Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Iphone 12 & 13 cases are pigmented coated leather so they won't patina at all until you physically wear through the layer of paint they apply to them. Left on their own it usually only happens on the edges.

The old Iphone X Saddle cases weren't pigment coated.

I was hoping for a repeat with the Golden Brown case too but that clearly wasn’t going to happen.

After just digging the old X case out it was a lot flimsier than I remember it, the Andar is way nicer.
It did patina well though, IMO. After about a year of use:

Very much like mine for the iPhone 8. It was good leather.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bc 08
After being completely happy with the Apple Brown Leather cases for years, the Saddle Brown for my 12 Pro was a complete failure.

25A6D413-94A1-4C4E-B880-AFAEF3F7A0F9.jpeg



I decided to give the Golden Brown one last chance. I love the color combo with the SB. Sadly, it seems to be headed in the same direction. It’s already starting to wear solely on the edges.

C9E87113-FA71-4C6F-A3A9-420138E0C9D5.jpeg


Bullstrap’s BF sale convinced me to pull the trigger on a Sienna. With a 10% coupon stacked on the BF deal, was only $56 shipped. Cheaper than the Apple.
 
Me too. $56 shipped is a great deal for the 13PM. I do miss the sienna color. I am currently using the Andar jet black and loving it so far. Hopefully sienna goes well with Sierra blue.
 
Trust the process??
Guessing you’re new here
Andar camel tan @ almost 2 weeks. Darkening quickly now and turning to a more amber brown by the day.

It’s starting to look pretty rich in person but I’m not sure how well it comes across in the photo.
im seeing a very similar patina in my 12! Love the direction it’s headed, I can see myself keeping this case for 2+ years
 
Even though they are back ordered, I went ahead and ordered a Bullstrap case for my 13PM. Their sale plus the coupon code TJH that adds another 15% off made the total come to $53.72. Much better than $79.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigMcGuire
Used this nomad case 3 weeks, I am so disappointed, scratches make it so so bad, don’t like it…the black one on XS Max never did like this. Can I do anything? I will get my Bullstrap at the end of december, now I use the Apple Silicone case. :(
9FB70142-2A39-4505-94F2-8328B77E3BF1.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: JamiLynee
Used this nomad case 3 weeks, I am so disappointed, scratches make it so so bad, don’t like it…the black one on XS Max never did like this. Can I do anything? I will get my Bullstrap at the end of december, now I use the Apple Silicone case. :(
View attachment 1916979
normal, so no. yes black does the same but doesn't show as much.

This is a 2 month old 12 max folio, looks worse in close up photos v a distance. rolls around in the Mrs handbag so gets a flogging lol.

FE6E42A1-11C9-4C26-9278-536AA0D86BD1_1_201_a.jpeg
68728ED5-64A8-4187-B0D8-A6948634D1CD_1_201_a.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Used this nomad case 3 weeks, I am so disappointed, scratches make it so so bad, don’t like it…the black one on XS Max never did like this. Can I do anything? I will get my Bullstrap at the end of december, now I use the Apple Silicone case. :(
View attachment 1916979


You didn't know that the Nomad would do that? It's their entire thing... their cases patina. It's' all over the websiet and even on the box the case came in. How did you miss that?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jacob_116
You didn't know that the Nomad would do that? It's their entire thing... their cases patina. It's' all over the websiet and even on the box the case came in. How did you miss that?
Used black one 1,5 years, didn’t noticed like this. What can I do if I don’t like it? I think I can’t sell it LoL.
 
Hi, I have been reading this topic for days now, and thanks for all the info on leather cases.
And now I have to decide betwen Andar Aspen - Camel tan or Bullstrap - Sienna colour.
Any suggestions or experience with both of them? To help me decide which to choose.
And is Bullstrap leather also full grain - on their blog site they say that they use both full grain and top grain on their products, but how to know from which is the Sienna Case?
Thanks for you answers
 
And is Bullstrap leather also full grain - on their blog site they say that they use both full grain and top grain on their products, but how to know from which is the Sienna Case?
Thanks for you answers

You won’t go wrong with either one.

Regarding Bullstrap leather it’s top grain:
 

Attachments

  • 00232D4B-FB62-4BD7-BAB2-82032953B879.jpeg
    00232D4B-FB62-4BD7-BAB2-82032953B879.jpeg
    202.8 KB · Views: 142
You won’t go wrong with either one.

Regarding Bullstrap leather it’s top grain:
Thanks for your answer.
Will probably go with Andar, because its full grain, and 20€ cheaper with shipping costs and also their delivery to EU where I'm from looks more reliable than Bullstrap. Andar shipping is in 7 days, Bullstrap almost 30 days.
All the best
 
  • Like
Reactions: bc 08
8FA3DF40-DB1D-4DB7-B354-4929E43A8620.jpeg
6B27355F-05AF-4A16-9C06-5EA0B958891F.jpeg

I got this from TaoBao, a china leather phone case maker, named GWW. They make iPhone case with famous leather brand like Horween etc. this one is around USD 48 with full Horween Chromexcel leather. It has very good leather smell and touch.
 

Attachments

  • 7D1A6CC2-1ED9-4C9C-BCC6-2D350BFABEE1.jpeg
    7D1A6CC2-1ED9-4C9C-BCC6-2D350BFABEE1.jpeg
    555.8 KB · Views: 116
  • Like
Reactions: JamiLynee
This isn’t a case but I’m still proud of the patina so far. I just got this a few weeks ago.
It’s starting on both sides where my fingers lay when I’m holding my iPhone 13pm.
b8329f2cf3349a785a726e941fffeb22.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: JamiLynee
This isn’t a case but I’m still proud of the patina so far. I just got this a few weeks ago.
It’s starting on both sides where my fingers lay when I’m holding my iPhone 13pm.
b8329f2cf3349a785a726e941fffeb22.jpg
After about a year with my saddle brown Apple wallet, I found they have the same coating as their leather case.
 
Even though they are back ordered, I went ahead and ordered a Bullstrap case for my 13PM. Their sale plus the coupon code TJH that adds another 15% off made the total come to $53.72. Much better than $79.
I just did the same. Hoping for better quality than what I got from Andar. I've been wanting an Ocean case since I switched to the 12 Pro from the 12 Mini.
 
I just did the same. Hoping for better quality than what I got from Andar. I've been wanting an Ocean case since I switched to the 12 Pro from the 12 Mini.
I also ordered the Ocean. Had one on the 12PM and love that color. And, for the price because of the sale and coupon I couldn’t resist. I’d never pay their $79 asking price, though. Here’s to hoping both of us get them fairly quickly and there are no problems with the cases.
 
I also ordered the Ocean. Had one on the 12PM and love that color. And, for the price because of the sale and coupon I couldn’t resist. I’d never pay their $79 asking price, though. Here’s to hoping both of us get them fairly quickly and there are no problems with the cases.
From my understanding they're backordered and the next shipments are going out 11/30. Not too bad.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.