andym172 said:
There is one positive IF they don't allow us entry, and that is that we shall forever be Undefeated Champions
That is very true!
I agree with you on all points, and that eventually UEFA should change the rule to allow the champions to defend the title independently of their league performance -and I would extend the privilege to the uefa cup winner- (this would be from the lowest entry point if they don't qualify normally), but i am not sure it should be changed this year on the fly.
truth to be said, all major tournaments (including the World Cup) moved away from automatic holder berth, though i'm not sure why.
I mean, the (new) UEFA CL rules were always very clear: 4 teams max per country, including title defender, selected by the national federation. This has been in place for a while with everyone's blessing and a lot of pressure from thee smaller federations (I am sure that when spanish teams were not awarded 5 spots 3 ys ago, not too many other european teams/leagues complained).
So it
was down to the FA to decide. and until a few months ago (and clearly stated last year) the provision that they were 3+1 spots was there. Only very recently they clarified that the premiership was the only deciding factor, and I suspect that there was some degree of political gamble in the sense that they thought they could
de facto force UEFA to add one spot if Liverpool won. It looks they might be right in this, but that means someone will be wronged (in addition it offsets the league ranking system in favour of -in this case- england, unless they move to even more baroque point system).
As mentioned in the earlier post, I think the 'less unfair' way (to LFC, everton and the other teams) could be to have LFC enter at the first round, and then simply make it a rule that in the third, when everton is up, they play each other. And then this would become the permanent way to deal with non-qualified title holders. This would ensure no more than 4 english teams (but at least 3

) in the group stage, decided by the field.
Or UEFA could save one (or two) wild card spot to be assigned to the highest uefa-ranked non-qualified team (indipendently of league quota)
What do you think?