Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Does any HomeKit computable TV allow volume control via Siri? We have three in the home of varying brands that literally do nothing via Siri except turn on and off
 
Does any HomeKit computable TV allow volume control via Siri? We have three in the home of varying brands that literally do nothing via Siri except turn on and off

I would love to know this, too. My Vizio can only power on and off or switch inputs via HomeKit. Seems a ridiculous omission. (I was so certain I must have missed something that I contacted Vizio to ask how the heck to change volume with HomeKit, only to be told that was not possible, nor planned.)

I believe the Homebridge WebOS plugin allows volume control. If someone working on the outside can make it work, why can't those on the inside, with -- presumably -- easy access to the code?
 
As mentioned before for the previous article, their previous statement of “no plans” was just non-committal corporate speak. Lots of companies, including Apple, talk like this before products or updates are actually available. Everyone, including MacRumors, made a mountain out of a molehill.

I’ll provide the example again where LG Canada said they had “no plans” to sell the 48” CX OLED in Canada, and then just a few weeks later the 48” CX OLED was available at Best Buy Canada.
Well sorry to said that is not correct.

because they did retract their plan, as they have removed all support articles on line that made reference to 2018 TV. So no actually Macrumors has helped the community to get upgrade and put the spotlight on LG
 
Well sorry to said that is not correct.

because they did retract their plan, as they have removed all support articles on line that made reference to 2018 TV. So no actually Macrumors has helped the community to get upgrade and put the spotlight on LG
If you choose to believe that, that's fine, but like I said, the "no plans" statement often doesn't mean what you think it means. I already gave you the example where LG said "no plans" for the LG 48" CX OLED in Canada. Well, to further describe the situation there, they had actually previously had it on their Canadian website but then had removed it, and when someone asked about it, LG Canada said there were "no plans" for it. There was no protest and no petition, yet just a few weeks later, it arrived in Canadian stores anyway.
 
Last edited:
Nice! It brings me back hope to finally get it on my crazy expensive 2017 OLED65B7.

PS : Don't quote me on this. I'm kidding.
 
I would love to know this, too. My Vizio can only power on and off or switch inputs via HomeKit. Seems a ridiculous omission. (I was so certain I must have missed something that I contacted Vizio to ask how the heck to change volume with HomeKit, only to be told that was not possible, nor planned.)

I believe the Homebridge WebOS plugin allows volume control. If someone working on the outside can make it work, why can't those on the inside, with -- presumably -- easy access to the code?

Does your Vizio switch inputs via Siri though or just the Home app?

You can sort of control the volume from the phone as well but only when using the tv as an AirPlay speaker. Sloppy really.
 
Does your Vizio switch inputs via Siri though or just the Home app?

You can sort of control the volume from the phone as well but only when using the tv as an AirPlay speaker. Sloppy really.

Good point -- I think I've only switched inputs via app, not voice.

And yeah, the volume stuff is very sloppy and quite un-Appley.
 
You don't need an Apple TV anymore. It's an App directly on the TV, like netflix.
Ehh. You’re still using the TV‘a processor. These aren’t great compared to standalone units like an Apple tv4k you can upgrade every few years. This is one small feature. You still have to pass audio to your speakers with arc using on board apps.
This would never replace an Apple TV or a different streaming device for me and you can’t upgrade the tv systems hardware down the road
 
  • Like
Reactions: ssspinball
I'm actually a bit surprised, given that LG (like most manufacturers) only supports their TV apps for a few years after manufacture. I know with my 2011 LG television (which is still working great... as a television) they had stopped updating - and, in some cases, actually removed - most apps by 2015-2016.

I still think you're better off buying an inexpensive set-top box for the "smart" part of a smart tv... but this is good news for people who own 2018 LG televisions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ssspinball
I still think you're better off buying an inexpensive set-top box for the "smart" part of a smart tv... but this is good news for people who own 2018 LG televisions.
I've gotten lucky so far.

2018 LG TV here, already with the Apple TV app, and getting AirPlay 2. However, I have Apple TV 4K for this TV anyway so it's kind of moot.

More importantly though, in 2018, I got Dolby Vision (& HLG) support added to my 2015 Marantz and Denon receivers, which was near-perfect timing for my 2018 LG 4K HDR TV purchase.

I think I'm good for another 5 years unless something breaks, or if LG suddenly drops pricing hugely on 77" OLED models.
 
What ever happened to Roku promising the same and it allegedly being nearly done?
 
6241BB96-3E11-4101-A158-95598D926B5A.png

why does LG’s flipping and flopping over this decision remind me of this Office scene for some reason haha
 
I have an 2018 LG SK series TV, and it's great. Great with the Apple TV 4K, and plays PS4 games with very little latency.

