Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
300 survey out of 10,000,000 is:

Accurate 19 times out of 20
+/- 5.66%

Sounds statistically relevant to me (provided the sampling was in line with accepted methodologies).

For a population of 300,000,000 (the USA, for example); in order to be accurate +/- 5%, 19 times out of 20 you need a sample size of 384.

Not as far fetched as some might think.

Sampling a large heterogeneous population randomly using a large sample is a lot simpler than sampling something much more niche like this.

Their sample must be representative of the population they want to represent. This is very very easy to do badly even in large samples; in small samples it gets even harder.

All kind of factors could impact upgrading to IOS; age, location, earnings, ethnicity, sex, existing phone, dominant carriers, Iphone upgrade cycle (how many IOS users have 2 year and older phones), education, etc. In surveys, self-selection is always a big problem.
 
Most Android phone owners I know think that iPhones (and Apple) are either uncool, old people's phones, technologically behind, or all of the above. They sincerely have no desire for one.

They see nothing about my iPhone 6 that makes them wish they had one. On the other hand, I'm impressed with many of their phones, especially Motorola smartphones.
 
Apple did allow enough time to pass with a "small screen phone" for Android users to build up a disdain towards Apple. Now they won't switch back out of spite and have been sucked into the Android world of specs for spec's sake.

For me, it all comes down to the synergy of Apple making beautiful hardware and software designed to work together. There's something I dislike about a pay-per-click ad company making software for plastic-loving hardware companies that allow hideous carrier logos to be stamped all over them. I can live without 30 home screens and being able to change the colors of things.
 
You're predicting it wrong if you think making a big iPhone will get people to switch.

Main reasons to reject it:

- Lack of SD slot
- No removable battery
- Markup
- GUI
- Barely any discount
- Bezels

Yeah, because the average user cares about those things. Please.

Millions of people are lining up for the GS5 and Note? Not really. In case you missed it, Samsung's mobile division is sucking wind right now as demand for their products has tanked.

If someone is deeply entrenched in Android then they won't switch but a lot of people aren't geeky enough to care. The want something that does photos, e-mail, message, calls, plays games etc. They are hardly wading deep into customization.

The sample size is minuscule and pretty meaningless. Regardless, the demand for the iPhone dwarfs any other device and probably rivals or excedes the sum of the top of line devices from Samsung, HTC, Moto etc combined.
 
Not necessarily, people wait months for the OPO. Mens favorite quote applies here too I think.

It is not the size alone that matters but also what you can do with it. Android devices aren't just bigger but you can customise them. All you got with the 6+ are more rows and columns.

The "you can customize Android" mantra, while completely true, is surely something that the vast majority of Android users NEVER do. The ability to re-skin, re-prom or whatever it is exactly that people talk about doing with their Android phones is something only a small minority of people are doing. How do I come by my suggestion it is a small minority you ask? Because of the sheer number of Android phones that don't ever see an update and even the lack of web usage by Android phones (compared to iOS) in general tells me the great masses of Android users are likely using their phones as phones, maybe checking email, the occasional web views, maps and that is about it. Customizability is sold as a benefit, but when people aren't using it, due to complexity, is it really a benefit?

A couple of years ago, I remember seeing a guy with a large screened Android phone, while waiting for a flight at LaGuardia, looking at his home screen with it's active weather widget showing clouds and rain. It was an interesting info-graphic but I'm sure burned battery life doing something that was completely unnecessary (as you could look outside and see it raining - and at LaGuardia with all the delays, it was doubly apparent it was raining out).

Yes, the grid of icons may be a bit boring, but when all it takes to go into an app that is more dynamic, is to touch once, maybe twice, I just don't buy into the need for active widgets. I don't have active widgets on my computer either, nor do I like playing slot machines with all their blinking lights and sounds.

Maybe I'm old that way (or old in general), but I much prefer Apple's approach to making things work so that you don't have to think about or even know how to run a computer or smartphone. It's not dumbing down necessarily, but rather making sure that technology isn't in the way of getting things done.

