Yvan256 said:
PDA equals "distinct operating system" to most people. I'm not talking about a PDA, I'm talking about a portable computer the size of a "PDA".
I don't want some "OS X lite" operating system that requires a special version of software (like Windows CE or PalmOS). This is one of the main reason the PDA market isn't as strong as it could be (similar to MP3 players before/without the iPod).
This thing (PCG-X505) is way too big, there's no real surface difference between that and a 12" iBook/PowerBook. Making something thinner doesn't make it smaller (you can't fit a 0.5" thick laptop in your pocket if it has a 12" screen).
Imagine a thin (0.5") Mac mini, cut about 25% on the depth (say, 6x4x0.5").
mmm, hafta disagree. You say that PDA's are not as high of market share because they run skimpy OS's. Like mp3 players before the ipod.... oh wait, that's why the ipod sells so well. Really simple OS. If you put the full fledged OS on there, not only woudl it be a major resource hog given what you can fit into a PDA, and be ghastly to operate without a keyboard and mouse, but also it would be decidedly complex for the job it needs to do. You aren't going to be able to use all the features of an OS on something that small, so do you want them? No.
And perfect evidence. Mac mini is just barely enough computer to run the OS well, some would argue not given the lack of HD space. You KNOW apple crammed that thing tight. And you argue making it 1/4 the size, while adding input devices and a screen. Asking for a little bit of a miracle.
If apple does release a product in another market like that, I'd be dissapointed. Apple is small, so they should use that to their advantage, as they do. It allows them to be nimble, to focus on doing a few things right, to not have to please everybody and therefore embrace simplicity. Apple will do better by working to do better in the buisnesses it's in, or entering into others that are prime (like ipod), than trying to leverage its way into doing everything that is being done. Why? Apple can grow that way, they don't spend money (don't have risk) and don't have huge boat and thousands of projects they have to keep going when they need change direction. Microsoft, though, has no room to grow within its market, but has a lot more leverage and a lot more secruity of revenue stream built in. So its best course is trying to get into as many markets as it can as a method of growth, and use its weight to kick others out. So they fight the netscape IE wars, the AAC WMA wars, the cell phone OS wars- they make a media center OS, hope it goes somewhere, make a tablet PC, hope it's the next big thing.
But if apple did that, they'd be broke fast.
So I'm just aiming to say, not to you but to all those who dream of an iphone or a PDA or a true media center or a true video ipod -- don't expect it. Apple's got the privelage of being able to pick and choose markets and hence battles. It will exercise that privelage.