I'll be honest though, I bought the TV not expecting to receive any form of post-purchase support. If this does happen, it's a nice thing, but won't be the end of the world for me if it doesn't happen.
Although I agree with you with the buying without expecting much support, the problem is that even newer TVs didn't have AirPlay. AirPlay was opened by Apple so others could add it and LG decided to do that. This all started in 2019,
why would they not give it to very recent models?.
 
Apple support on TV’s is good but you still want an Apple TV if you purchase a lot of content as iTunes extra’s are not available on the TV app. i don’t think this is mentioned enough.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: TimB21
You don't need an Apple TV anymore. It's an App directly on the TV, like netflix.
I do know what you mean, but because I prefer premium experiences, I'd still get an Apple TV.

First for the bigger and better quality app ecosystem, second for the huge amount of power as compared to TVs, third because it's going to receive "major" upgrades for a longer period than any TV, and fourth the Apple TV's navigation is better than most if not all TVs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ssspinball
...fourth the Apple TV's navigation is better than most if not all TVs.

That's a matter of opinion. I have an AppleTV in my kitchen and an LG OLED in my lounge. For me, I find WebOS and the pointer remote a far better user experience than TVOS with Apple's horrible scroll-y remote. It's just a personal thing, so everyone will have their own opinion.

I have to agree with you about most other TV's. WebOS is the shining light in a sea of utter mediocrity in the TV world.
 
That's a matter of opinion. I have an AppleTV in my kitchen and an LG OLED in my lounge. For me, I find WebOS and the pointer remote a far better user experience than TVOS with Apple's horrible scroll-y remote. It's just a personal thing, so everyone will have their own opinion.

I have to agree with you about most other TV's. WebOS is the shining light in a sea of utter mediocrity in the TV world.
I know what you mean, I have an LG with webOS and the pointer remote too, and honestly, it's extremely solid. I love it.

This is why I added most other TVs, I still remember trying a few others before buying this one, and I found webOS to be by far the best TV OS out there. Between tvOS and webOS, it'll only be a matter of taste.
[automerge]1599569008[/automerge]
WebOS is the shining light in a sea of utter mediocrity in the TV world.
I couldn't have said it better. 😄
 
HomeKit support isn't even that good on the C9. About a third of the time it doesn't even show up as recognized.
 
Well, partially. There are still some big plusses to having an Apple TV box ...
As my TV has a PLEX app I'm wondering if I should go down that road for my local library instead.

I was doing some testing yesterday and I find that Plex on my Apple TV 4K has fewer issues streaming a 4K movie than the native Plex app on my OLEDB8. Better network card, I guess. So yeah, I'd say that's another definite advantage to having some sort of dedicated box.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ssspinball
Uh why? The no signal message is there for a useful purpose, to indicate there is no signal of course.
It doesn’t need to be shown all the time. It ruins the wallpaper on the TV. Also, it’s pretty obvious that there’s no signal when the wallpaper comes on. I see no reason why LG can’t give us the option to switch this message off
 
It doesn’t need to be shown all the time. It ruins the wallpaper on the TV. Also, it’s pretty obvious that there’s no signal when the wallpaper comes on. I see no reason why LG can’t give us the option to switch this message off
I see no reason to watch the TV with no input signal.
 
Well, regardless of how it happened, I'm very glad HomeKit is coming to my 2018 C8. AirPlay & + are bonuses as I have a dedicated AppleTV. The LG software is great, far better than Android or Roku, IMO, but the hardware on the AppleTV is just worlds better, going back to the LG WebOS feels laggy and slow. The magic wand and tile based UI is slick (honestly better than the Apple Magic Remote) but even at almost 4 years old, the A10X runs circles around the LG SOC.
Our experience with LG's magic wand has been absolutely terrible. The lag is maddening, especially changing inputs (which other remotes can't perform because LG implemented it in such a non-standard way). I would never buy another LG without verifying inputs can also be changed by mashing buttons. YMMV.
 
Our experience with LG's magic wand has been absolutely terrible. The lag is maddening, especially changing inputs (which other remotes can't perform because LG implemented it in such a non-standard way). I would never buy another LG without verifying inputs can also be changed by mashing buttons. YMMV.
I'm sorry to hear that. To be fair, I use just the AppleTV via the Apple Remote (HDMI-CEC to control the TV/amp) 99% of the time but we exclusively used the LG interface when we first go the TV. It would occasionally act up but I never like you're describing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: John.B
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.