I felt that way back when I had to use crazy complex commands to use our college computer system and a roommate had an original Classic that was just so easy to use, at least for the things I wanted to do, like write papers.

Compared to the word processing program we used on our mainframe computer, where you typed, not knowing where the page breaks, paragraphs, or really anything was, as that all needed to be formatted within the program, but was not WYSIWYG. And I say all this, having taken and learned punch card computing for my statistics studies, so I understand how computers work, or how to make them work.
 
The Android kids will not come over to iPhones until they can have their own themes and icon packs...such as Pokemon, PowerRangers, Star Wars, Batman, Spiderman, etc...
 
1GB RAM.

This is probably the biggest reason.

This is another major reason to reject the iPhone if you have not just forgotten about it after seeing all the other things that are wrong about it.

1.5GB was the minimum acceptable last year for a basic phone, and 2GB for a premium phone.

Another thing to think about after looking at all that is Bendghazi.
 
I always get a good laugh at mention of "power users."

Are these people of importance and are high salary executives?

Most professionals with high salaries I know use their phones for email and texting friends, colleagues, acquaintances and family. Maybe a little bit of news on the side.

Rigifan, I think he refers to all those people who spend endless hours tweaking their phone settings and playing games. Yeah, power users, man!

Yeah man! you're totally right. i was absolutely referring to those people with more brains than cash who also do not pay Apple to make "decisions on their behalf"
 
Last edited:
I switched from iPhone 5 to Android Samsung S5, and back to iPhone 6 Plus. Man was that a good move. That S5 was wearing me out. My 6 Plus is by far the best phone IMO. Couldn't imagine going back to Android anything.
 
First of all, my own anecdotal experience in picking up both a 6 (for the wife) and a 6+ for me on two separate trips to two different retailers (AT&T for the 6 and Apple Store for the 6+), we witnessed four different unrelated Android switchers take place.

Of the 4 cases of people switching from Android (I can't say what brand or models they were leaving), we didn't hear questions related to worries of their being "only" 1gb of ram in the iPhones, and none of these people (3 men and 1 woman) seemed to have anything but a general sense for how their Android phones worked, based upon the questions they were asking about how to move things from their Android device to the iPhone.

In the same way that people on these forums are really just a subset of a narrow population of Apple enthusiasts, with an even narrower subset of Apple haters, as the article states, the survey numbers were really too low to be considered representative of the overall population. And to base their report on just the first 30 days, then doesn't take into consideration supply constraints on the 6+, which would have limited the ability of switchers (and existing iPhone users) to even have the ability to choose a 6+.

If I had to toss out some claims about iPhone vs Android, I'd say that there are some people who own Android or iPhone just because, some who would never switch from iPhone to Android or Android to iPhone, and some who will jump on getting whatever is new / different, regardless of brand. Also, non-tech people who have bought into the Apple ecosystem are more likely to stay in the Apple ecosystem because it's easier for them to do so. Conversely, it's actually easier for those on Android to switch to iOS / OS X because Android does NOT have the same all-encompassing ecosystem that Apple has created.

When I see reports like this, it's easy to assume the authors are trying to show that Apple has not gotten the switchers they forecast, and the fact that they didn't use a representative number of people polled and we can't even say if they chose the 300 people from one area or even one store, to know whether regional differences or product availability played into the conclusion they're making.

I'll call it a sloppy anecdotal story, not unlike my own experiences. I didn't note that in both of my own cases of getting new 6's, I was the only person around that got a 6+. AT&T didn't have any and when I went to the Apple store, the 6+ I got was the only delivered 6+ they had gotten that morning. In both cases, it was within the initial 30 day launch.

Yeah, I got my 6 Plus on release day at ATT at a big mall in Indianapolis. They only had 3 6Plus' and most of all ATT stores in the state had none. Needless to say I was first in line and lucked out. But yeah, great comment. I agree.
 
Yeah, because the average user cares about those things. Please.
I am sure they do at least in some points. There are people out there, who buy things that fits their needs at best.

Millions of people are lining up for the GS5 and Note? Not really. In case you missed it, Samsung's mobile division is sucking wind right now as demand for their products has tanked.

