They’ll probably be able to finally integrate the modem into the SoC, like Qualcomm does with Snapdragon. And I hope this means cellular is finally coming to the Mac.
You do know Apple don't own arm right? Arm builds the latest gen, license out the schematics, and vendors are allowed to tweak it. I give you that Apple has done a great job at enhancing the architect but they didn't create it. Plus, Apple then goes to tsmc and ask them to build the cpu.Yeah, folks.
Keep underestimating Apple here.
We know how that went the last time, right?
Apple is going to eventually "build" everything themselves.
I wonder if screens are next (no more Samsung).
Yes. Apple is trying to enter into someone's else specialty with no expertise. Look at their car division. It's gone nowhere fast and every car manufacturer they asked to help build the car turned them down. These stuff are incredibly difficult.Why couldn’t Intel hack it? And why is Qualcomm so much better? Is modem engineering much more complex than people realize?
Most 5G patents are held by Huawei. Even Qualcomm licenses a lot of patents from Huawei, especially when it comes to TD as opposed to the traditional FDD technology.What patents will be infringed upon that aren't covered in their 8 year licensing agreement?
The big players in this field (companies like Qualcomm, Ericsson, Nokia, Samsung) have cross-licensing agreements. Huawei was very active in filing patents in recent years, but they entered the field relatively late and their portfolio of essential patents is still smaller compared to the older companies that practically invented cellular networks.Most 5G patents are held by Huawei. Even Qualcomm licenses a lot of patents from Huawei, especially when it comes to TD as opposed to the traditional FDD technology.
Apple has an architecture license from ARM, IIRC. The CPUs that Apple is now building, especially starting with A11 (Bionic) are such that they are closer to Intel in building it completely themselves than simply adapting an ARM design. In other words, Apple doesn’t use ARM schematics and then simply bolt on stuff. These are Apple-designed CPUS.You do know Apple don't own arm right? Arm builds the latest gen, license out the schematics, and vendors are allowed to tweak it. I give you that Apple has done a great job at enhancing the architect but they didn't create it. Plus, Apple then goes to tsmc and ask them to build the cpu.
Intel goes to no one to build it. They have their own manufacturing. Just like with Samsung, they have their own manufacturing. Apple needs tons of vendor to build their phones parts and not to mention Foxconn.
An automobile is an order of magnitude more complex than simply building a modem. Apple has the in-house chip expertise to build cellular modems that compete with Qualcomm even if it takes another couple of years before they release an Apple product with in-house cellular. Building an automobile is way outside their wheelhouse, a cellular modem, not so much.Yes. Apple is trying to enter into someone's else specialty with no expertise. Look at their car division. It's gone nowhere fast and every car manufacturer they asked to help build the car turned them down. These stuff are incredibly difficult.
Exactly. They have cross-licensing because they are equal. Cannot be said the same for Apple+Intel.The big players in this field (companies like Qualcomm, Ericsson, Nokia, Samsung) have cross-licensing agreements. Huawei was very active in filing patents in recent years, but they entered the field relatively late and their portfolio of essential patents is still smaller compared to the older companies that practically invented cellular networks.
You do know Apple don't own arm right? Arm builds the latest gen, license out the schematics, and vendors are allowed to tweak it. I give you that Apple has done a great job at enhancing the architect but they didn't create it. Plus, Apple then goes to tsmc and ask them to build the cpu.
Intel goes to no one to build it. They have their own manufacturing. Just like with Samsung, they have their own manufacturing. Apple needs tons of vendor to build their phones parts and not to mention Foxconn.
Exactly. They have cross-licensing because they are equal. Cannot be said the same for Apple+Intel.
There was a comparison done by Opensignal, even though they both have the 5G modems by Qualcomm, Android phones have a faster 5G download speed than iPhone 12. Apple not only needs to make a good 5G modem, but also they need to integrate it into their A SOC for better performance. Apple has a long way to go.An automobile is an order of magnitude more complex than simply building a modem. Apple has the in-house chip expertise to build cellular modems that compete with Qualcomm even if it takes another couple of years before they release an Apple product with in-house cellular. Building an automobile is way outside their wheelhouse, a cellular modem, not so much.
Good chance that Qualcomm doesn't have the right to license out others' licenses. If I were one of the major license holders, I would never sign an agreement like that with Qualcomm since it means the loss of future business deals.We have no idea if the apple-qualcomm agreement is a cross-license or not. Qualcomm certainly would need a license to Intel’s patents. They may have a pre-existing license.
Yeah, keep dreaming. Qualcomm has been making modems a long time. Apple is just starting.
Good chance that Qualcomm doesn't have the right to license out others' licenses. If I were one of the major license holders, I would never sign an agreement like that with Qualcomm since it means the loss of future business deals.
Apple already has a silicon design office in San Diego.Who knows, Apple might set up an office in San Diego and Qualcomm engineers may start to jump ship.
If the rumor is correct, Apple has another 24 months to go before they begin any sort of mass production, so I’m not really all that worried. Awful lot of needless anxiety on this thread, though.There was a comparison done by Opensignal, even though they both have the 5G modems by Qualcomm, Android phones have a faster 5G download speed than iPhone 12. Apple not only needs to make a good 5G modem, but also they need to integrate it into their A SOC for better performance. Apple has a long way to go.
Intel's modem business was horrible.No they aren’t. They bought intel’s modem business, including most of the employees.
It depends on which are necessary.Below is the pie chart of 5G patents. Intel and Apple are among "Others". They got granted a total of 65 patents.
Even if they are allowed to use Qualcomm's patents, they still have to make license deals with the other major patent holders or come up with equal amounts of new patents of their own to leverage the cost.
View attachment 1772493
Qualcomm isn't a troll, they actually build things.Yes, once all the patents are expired in 20 years time. Qualcomm made the "huge" and continuous investment and R&D on 5G ( as with many other companies ), You might disagree on what they are charging, but surely they deserve something.
But then vast majority of MR thinks they are patent trolls.
No, they did not let most of the experienced designers go.Intel's modem business was horrible.
They kept some people, but most of the experienced designers they let go.
For all intent, the Apple development is a restart with Intel IP.
That's why I put "build" in quotations.They don’t build anything