Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
68,968
39,979



Leaked proposals from the European Union suggest that smartphone manufacturers in the EU could be forced to make all batteries removable in the future. This would mean that any smartphone brand wanting to sell a handheld in the EU, including Apple, would have to ensure that every device on the market has a user-removable battery (via TechRadar).

ifixit-iphone-x-battery-tabs.jpg
Image via iFixit


This proposal is said to be a long way from being confirmed as it's not even out in the public yet. The documents were leaked by Dutch publication Het Financieele Dagblad, which suggested that the proposal will be officially unveiled in March.

Apple has always made its iPhones with non-removable batteries, encouraging users to take their devices in to specialists if they ever face issues with degrading batteries. The leaked EU proposals suggest that users shouldn't have to rely on outside help in these situations, and that they should be able to simply swap the battery out on their own.

The iPhone would have to undergo massive design changes to comply with a removable battery design. With a removable battery, the iPhone would potentially lose features like waterproofing and a slim design.

Apple is already pushing back against one ongoing change in the European Union, related to a common charging standard for mobile devices. The European Parliament wants one charger to fit all smartphones, tablets, and other portable devices, with the likely candidate to be USB-C.

This could make the Lightning port on current iPhone models incompatible with the law, and Apple's current stance is that the iPhone is too thin to house a USB-C port. Given that the company disagreed with the charging standard vote, it's likely that if the removable battery proposal ever becomes real legislation in the EU, Apple will once again push back against the proposal.

Article Link: Leaked Documents Suggest Apple Could Be Forced to Build iPhones With User-Removable Batteries in Europe
 
Is this really necessary? Smartphone batteries have such long lives these days that swapping your battery isn't something people typically have to do very often. I had my iPhone 7 Plus for three years and the battery was still excellent; my girlfriend is using it now for about six months more and she still gets awesome battery life.

I'm normally all for user serviceability but smartphone battery tech has gotten really good and I'm not sure I want the compromises from a battery swappable design anymore.
 
The European Union is trying to get involved in our lives on a micro level. Deciding what we buy and what companies produce. It's almost like a big communist state. Except that it's just a governmental body on top of everybody's own government and no country is a communist state on it's own. One forced thing isn't that hard, but they already decide on what kind of light we can use in our lamps and the amount of watts our vacuum cleaner are allowed to use. It may seem for the greater good, but it's all so restrictive. There is no real benefit in it.
 
I'm normally all for user serviceability but smartphone battery tech has gotten really good and I'm not sure I want the compromises from a battery swappable design anymore.
What compromises do you mean? We're not talking about hot-swapping batteries, and Samsung has proven multiple times over that you can create a waterproof user-replaceable battery (and headphone jack...) without compromising the form or function of the device.
 
I think this is a little over the top. The non-proprietary USB-C is a good thing, but enabling consumers to mess with highly volatile batteries is another thing. An affordable battery replacement program is a better idea.
What next? Forcing consumers to have a person pump gas for them, so they aren't messing with even more volatile gasoline? Please, there's no need to further emulate New Jersey. My 1½ year old is able to "mess with highly volatile batteries". Not that she should...
 
About time.

This also means Apple would be forced to sell OEM parts to consumers.

The battery in the iPhone is good for 500 cycles. This means the battery should be replaced every 12-18 months. The average smartphone replacement cycle now is over 3 years.
 
Is this really necessary? Smartphone batteries have such long lives these days that swapping your battery isn't something people typically have to do very often. I had my iPhone 7 Plus for three years and the battery was still excellent; my girlfriend is using it now for about six months more and she still gets awesome battery life.

I'm normally all for user serviceability but smartphone battery tech has gotten really good and I'm not sure I want the compromises from a battery swappable design anymore.

I have an iPhone 7 that is just about a year old and already the battery has taken a very noticeable hit.
 
What compromises do you mean? We're not talking about hot-swapping batteries, and Samsung has proven multiple times over that you can create a waterproof user-replaceable battery (and headphone jack...) without compromising the form or function of the device.

I consider an ultra-thin plastic back that you basically peel off to access the battery a compromise in form o_O
 
Oh no! But I totally enjoyed waiting in line for half an hour, twice, but only after booking three appointments at the Apple Store over an over again only to be told, once I went there and waited in line, that they can't actually do the replacement and that I should book another appointment, and then paying a third of the price of a new phone, for a battery replacement. Only to then find that the battery life didn't improve, because that's just how bad battery life is on iOS 13.

The only thing that enjoyed more than that, was the battery replacement on my MacBook Pro, which took two months of setting up appointments here and there and paying huge sums of money to basically replace half of my computer. It's almost as if when designing products, Apple pretends that batteries are not consumables.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.