Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
My S0 watch face “popped” and it looked like the photo, it was still connected and dangling. It was immediately apparent, made a pretty loud pop sound and posed no real danger. I would love to be a fly on the wall to see how Chris Smith managed to slice his arm open.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gene731
Another example of MacRumors reporting news using a formulation that seems intentionally inflammatory (to create more debate here in the forum thread, and thus more viewers of the irritating ads interspersed with our posts?):
?

Compare (as originally posted):

Every generation of the Apple Watch has a battery swelling defect that can cause operational failures and injuries from broken screens, states a new class action lawsuit that has been filed against Apple.


With (a simple switch to the sentence construction):

A new class action lawsuit that has been filed against Apple states that "every generation of the Apple Watch has a battery swelling defect that can cause operational failures and injuries from broken screens".
Hold on, your saying that a MR editor changed the sentence to the latter? If that is the case then MR needs to explain why the post does not show 'Edited....' so viewers can see that something in the post was edited.
 
Spicy pillow is a risk with any lithium battery. Did the case get forced open while the wearer had it on? That' would be some brown trowsers times. If it's already open before the wearer puts it on, then Darwin recipient and his lawyer trying to pull a fast one on Apple. If the battery has swollen up enough to crack the case, you tempting fate by continuing to wear the watch.
 
Another example of MacRumors reporting news using a formulation that seems intentionally inflammatory (to create more debate here in the forum thread, and thus more viewers of the irritating ads interspersed with our posts?):
?

Compare (as originally posted):

Every generation of the Apple Watch has a battery swelling defect that can cause operational failures and injuries from broken screens, states a new class action lawsuit that has been filed against Apple.


With (a simple switch to the sentence construction):

A new class action lawsuit that has been filed against Apple states that "every generation of the Apple Watch has a battery swelling defect that can cause operational failures and injuries from broken screens".
Without the ad revenue, the website doesn’t have the money to run, so while mildly annoying, it is a necessary evil. I don’t think that the article is written specifically to do the thing you propose it is, but I think that it is written with the target audience in mind. I don’t think it is unreasonable for a website that is based on discussion to have articles written in a manner that sparks discussion. This is not, say cnn or npr whose number 1 goal is to inform and there are also comment sections, I think the article is the start of the conversation. But I also don’t think it is necessarily “clickbait”
 
"Whether it's widespread can't be figured out by this lawsuit"

The attorneys are incentivized to figure out how widespread it is via the class-action lawsuit. The more widespread the issue, the more plaintiffs can be joined to the suit, and the larger the monetary judgment (for plaintiffs and attorneys).
Not really. Plaintiffs seeking certification of a class are required to satisfy a "numerosity" requirement before the class can be certified (among many other requirements). These guys won't be able to get very far unless they can actually demonstrate that a large number of individuals were injured by the issue alleged. They won't be able to, so they either are extremely poor attorneys or they are simply hoping for a nuisance-value settlement before the case is dismissed or the court rules that there is no class to be certified.
 
Go for it but make sure you share your experience here
A friend of mine has had the same Samsung Watch for years and I thought it was cool. Made me think of getting an Apple Watch.
I wouldn't say Samsung Watches are bad.
 
They weren't designed for that purpose. That's just how the screen is assembled. The inners are put in and then the screen it stuck on.
No, no device is designed to "explode", but you can integrate an "intended beaking point" in case of...
A screen popping of appears to me an acceptable emergency exit. Melting down towards your arm might be less desirable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: amartinez1660
He was in a golf cart and reached down from the steering wheel to place it in motion, when the detached screen "severely sliced" the underside of his forearm, cutting a vein.
"Severely sliced", seriously? Can it decapitate people too?

I'm not an Apple zealot and will side against them where it makes sense to but this is just silly. By this reasoning glass is an excessively dangerous substance that shouldn't be found in any product.

Glad the device is actually coming apart rather than catching fire when this happens, given it's designed to be on people's wrists. It's a shame we can't make safer battery tech.
 
So Chris Smith reached down from the golf cart steering wheel whilst driving, to pop the screen back in, am I reading that right?

If he fell out of the golf cart for no reason would he sue himself?
 
Not really fanboying apple here. The construction of a watch with glue to hold the screen in, it IS rather bad design not gonna lie.

The screen on my 3+ year old apple watch popped off during an exercise session. I found the screen thankfully. And was able to buy the parts to fix it (fixed the crappy battery too)

What failed was the glue. It simply just popped off.


So I guess the apple watch really isn`t a quality timepiece built to last, and I was frankly surprised that a mere 3 years in it breaks. ALSO the battery... it was loosing juice so fast it was basically useless. I looked at the battery, it wasn`t deformed or swelling so def the glue.

Umm, yeah, because a few anecdotal stories are indicative of the overall quality of a product.

Hate to tell you this, but there's no such thing as a mass produced product with a 0% failure rate. I don't care how much you spend on it.
 
I’m pretty sure that people’s desires to get their hands on some sweet sweet Apple cash is going to have them jumping in front of Apple cars when they ship.
 
  • Like
Reactions: amartinez1660
Just for fun, take a look at the guys arm in the link to the lawsuit... He's got quite the gash there.
 
I've just filed a class action lawsuit against Apple, too, for knowingly allowing victimized customers to intentionally file class action lawsuits against said company whenever they personally experience anything negative and positioning the suit such that said company knowing allowed such defects to be sold in the marketplace to unsuspecting consumers. /s

The wording and exaggeration in these suits makes me feel sad for the human race.
 
I look down, see my watch battery has swollen and broken the screen. Two options for how to proceed: 1) carefully remove the watch so as to avoid injury, 2) make sure I cut myself on the obviously broken glass in order to initiate legal proceedings against Apple.
Think one step more. Imaging you wake up in the morning and look down to your swollen watch and broke screen. Then you look at your wrist and fingers…
 
A friend of mine has had the same Samsung Watch for years and I thought it was cool. Made me think of getting an Apple Watch.
I wouldn't say Samsung Watches are bad.
I was not suggesting that, if I were in the Android system, I'd probably have one.
just that the poster I was responding to seems to be posting rather negative comments about Apple and apple products in general so I was encouraging him/her to give a a product review - and I am not naive enough to believe that would happen ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Captain Trips
I went to an Apple Store with my Series 0 where the screen popped out from the battery swelling, it was no longer under warranty so they told me I needed to get a new phone and did not offer any other solution or discount.
 
While I have read here on MR about some folks experiencing swollen batteries, most seem to happen during charging and not while wearing the watch. Not questioning that it happened to this guy, but a class action suit does not seem appropriate.
I agree, my screen popped off while my Apple Watch Series 0 was charging over night, it could have been a fire hazard though as the watch was hot as hell when I removed it from the Apple Charger
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.