I would add a third group: The mother/father of a young kid that is 'helping' their parent pick out 'the perfect phone for you mom/dad', and sticks them with an Android phone. I've talked to many since the 'droid' phones first came out. They complain that the features are overwhelming, and every time their child touches it, they change something and make it harder to use it.
Then they ask what I use, and I show them, and they practically drool over it and one person went back and told their kid they wanted an iPhone,and the kid went all fascist on them and told them they will take the Android, or nothing. YIKES!
I still, rightly or wrongly, lump the iPhone into the 'Devices That Work' category. Sure, there are more ways to 'bling up' the Android phones, and you don't have the specter of Steve Jobs telling you what you can install on it, but I personally do not see them as being very secure, especially in the hands of an undereducated pre-senile oldster who could click on any URL that pops up on their phone and install any number of nefarious apps.