Where should they line up? You ever saw a Samsung store to line up? Why should they line up? If i want a Note 4, i just buy on Amazon. There is no need to camp in front of a Store and make a fool of yourself.

If someone is deeply entrenched in Android then they won't switch but a lot of people aren't geeky enough to care.

RGB Notification LED, Return and Menu Button, no iTunes, use non-GPlay Apps without rooting, Multitasking, Tasker.... you don't need to be geeky not to switch to iOS.
 
I am in the :apple: Eco System with 4 Macs and several iPads in the household but i am using an Android phone. I wanted to have a bigger screen iPhone years ago but that time Apple insisted on their tiny screens so I went the Android route.

I was sure that as soon as a bigger screened iPhone was available, I would switch. But that didn't happen. Why I am still using Android:


  • Form factor. For me a screen size of 5.2" works best. The iPhone 6 screen is too small and the 6+ is too big. Especially with those gargantuan Bezels.

  • Price. For what is offered, I feel the iPhone 6(+) is just too expensive.

  • Battery life. Even if I would force myself to use the 4.7" iPhone 6, I am sure, the battery would not last me through the day. My current phone is running a 3000+ mAh battery on a 5.2" screen.

  • UI. I like to have Widgets on my home screen. I have become so used to them, I just can't imagine to not have relevant info on a glance on my homescreen.

  • File system. Sometimes if I want to download something, modify it with 2 or 3 apps, save and forward it, I rather do it on my phone than my iPad. In that sense iOS feels to restricted.

  • The ability to sync to iTunes and iCloud Contacts and Calendar. The syncing works great on my Android phone, so I have no rush to leave Android for that reason.

  • Software. For what is important to me and what I use for work, I actually found better and more functional software in Android compared to iOS. Apart from that, just for that godawful and Alphaversion lookalike Photos App I wouldn't use iOS. :eek:

  • And talking about Software: the ability to set default Apps.

  • Waterproof device. I can take my current phone into the swimming pool to shoot videos of my daughter learning to swim. Maybe not the most essential or deciding factor, but now after having it, I enjoy that tremendously.

  • And one more minor point: the ability to theme. Every now and then after a few month, it feels kind of refreshing to be able to use a different icon set, menu colors, etc. Again, not overly important, especially if you just want a work horse as a phone, but still nice to have.
 
Last edited:
Former Note 2 user to iPhone 6+ user. Didn't mind Android for the most part. It's when these phone manufacturers start putting their crappy, laggy UI's on top of Android. Samsung + AT&T made for horrible updates and pretty much giving up on getting those updates in a timely fashion. Initially the Note 2 was great. Great battery life, pretty smooth UI experience. After the first update, went from great battery life to having to charge my phone twice a day; sometimes 3. The update released to correct this and many other issues didn't get put out until about 4-5 months later.
 
I am in the :apple: Eco System with 4 Macs and several iPads in the household but i am using an Android phone. I wanted to have a bigger screen iPhone years ago but that time Apple insisted on their tiny screens so I went the Android route.

I was sure that as soon as a bigger screened iPhone was available, I would switch. But that didn't happen. Why I am still using Android:


  • Form factor. For me a screen size of 5.2" works best. The iPhone 6 screen is too small and the 6+ is too big. Especially with those gargantuan Bezels.

  • Price. For what is offered, I feel the iPhone 6(+) is just too expensive.

  • Battery life. Even if I would force myself to use the 4.7" iPhone 6, I am sure, the battery would not last me through the day. My current phone is running a 3000+ mAh battery on a 5.2" screen.

  • UI. I like to have Widgets on my home screen. I have become so used to them, I just can't imagine to not have relevant info on a glance on my homescreen.

  • File system. Sometimes if I want to download something, modify it with 2 or 3 apps, save and forward it, I rather do it on my phone than my iPad. In that sense iOS feels to restricted.

  • The ability to sync to iTunes and iCloud Contacts and Calendar. The syncing works great on my Android phone, so I have no rush to leave Android for that reason.

