able to drop media on our device and not need a specific "sync" if we don't want it.
 
Yeah - I know iTunes is the STORE, obviously. Apple can't incorporate buying Music & TV Shows/Movies through the individual apps instead? iTunes is just a bloated mess, ESPECIALLY on Windows. Why get rid of it here and not there? Let's confuse the public even more. :rolleyes:

Why get rid of it AT ALL??? o_O

I'd like someone to explain to me exactly WHAT is "bloated" about it after all these YEARS of hearing about "bloat" that doesn't exist. WHAT is bloated about it?

Is KODI "bloated" because it handles music, tv shows, movies and has streaming plugin options? Does that make it BLOATED because it handles all MEDIA in one program?

What do you hope to gain by having separate programs for MEDIA when it's ALL MEDIA???

Multiple confusing GUI interfaces with no interaction? No combined playlists? Separate stores? Separate media types? Instead of having one place to view all media, you want maybe 12? 15 even?

I'm sorry, but splitting up one thing (MEDIA) into multiple apps is Stupid with a capital S. It's just a button on an AppleTV 4, but on a Mac it's multiple dock spaces, multiple programs, multiple interfaces and multiple problems when one app gets updated and the others lag. I mean who does podcasts in 2019? That many? Wow. I haven't watched or listened to one in about 8 years now. Might as well dump it period. Apple is already putting "owning" music on the back burner. Push Apple Music and renting over owning. My Internet went out twice today at home for about 5 hours total. No streaming. NONE. Go hiking in a remote area? No music. Drop your phone? Sorry, but your car has no music again unless you enjoy commercial ridden FM. Why have a few thousand songs on a USB stick in the car at all times when you can use your phone and RENT music? It's the future. It's GREAT too! Just ask Rent-A-Center how much they enjoy renting your furniture for 10 years where you've paid for it 4-5x over and still don't own it at all.

did you not see the new affordable mac pro+display?

Oh yeah! $6000 for the base computer and $6000 more for the display (and ANOTHER $1000 more for a "Pro" stand to put the display on!) Now THAT ($13,000 for the BASE MODEL!) is what I call AFFORDABLE, especially comparable to the previous "cheese grater" Mac Pro that started out at $2000. I can't wait to buy one! Maybe two even! And the BEST news of all? As near as I can tell, it doesn't even have PCIe 4.0 that comes out this summer for Windows machines and blows the previous PCIe bus out of the water! Way to stay up to date Apple! FINALLY release a new "Mac Pro" after a half decade and it will already be out of date by the time the first one ships! WTF Apple!!! :eek:
 
You will be disappointed if you switch for iTunes. I'm actually disappointed to hear this news. I use iTunes to manage and sync music on my iPhone, and I can't for the life of me understand why it is one of the least reliable pieces of software that I've ever used. I used to use it to back up my iOS devices, but I've switched to iCloud after iTunes was unable to do the simple task of using a backup to set up a new iPhone. Wireless syncing almost never works for me either.

So in short, I was looking forward to a replacement that hopefully Apple had taken the time to finally improve. I'd almost swear that they make iTunes for Windows bad on purpose to encourage people to switch to Macs.

naturally i was kidding, but i also use my itunes mostly for just that. so is the music app not going to do this anymore? then how is that supposed to happen?..
 
So your name is macbook guy, you regularly use iPad, iPhone, iOS and iTunes... and you switched back to windows?!? Just curious...

Yes. I had an iMac G3 - blueberry (OS 9, OS X public beta, OS X 10-10.2), an iBook G3 (snow), a 2006 intel core iMac, a 2006 intel core 2 MacBook, a late 2011 iMac, a late 2011 15" MacBook Pro, and a 2014 15" rMacBook Pro.

I am now running a Dell gaming laptop.

Edited to add: forgot about my Minis. I had a mid 2011 and a late 2012. They were handy when I did livestreaming for events.
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.