  • Software. For what is important to me and what I use for work, I actually found better and more functional software in Android compared to iOS. Apart from that, just for that godawful and Alphaversion lookalike Photos App I wouldn't use iOS. :eek:

  • Waterproof device. I can take my current phone into the swimming pool to shoot videos of my daughter learning to swim. Maybe not the most essential or deciding factor, but now after having it, I enjoy that tremendously.

  • And one more minor point: the ability to theme. Every no and then after a few month, it feels kind of refreshing to be able to use a different icon set, menu colors, etc. Again, not important, especially if you just want a work horse as a phone, but still nice to have.

All these things, and so many, many more. I'm tired of complaining I'm tired of hoping I'm tired of being overcharged I'm tired of senseless restrictions. I'm tired of Hollywood I'm tired of old farts desperately trying to buy coolness I'm tired of social consciousness I'm tired of being sold lipsticked pork. Android Android forgive me for leaving I've sinned and your lollipop is delicious. I'll be returning to the fold now, it's just so hard to decide which handset. Z3c is the frontrunner ATM.
 
Too big for me

I have the iPhone 5s and I considered upgrading to the 6, but I found it overly big for my hand. I couldn't reach the top of screen with my thumb, I couldn't even reach across the screen with my thumb to type. I like using one hand to access most information on my phone. I don't use two hands too often.

My biggest concern is that Apple won't keep a smaller form factor phone. I still really use my phone as a phone. Secondarily it keeps my calendar and a few apps. So Hopefully when the iPhone goes to 7, they'll have a 7 small form factor, 7, and 7 plus.
 
1GB RAM.

This is probably the biggest reason.

Y'know people keep bitching about this but it's really not a big deal. Yes the Safari issue needs to be sorted but I don't think its a ram thing at all. I can only say this because as an app developer of 5 years I can tell you that it's pretty damn hard to hit the 1GB limit of ram usage unless your app is really really really badly made. Automatic image compression along with ARC memory management within Xcode makes for incredibly efficient apps no matter what you do, the majority of apps just cache from the storage space anyway which isn't as fast as RAM but quick enough that most consumers never notice.

Apple know this and so do most of the developers out there, the whole RAM argument is just spec talk riling up the people who seem to think it's important.
 
It will be hilarious to see how Daniel Eran Dilger (of Apple Insider) is going to spin this...

;)

I know how Tallest Skil, Apple II, and the other regulars will. "Android users are all welfare trash Obama-lovers, and of course they'd love Samscum, we don't want them anyway. I long for the day when only pure, red-blooded Americans use Jony Ive's designs." I'm not even exaggerating.
 
I know how Tallest Skil, Apple II, and the other regulars will. "Android users are all welfare trash Obama-lovers, and of course they'd love Samscum, we don't want them anyway. I long for the day when only pure, red-blooded Americans use Jony Ive's designs." I'm not even exaggerating.

LOL, I know you are not exaggerating at all... good old Apple Insider and their crazy forum members.

I am sure the words "paid shill" and "ANALyst" will also be mentioned ("analyst" when reporting something favorable to Apple, "paid shill" and "ANALyst" when reporting something not favorable to Apple).
 
Sample size

300 people sampled is a joke.

Why is this being presented as news? Or anything remotely worth discussing.
 
Y'know people keep bitching about this but it's really not a big deal. Yes the Safari issue needs to be sorted but I don't think its a ram thing at all. I can only say this because as an app developer of 5 years I can tell you that it's pretty damn hard to hit the 1GB limit of ram usage unless your app is really really really badly made. Automatic image compression along with ARC memory management within Xcode makes for incredibly efficient apps no matter what you do, the majority of apps just cache from the storage space anyway which isn't as fast as RAM but quick enough that most consumers never notice.

Apple know this and so do most of the developers out there, the whole RAM argument is just spec talk riling up the people who seem to think it's important.


I'm having constant app crashes due to OOM errors - 8.1 is a RAM hog and I'm fed up. Putting out the 6 with only 1gig goes down as one of current management's greatest blunders. There are many others now of course.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.